7 ms·
This deserves a better, less clickbaity (which I think has the opposite to intended affect with this audience) title. Particularly towards the end, s/he comes
by OJFord 10y ago
This deserves a better, less clickbaity (which I think has the opposite to intended affect with this audience) title.
Particularly towards the end, s/he comes across extremely self-aware, and makes some salient points around the state of school CS education in the UK. It certainly resonated with my experience.
- dcole2929 10y agoI agree. It says a lot about society that someone who has clearly found his thing, due to some admittedly poor decision on his/her part, has basically zero options with which to pursue his interests in a controlled environment. I'm not from the UK so I will refrain from commenting on the state of their education system, but I've definitely seen this scenario play out here in the states. I'm not an educator but it's obvious that people are slipping through the cracks and that's something that should be deeply disturbing to most.
- noir_lord 10y ago> I'm not from the UK so I will refrain from commenting on the state of their education system. Fucked until Uni and not great then.
- vvanders 10y agoThat was actually the genesis around the Raspberry Pi. Eben Upton was really frustrated with the state of CS education in the UK(from what I recall it was mix of Excel and "computer skills"). The RPi was intended to be low cost computer that kids could hack on similar to what happened with the C64 back in the day.
- OJFord 10y agoYes, and not forgetting the micro:bit too. I'm glad it's being worked on, and I'm sure it will be better for those going through now - but if the subject of this post is in 'high school', s/he had none of that. We had 'ICT', in which we learnt to operate Microsoft products.
- DaiPlusPlus 10y agoYup - though all the class literature was careful to use generic names like "spreadsheet software package" instead of naming Excel. We did get some exposure to other platforms though - we were taught about the existence of Netscape Navigator in 2001 - but naturally school computer policy meant we couldn't actually install it to use it. The worst part about my school's IT classes was how we were supposed to officially document our progress by taking a screenshot of the work we did, printing it out, cutting it out with scissors and sticking it into our classbooks with PVA glue - like right out of primary school. The fact we were doing this right into Yr.10 just felt insulting - and surely a better demonstration of IT proficiency would be to maintain our work-logs in a purely electronic format? Isn't using a backwards format like (literally) pasted-in screenshots the antithesis of information technology?
- DaiPlusPlus 10y ago"Excel and computer skills" isn't CS - it's "ICT" which does not pretend to be computer science. When ICT as part of the curriculum in the early 1990s I think the country was doing the right thing - computer skills beyond using Facebook are essential and too many people still don't understand how spreadsheets work. In the UK you can do proper Computer Science in high-school at A-Level (ages 16-18), I did it myself - I'd describe it as a somewhat cut-down version of my undergraduate computer-science degree: we did briefly cover the basics of fundamental computer architecture, formal logic and logic-gates, database theory, and software development - the problem is that very few schools actually offer the subject (like 90% of schools offer ICT at A-Level, but I reckon less than 50% offer Computer Science) - and that's due to the staffing: if you can teach Computer Science for A-Level then you're going to be qualified to work as a software developer for a multiple of a typical teacher's salary. My only real criticism of A-Level Computer Science (at least when I did it) was that schools could choose between Pascal/Delphi, VB6, and Java - my school chose VB6 - possibly the worst possible choice considering both how antiquated it was (this was in the mid-2000s so VB.NET/C# were already well-established) but also, more importantly, how it's a poor tool for computer science because VB6 lacks class inheritance and instills bad habits (e.g. SQL concatenation). When I worked at Microsoft in the US, they took part in a programme called "TEALS" where professional software engineers employed by MS and other companies (Amazon, Facebook, Google all have Seattle offices) are invited to teach high-school AP class computer science classes part time, and I understand it's proving to be quite successful. I think this system should be expanded to allow other industries to take part - I'd sure love to have given chemical engineering or architecture a try in high-school - and kids often need decent exposure to industry if they've yet to decide what they'll do at university and beyond.
- FLUX-YOU 10y ago>has basically zero options with which to pursue his interests in a controlled environment No way, he could easily get his own lab in AWS and probably for not much cost since he is in Uni. Hell, buying used stuff from ebay or some other auction site and hacking those for legitimate research would also be a path. Medical devices are probably low effort, high reward. I definitely get where he's coming from with not having peers interested in security. Message boards and chats only do so much, but there's ample knowledge out there to build a plan for how you want your life to go from this upbringing. Going to a few conventions (even alone) would probably do wonders for him in terms of making connections but those can be expensive.
