4 ms·
I wonder if a side effect of WebM will be to push Ogg Vorbis into wider adoption? Platforms that want to play WebM will also decode Ogg, so why not support the
by stcredzero 17y ago
I wonder if a side effect of WebM will be to push Ogg Vorbis into wider adoption? Platforms that want to play WebM will also decode Ogg, so why not support the audio-only format?
- jon_dahl 17y agoDefinitely. Vorbis is a good codec, too, so this is a win for everyone.
- naner 17y agoWill this also open up Vorbis for patent suits? If MP3 is covered by over 100 patents then Vorbis is probably a ripe target.
- mbrubeck 17y agoVorbis has been around for over a decade now, and incorporated into numerous products with no successful patent threats yet. Xiph.org conducted a patent search and believes Vorbis does not infringe on any patents. And since US patents expire in 17 to 20 years, there is a shrinking body of patents that could be used against Vorbis.
- jrockway 17y agoIncidentally, the last MP3 patent expires in 2017.
- vetinari 17y agoThat hard to believe, as MP3 was standardized in 1989. Didn't you mean AAC?
- mbrubeck 17y agoNo, apparently he does mean MP3, but don't ask me how a patent filed in 1997 covers a standard that was finalized in 1991. (Was there a delay between date of invention and date of application, maybe involving provisional patents? I do not know the details of these things.) http://www.tunequest.org/a-big-list-of-mp3-patents/20070226/ http://www.tunequest.org/a-big-list-of-mp3-patents/20070226/
- pbiggar 16y agoThere is generally a delay between patents being filed and issues. I've heard of a number of very long waits before. (I'm not an expert at all.)
- jmillikin 17y agoI hope it does, but believe it won't. Much like Theora, the primary reason to oppose Vorbis is political. It's not covered by patents and doesn't support DRM, so to content providers it's a significantly worse codec than MP3 or AAC. If Apple or Microsoft were going to support Vorbis, they'd have done so years ago.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoNot to detract from your general point, but Ogg and Vorbis support DRM to the same degree that any other container and codec do, it's generally an orthogonal concern. It's main problem is network effects, in cases where network effects don't apply, e.g. game audio and web streaming audio, it has longe been used by big names such as Microsoft and Spotify. There is now no reason for it not to be the standard for web audio, since you can even fall back to Vorbis in Flash 8 via a non-native decoder. It's also likely to get a boost in the pirate video market, even when paired with H.264 as a result of WebM introduction. It really could become mainstream for a variety of uses. The biggest drawback in the last few years has been the lack of support in iPods. It will be interesting to see if Apple chooses to prevent you playing Vorbis audio on your iPod Touch even if it caves and allows it for web audio.