4 ms·
As the embedded video alludes, it's not that revolutionary an idea to pool transactions and use local resources to fulfill more cheaply if possible. That said,
by kbenson 10y ago
As the embedded video alludes, it's not that revolutionary an idea to pool transactions and use local resources to fulfill more cheaply if possible.
That said, the world is full of wildly successful companies that just executed well on not very revolutionary ideas, and they provide real value that was largely absent before they grew to prominence. Sometimes it's not about doing something new, it's about doing it well, or doing it in a way that allows more people access.
- jlg23 10y agoOr, in the case of international money transfer: They see through the existing system and just openly do what most banks have been doing all the time behind the scenes, passing most of the savings to the customer. The only problem I see with this specific business model: As soon as enough people use it, this method of transfer will be the norm and all the big banks will offer it too, thereby invalidating the justification for the existence of the new players. (Mind you, still a great win for the customer!)
- lumberjack 10y ago>The only problem I see with this specific business model: As soon as enough people use it, this method of transfer will be the norm and all the big banks will offer it too, thereby invalidating the justification for the existence of the new players. Yes exactly what I was thinking. But by that time Transferwise could be a reputable brand with lots of customers so they could pivot to offer other financial services.
- RangerScience 10y agoAnd almost certainly better tech. You ever check out the OS your bank is running?
- jlg23 10y agoHonestly, I don't care whether I am driven over by a Porsche Cayenne or a Willys MB. And while I have not worked in the banking sector myself, lots of my friends did - and it was not cobol. They are catching up and they all know that their mainframe sw is dated and act upon it. I don't think the "quality" of the tech is of any relevance here. EDIT: Well, I actually know some guys who bit the bullet and learned cobol when they were just turning 20. By the time they turned 30, they did not have to work anymore.
- mastazi 10y ago> and it was not cobol And if it was, personally, I wouldn't have a problem as a customer.
- bloopalert 10y agoIt's cobol.
- jomkr 10y agoI'd have 100% more trust in a system written in COBOL than node.js.
- joe563323 10y agoBut it is currently maintained by the new nodejs devs who figured maintaining COBOL pays greater.
- saiya-jin 10y agoBanks run all kinds of stuff - never seen AS400 mainframe at the bank (but some for example in Renault), but plenty of 15-20 year old systems. I consider SAP a legacy system that should be avoided/pushed out at all costs, but that's personal opinion. And guess what - in many cases those old systems work extremely well. if you can integrate with it via Java or similar, then there is no good enough reason to upgrade. I've seen plenty of projects pitched as salvation to customers, when at the end the customer needed 3x the amount of people to support it, wasted ton if time and money putting new 'cool' tech in, which just brought its own set of problems. True added long-term value for customer was minimal.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> You ever check out the OS your bank is running? Does it matter? I don't care what Fidelity, Vanguard, etc run under the hood, I have no loyalty nor switching costs. Vanguard's interface is garbage, plain and simple, but they have the lowest cost index funds; I'd use paper and pen to correspond with them if necessary. I moved from Betterment, who has a very delightful iOS app and web interface, because the fees were lower at Vanguard.
- kriro 10y agoIdeally this is solved by positioning. Since they are associated with this concept it should be hard to copy as long as they executed it well, even if (or especially if) it's copied by a huge traditional banking brand (e.g. a British bank). At the very least they should be positioned well for a buyout (as that's likely the best way of going about it by a traditional bank).
- csomar 10y agoI don't think it's possible without significant restructuring (for banks). They have huge costs that TransferWise is avoiding.
- elastic_church 10y agosometimes you say? it is always about execution being passionate about things that nobody wants, and disrupting things nobody cares about will get you nowhere. a low margin grocery store fulfills a need and thats why they are everywhere.
- phil21 10y agoIdeas are utterly worthless. Execution is everything. I freely give every single idea (some actually valuable!) I've ever had away for free. Because I know if someone is better at implementing it than I am, they are the ones who provided the world value. Not me for dreaming it up and then doing nothing about it - there are millions of me's, and ideas without execution are not interesting.
- nostalgiac 10y ago>Ideas are utterly worthless. >I freely give every single idea (some actually valuable!) A solid contradiction ;) But I understand your intentions.
- yellowbeard 10y agoI guess value and worth can have subtlety different meanings
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- phil21 10y agoHa. Good point :)
- elastic_church 10y agoI give most of my ideas away, since I've ruled them out as not being optimal uses of my own time. I've done the teeth pulling NDA and noncompetes with a lot of people, just so they would tell me their original idea that I'm contractually bound not to copy for a limited time in a limited geographic area or tell anyone about. And I realized how unoriginal all of them are. If they weren't so concerned about people copying their idea they would have gotten feedback on it a lot sooner for the simple answer of "Hey, Spotify does this already, did you check the menu options?" running completely counter to their market research and conclusion that "nobody" is doing this and its "huge".
- nickpsecurity 10y agoFor an example, FedEx established the business model of paying extra to get something there sooner in a high-volume, economical way. It's always been there in a custom, luxury form despite the early doubters acting like it was a dumb idea entirely. Fred Smith and company just executed it very well vs all prior attempts. Billions in income followed.
- dmoo 10y agoLike Drucker said, there is efficiency and effectiveness. When you do both it's a good outcome.
- mstade 10y agoI use this service all the time when I need to transfer cash,. It's simpler than using a bank, often faster, and almost universally cheaper. The idea is old as dirt, but execution is everything, and boy do they execute well.