5 ms·
One thing I've wondered (and I hope this isn't an inflammatory question) is if a breed in dogs is analogous to race in humans? If that's wrong, does the idea of
by criddell 10y ago
One thing I've wondered (and I hope this isn't an inflammatory question) is if a breed in dogs is analogous to race in humans? If that's wrong, does the idea of breed have any human equivalent? Does race have any equivalent in dogs?
- ludamad 10y agoSeems like a fair question. Dogs seem very versatile. Dogs are apparently like neonatal wolves, can we breed neonatal humans?
- Asooka 10y agoHumans are neonatal humans. But also we cross-breed a lot. The exception would be certain royal families in centuries past and we all know how that ended up. Human races are a result of a process similar to dog breeds, but the differentiation is nowhere near the same.
- richmarr 10y agoWhat do you mean by neonatal in this instance? My use of that word would be 'relating to newborn babies'... so "can we breed neonatal humans" seems to imply a different usage?
- upvotinglurker 10y agoI think the word intended is "neotenous" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoteny https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoteny
- richmarr 10y agoTa
- Mikeb85 10y agoWell there are families that inherit hereditary disease, and inbreeding has been a problem in some communities in some eras, but it's always been far, far more localised than any culture or 'race'.
- Nursie 10y agoBreed in dogs is a product of selection by humans on dogs. So no, no real analogy.
- criddell 10y agoWhat about in communities that are basically closed by custom or by geography? Is how differences arise more important than the actual differences when it comes to talking about breed? I'm thinking about aboriginal communities, Pygmy peoples, or even groups like the Ashkenazis.
- pjc50 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_eugenics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_eugenics (It's the most inflammatory of questions!)
- snerbles 10y agoTo an extent, we can abstract dogs away as a thing we can categorize with detachment. To start categorizing humans in such a manner invites similar detachment, with the hazard of conclusions potentially being applied to people.
- Periodic 10y agoAll dogs can still interbreed, so they're still the same species. They're different enough from wolves that they're given a different sub-species, sort of like Homo Sapiens Sapiens and Homo Sapiens Neanderthalensis. However, the variety within domesticated dogs is similar to race. What makes dogs breeds so different is that the dog genome is extremely plastic: it has a lot of room for variation as evidenced by how far pugs have come from wolves, even though theoretically they can still mate and produce fertile offspring.
- richmarr 10y ago> What makes dogs breeds so different is that the dog genome is extremely plastic Is there evidence that dogs genome is more plastic than humans? To my (very limited) knowledge we've not tried selectively breeding humans within bloodlines in anywhere near the same way that breeds of dog have been selected. Are there other domestic animals that have recieved the same degree of breeding but not reached such variation?
- LordKano 10y agoIt's my understanding that breed in dogs would be more analogous to ethnicity in humans. Whereas certain breeds of dog are prone to developing certain medical conditions, like hip dysplasia or heart failure, certain ethnicities of human are more likely to develop certain medical conditions, like Tay-Sachs or Sickle Cell Anemia.
- csours 10y agoThis touches on Eugenics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics
- pwthornton 10y agoDog breeds would be the equilivent of small groups of humans with very small genetic diversity. Perhaps, a small, uncontacted tribe. The defining characteristic of pure breeds if selective inbreeding, essentially.