3 ms·
> It is a tacit acceptance of the falsehood that there is a skills shortage. The entire premise of the H1-B program is that there is a skills shortage. It's no
by koolba 10y ago
> It is a tacit acceptance of the falsehood that there is a skills shortage.
The entire premise of the H1-B program is that there is a skills shortage. It's not specific to IT, it can be used for any field where you cannot find local talent.
> It ultimately relies on scarcity of visas. There will be a number of visas to auction off and this number will become a political football that is tweaked and tweaked until it is meaningless. What is the point of an auction if there are a million visas being auctioned off?
There's already a number of visas auctioned off. I don't see how the number is any more or less political if it changes to an auction based on salary.
> It does not address the corporate/education institution partnership loophole.
I don't know what you're referring to here. Please explain.
> Ultimately if they are the best and brightest the visas should be given to the employee not the employer and, if the employee wants, they should be put on a fast track to a green card as soon as they start (6 mo-1 year)
The visa already goes to the employee, not the employer. H1-B visa holders can move jobs if the new company is willing to take over the H1-B sponsorship (I think it's just a bunch of paperwork).
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The entire premise of the H1-B program is that there is a skills shortage And it's a bad program even if that was true, since at best it's a band aid that papers over short-term symptoms without addressing underlying problems, and since it is perennially used in the same industries for the same types of jobs, it's clear that if it is addressing a skills shortage, it's not a transitory, short-term problem for which a short-term patch to cover up symptoms is the appropriate response. Either no one involved in making policy has noticed this, or "skills shortage" isn't the actual reason for the policy.