4 ms·
If you read between the lines you may see something. The F-35 still sucks at air-air combat. Period. But if you use its radar and software systems to feed tacti
by phkahler 10y ago
If you read between the lines you may see something. The F-35 still sucks at air-air combat. Period. But if you use its radar and software systems to feed tactical data to the "real fighters" the team becomes extremely lethal. So it's still a giant money sink and they should probably just retrofit some of the older planes with those more advanced info systems.
- alkonaut 10y agoWithin visual range air-air combat. It's designed for BVR combat (although it's suffering from a lack of very long range weapons like the Meteor at this point). Older planes are always retrofitted with more systems, that's what the su-30/35 is (on the Su 27 platform) and similarly for super hornet, late block F-16s etc. The problem is that those airframes are decades old and there comes a point when the power and cooling requirements just don't fit in the old frame any more.
- jandrese 10y agoThe old airframes are also not stealthy, which is a pretty important perk for BVR combat. Getting better missiles isn't much help if you don't know where to put them.
- alkonaut 10y agoI'm pretty sceptical about the value of stealth apart from being able to operate in contested airspace (read: attack). It's an advantage in BVR because of detection ranges etc but I'm not sure the stealth design is the most cost effective one for all those countries (probably) buying the F-35 without ever having to do "power projection" and instead will do territorial defense. Japan, Australia, Norway, Denmark, Canada(?) I think would probably have been better off with a non stealth design.
- wbl 10y agoAn invasion force attacking Japan will have seaborne and mobile anti-air capabilities which will need to be neutralized before using aircraft to attack the force. Ideally for Japan their islands aren't even touched.
- na85 10y ago> Canada(?) We're buying Super Hornets as an "interim measure" for reasons passing understanding.
- neurotech1 10y agoActually, the Super Hornet has quite low frontal RCS. If it was configured with low-RCS pylons and carefully selected weapons load it would be close to "stealth". The jet isn't operated that way by the USN who fly them loaded with large bombs.
- na85 10y ago>The F-35 still sucks at air-air combat It was never going to be good at air-to-air. It's a strike fighter by name, which means it's intended to be basically an A-10 that can also do some air-to-air in a pinch. There's a reason they operate the F-22 in the air superiority role.
- bluthru 10y ago>basically an A-10 that can also do some air-to-air in a pinch With four seconds of bullets? https://defensetech.org/2015/01/02/a-tale-of-two-gatling-guns-f-35-vs-a-10/ https://defensetech.org/2015/01/02/a-tale-of-two-gatling-gun...
- na85 10y agoIt's designed to engage from well beyond the ranges at which guns are effective. I'm not necessarily saying I agree with the choice of gun armament, but... yeah.
- phkahler 10y agoNo, it was meant to replace everything else.