3 ms·
Well, college is "different" (to put it mildly). My theory is colleges are, in effect, selling a positional good[1], one whose value depends on its ranking rel
by SilasX 10y ago
Well, college is "different" (to put it mildly).
My theory is colleges are, in effect, selling a positional good[1], one whose value depends on its ranking relative to other goods. People go there to prove that they are in the nth percentile by some desirable quality.
Positional goods providers behave like monopolists when (the perception of) that ranking can't easily change, and buyers place extreme importance on being in the nth percentile.
To compare back to the rebar example, if a buyer had to get rebar from a top 3 provider (rather than simply "rebar above X psi strength etc"), and the top 3 never changed, you'd probably see the same effect, and they would simply raise prices with every subsidy.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positional_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positional_good
- xyzzyz 10y agoBut the healthcare is not like this, and neither is housing: going to a better doctor is a very weak status signal, and while some people do spend a lot of money on housing to signal their status, for average person the function of their house or apartment is to provide roof over their head.
- SilasX 10y agoFair enough, but these don't all have to have the same cause (except maybe in a very abstract sense).
- abakker 10y agoDon't you look for the best doctor when choosing healthcare? Often, the best doctors cost more money since they have limited time. Spending more on housing is difficult because the location component of a house usually effects the price as much or more as the quality/size of the house itself.