- ihatestylometry 10y agoI wholeheartedly agree! And you put it way better than me. Maybe we're missing something here, but I got the impression that this is an incredible time for talented people. I've learned all about hacking online - kernel hacking, remote exploits, DEP/ASLR bypass techniques, Kali Linux for penetration testing, exploit-db.com and Metasploit for inspiration, the great tutorials of corelan.be and other great minds and so much more - it's all there, readily available for free. You don't even need a big budget to build a controlled environment - Raspberry Pi's, maybe some cheap routers and computers and you're ready to go.
- OJFord 10y ago> AWS and probably for not much cost since he is in Uni What? S/He said s/he's in secondary school. You can get certain AWS products for zero cost, for a year, but you need a .ac.uk or equivalent email address.
- ihatestylometry 10y agoHe's way too young for this attitude. I've hacked things in my teenage years too and was obsessed with hacking for many years before I started to do freelance work - the feeling of being superior is a common problem for all types of skills if you're young, no matter what, so he definitely shares wisdom with his last paragraphs. But I don't think the problem is not that society has problems finding interesting challenges for highly skilled young people like him. It's unfortunate his school doesn't have hackathons and other activities, but he's not dependent on such circumstances. I think his problem is that he doesn't recognize that he's in full control of his life. I've talked with several security researchers who hack IoT gadgets and other things for a living - they write their own ROP chains, hack web applications and test software for airlines with very high security standards - and they told me that they take every talent they can get. They're getting 4 to 5-digit daily rates for penetration test gigs and are well-respected. So there's demand and there are great people who want to share their knowledge. So my question: Instead of hacking printers, why not talk to companies who are searching for his talent? I'm not defending the current state of CS education, it's really bad and decoupled from reality, but it's no excuse for gifted people to give up and justify blackhat hacking - which is just another word for being criminal. Edit: Absolutely agree on the click-baity title!
- cblock811 10y ago> He's way too young for this attitude I've always found these kind of comments unusual. How old is old enough? For me this usually came off as arrogant. > the feeling of being superior is a common problem for all types of skills if you're young I know plenty of people who still have that exhibit that sort of behavior in pretty much every age bracket. Arrogance doesn't correlate to age. It's kind of arrogant to say "You cant think that way, you're too young" too.
- ihatestylometry 10y agoIt's just sad to see that he's already so negative about his options. My comment wasn't about how old one has to be to justify his negativism, I'm sorry if it came across as such. I can relate to his feelings and it makes me sad, this is all I meant with this sentence.
- dom96 10y agoCompletely agree. It resonated with my experience as well. Over my high school years I was incredibly frustrated by the things I was taught in ICT GCSE and ICT A Level (at the time there was no computing GCSE/A level offered by my high school). And even now, I'm studying for a BSc in Computer Science and I'm surrounded by people who probably can't write a hello world application without getting help from a TA. I find the state of things really ridiculous and I wonder whether all UK universities are like this. What frustrates me the most is when my professors are seemingly putting a cap on my grades. It feels like they are pushing everyone who is lagging behind up (past the 40% pass mark) and everyone who's doing exceptionally well down (towards the 70% mark). I'm guessing that it makes sense to retain as many students as they can and at the same time ensure that the course isn't too easy, but it seems incredibly unfair. Also, what is up with the grading system? A "first" is 70%+, and as soon as you achieve that as an average you're indistinguishable from anybody else.
- ihatestylometry 10y agoThe education system prioritizes that all students have a baseline knowledge above all else. It's not the goal to incentivize high achievers using a hard scoring system, because this'll prevent the success of others who aren't good in educational settings - and there is a group of people who are incredible programmers, but lack the skills to get good grades. If you're really good, you have remarkably good grades and do interesting projects in your spare time. w.r.t. your understanding of unfair: Don't compare yourself to fellow students, because they are by definition average. If you want to profit from your advantage: do stuff, get connected with great minds, build projects. This will get you years ahead of your fellow students who are busy passing the exams. What about this incredibly unfair advantage? ;)
- runeblaze 10y agoI hate when talent does not get distinguished. Nonetheless the time spent chasing the busy-work to get an A in US CS courses seems more detrimental to personal projects and interests... I wish I could just get a cutoff at 80% and just not worry anymore.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jimmaswell 10y agoSame problem in the US. Compsci education has been an absolute joke at both colleges I've been to (a community college then state university). The entire thing can feel downright fraudulent at times when you're writing yet another crappy implementation of merge sort in Java as part of a class you're taking one semester before graduating and your classmate can't figure out why their class with all the fields marked as static doesn't work when two instances are made of it. I haven't had to extend an iota beyond bare minimal effort to get any of my A's in compsci classes. It's almost always been the "professor" just checking that your program gives the right output but making you print it out anyway so they can draw a checkmark on it or some other horse baloney. At least I've been able to get real experience doing things on my own.