5 ms·
> Where is the evidence that make homosexuality was largely considered acceptable or normal by before the early 1950s? To be clear, the article's not saying th
by rsynnott 10y ago
> Where is the evidence that make homosexuality was largely considered acceptable or normal by before the early 1950s?
To be clear, the article's not saying that male homosexuality was largely considered normal. It's saying that having sex with men was not considered abnormal, which is a bit different. I think this is probably a bit of an oversimplification, but certainly, men who had sex with men would have been less inclined to think of themselves as different at the time than now.
- dpark 10y agoI have trouble buying that claim. In a world where gay sex happens but isn't acknowledged, I don't see how people engaging in gay sex would consider it "normal". As if it became "abnormal" only when we started labeling it consistently as homosexuality. Was "furry" sex also considered normal before we had a name for it? I can buy that men who had sex with men wouldn't consider themselves gay (or bisexual or whatever) because that wasn't really a recognized thing. That doesn't mean that the gay sex itself would have been considered "normal" even by the people engaged in it.
- wolfgang42 10y ago> Was "furry" sex also considered normal before we had a name for it? Yes, you could make the argument that it was (setting aside the question of how "furry sex" differs from "normal sex"). Consider the following quote from an article on Winston Churchill: > Like other lovers, they invented pet names for each other. Clementine was “Cat”, or “Kat”, Winston was “Pug”, then “Amber Pug”, then “Pig”. Drawings of these animals decorated the margins of their letters to each other, and at dinner parties Winston would reach across the table, squeeze her hand, and murmur “Dear Cat”. [...] > These were not one-offs, taken out of context. Due to Churchill’s odd schedule and frequent travels, he and his beloved Kat didn’t see much of each other, and even while living in the same house they wrote each other frequent letters. Practically all of them are full of love—and they’re equally full of what we today would recognize in a heartbeat as typical anthropomorphic on-line role-play. http://www.adjectivespecies.com/2012/12/28/blood-toil-tears-and-fur/ http://www.adjectivespecies.com/2012/12/28/blood-toil-tears-...
- foldr 10y agoYou can't really be comparing pet names based on animals to furry sex?
- wolfgang42 10y agoI glossed over this in the parent, but how exactly are you defining "furry sex"?
- foldr 10y agoPeople having sex while dressed in big furry animal suits.
- wolfgang42 10y agoThat's not nearly as common as you might think--among other things, it's a good way to ruin a several thousand dollar fursuit. (The best analogy I've heard is "Yes, there are furries who have sex in fursuits, but probably not more than people who have sex in space suits."[1]) The furry fandom is much less inhibited than general society--members tend to be willing to discuss sexual topics in a way that most people aren't. (This probably also accounts for the higher incidence of homosexuality[2], since it's not felt to be something that needs to be hidden.) However, the vast majority of furry-related sexual expression (as opposed to two people who happen to be furries having otherwise non-furry sexual relations) comes in the form of various types of media--published stories and images, but also private roleplay. In this regard, pet names based on animals are absolutely a part of "furry sex", certainly more so than dressing in animal suits during the act. 1: http://www.adjectivespecies.com/2015/08/29/yiff-murr-sex-in-the-furry-fandom/ http://www.adjectivespecies.com/2015/08/29/yiff-murr-sex-in-... 2: https://doi.org/10.1163/156853008X323376; https://doi.org/10.1163/156853008X323376; poorly-formatted PDF at https://archive.org/details/pdfy-vF2uQGRhrwdL1oe3 https://archive.org/details/pdfy-vF2uQGRhrwdL1oe3. "...they are less likely to be heterosexual compared to other males in the study."
- dpark 10y ago> Yes, you could make the argument that it was (setting aside the question of how "furry sex" differs from "normal sex"). Consider the following quote from an article on Winston Churchill I think you're answering a much different question than what I asked. You seem to be answering whether it existed before it had a name. I was asking whether it was normal before it had a name. I have no idea whether Churchill was actually a "furry" but I don't think giving it a name suddenly made it abnormal. To whatever extend "furry" behavior is normal or abnormal, it was the same before and after it had a name.