I wouldn't call 5mbps "perfectly fine", but I could do basic web browsing and email etc. And that's my point. I don't want to be shaped down to a barely-usable

I wouldn't call 5mbps "perfectly fine", but I could do basic web browsing and email etc. And that's my point. I don't want to be shaped down to a barely-usable connection. Why do they need to shape at all? The only argument is congestion. And if there's congestion, they should shape us down to a reasonable level like 5mbps. No reason it should be all or nothing, 35Mbit or zero.