6 ms·
I'm sorry, in what way did I second guess vets? I'm not making any special pleading here, the guardian piece is backed up by publications from the British Vete
by Nursie 10y ago
I'm sorry, in what way did I second guess vets?
I'm not making any special pleading here, the guardian piece is backed up by publications from the British Veterinary Association. I'm not impugning any vets, it looks like the entire profession is moving this way in the UK.
You're reading things into my argument which just aren't there, and what's more it feels like you haven't fully read the article.
- tptacek 10y agoOnce again: we discussed the issues of our breed in detail with our vet. Our vet, I think you can infer, does not agree with this advocacy piece. Your argument depends on the notion that only the veterinarians who agree with you are qualified to voice opinions. That's special pleading. It's not a complicated point. Also: please stop suggesting that commenters haven't read the article.
- Nursie 10y agoI can't infer anything, what did your vet say? What do you think the article is advocating? Because AFAICT it's not euthanasia, it's to stop supporting breeders in their quest for ever 'cuter' brachycephaly.
- tptacek 10y agoI know the article isn't advocating euthanasia. I think that, too, is a flaw in the logic of the article. I think it's totally fine to exhort people who don't have strong dog preferences to select non-compromised dogs. It also makes sense to me to advocate rescues. We own a rescue, too. Where you lose me is when you suggest that it's unethical to purchase a purebred dog. Acquiring a rescue when you have a preference for a purebred puppy is an ethically positive action. I think few people here would disagree with that. The fallacy in your argument is that the positive outcome of acquiring a rescue does not automatically imply that a acquiring a purebred is ethically negative; it can be --- and I think usually is --- ethically neutral.
- Nursie 10y agoNo, I'm suggesting to you that it is unethical to breed dogs that will suffer predictable, known, severe health problems. Further that purchasing from such breeders is also unethical.
- tptacek 10y agoI understand that to be your argument. I'm saying, you haven't made a coherent case for it.