5 ms·
Apple, Adobe and Openness: Let's Get Real
- metachris 17y agoInteresting, insightful article. It portrays the story taking the early years of cooperation between Apple and Adobe into account. > I was working at Apple when this process happened, and I can tell you that it was searing. Apple had invested countless hours and dollars marketing those products as prominent reasons to buy Macs, and then we saw that investment turned against us when the apps were made available on Windows.
- stcredzero 17y agoIf Adobe had more of a clue, I'd feel more sympathetic. They have a track record of putting annoying marketing ahead of good software and the user experience.
- tomlin 17y agoI'm having a hard time thinking of a software company (who works for profit) that hasn't put annoying marketing ahead of good software or UX. Trendy hate tends to be very specific.
- stcredzero 17y agoIn today's world, you don't have to be specific, so much as aimed at the worst offenders. No one is sinless, but there is an order of magnitude difference between the least guilty and the most. My hate isn't trendy. It's born of experience. One day, I was tracing down some process eating up cycles after I installed an Adobe suite to read PDFs. Lo and behold, it's a VB script process in the background to promote some sort of integration marketdroid crap with MS Office. I stop using Adobe, and my PDF reading is faster and my machine has more cycles I can use.
- tomlin 17y ago> "I stop using Adobe, and my PDF reading is faster and my machine has more cycles I can use." Great. I agree that Adobe has some pretty shitty software. No doubt. My point is that Apple has some shitty software as well. iTunes comes to mind. --- Shitty Adobe software: "I stop using Adobe" Shitty Microsoft software: "I stopped using Micro$oft" Shitty Apple software: <insert external fault here>
- stcredzero 17y agoEither you can't see ahead one logical step, or didn't take the time. (or this is a game to make me type the obvious) For me, Shitty isn't a Boolean. It's a quantity or a qualitative assessment. I use Microsoft and Apple software because those particular examples haven't exceeded the threshold. Adobe is in a different league. Different order of magnitude, really. (And for the record, Mobile Me chased me off because it exceeded the threshold awhile back.)
- tomlin 17y agoTrouble is, you're talking about you. Who may be perfectly logical and make sound decisions in the software you use based on the quantified experience. I've used enough Adobe software to confidently say that all of their software is not shitty. In fact, a few tools are indispensable. Photoshop, Aftereffects, Premier come to mind. In this "Adobe vs. the world" motif, all I see is: Adobe the dirtbag, and Apple the renegade hero with faults that preclude their existence. I, for one, am sick of it. While some of it has plenty of merit, the rest of it is tea-bagging, Republican-style fact-swaying that results in false information and a false result. Due to the assumptions laid forth for the "greater cause", we end up with no resolve. Just a table of "how we feel about Adobe" to reference without the bother to verify any positions or information or learn any lessons going forward. The gang mob anti-Flash movement carries with it an original truth that no longer exists in it's current form. Which is: The Flash Player platform should be open. I tend to agree. But what we end up with is: Death to plug-in arch (a complete opposite of open-web, IMO), death to experimental UI, death to technique that exists outside of W3C. Not understanding that Flash compilers are open source. Not understanding that frameworks like Flash carry with it underestimated advantages to moving the web forward. This comment will likely get downvoted (if anyone even reads this far before deciding I am pro adobe) and some dude with a backhanded comment goes up. Logical? Nope. Trendy. Yes. We're not learning anything from Adobe nor is Adobe learning anything from their market. That's their problem, true. But it's 2010 and we're getting video in our browsers...finally. And the bad guy is Adobe. Think about that.
- yardie 17y agoI'd have more sympathy for Adobe if: - Visiting Youtube didn't result in all 8 bars on my menubar, representing my 3GHz CPU, shoot to 80%. - The developers that wrote the god forsakened CS4 installer got the same treatment as terrorists. - Products weren't being held in beta forever and shipped in a reasonable timeframe.
- stcredzero 17y agoI guess shipping stuff in beta is ok. (Google)
- raganwald 17y agoThere's an old quote attributed to Napoleon, "If you start to take Vienna, take Vienna." Adobe failed to take Vienna. Note to other tech companies: Don't declare your intention to take over the world; do it first and explain later. (By the way, this explains both Apple's strategy and Chinese foreign policy, but I digress.)
- DeusExMachina 17y agoVery good analysis of the relationship between the two companies and the goals of each one. But I disagree on this passage: As a PostScript developer you were welcome to work with Adobe's low-quality font technology, but Adobe refused to allow any developer to access its proprietary high-quality APIs. Sounds like something Apple would do, doesn't it? There are a lot of things I, as a developer, don't like in Apple decisions on iPhone development and App Store policies, but to my record I've never seen such a behavior from Apple. Apple does not deny developers to use high quality technologies for its platforms, apart of the private API, but that's another matter. So I might miss something, but in my opinion, if you work on an Apple platform you get from Apple all the technologies to work on it.
- watty 17y agoAnyone have a link to more info on "refusing to allow high quality technologies"? Seems like the author left out Adobe's reasoning.
- vetinari 17y agoNot a link, just what I remember. You are welcome to Google it ;). At the time, PostScript documents could use Type1 and Type3 fonts. Type3 fonts were basically bitmaps, anyone could create one. Type1 fonts were entirely different matter - they were nice outline fonts and there wasn't anything similar. The problem was, that Adobe didn't publish specification how to create such fonts. They wanted everyone wishing to publish a font to go through them (for a fee, of course; I cannot help myself but it reminds me Apple and their App Store). In the end, it didn't work. Microsoft and Apple joined and created TrueType. The Type1 format was reverse engineered. Later Adobe capitulated and joined MS with Apple to create OpenType, which is open and is superset of both T1 and TT.
- DrSprout 17y ago>Apple does not deny developers to use high quality technologies for its platforms, apart of the private API, but that's another matter. No, I'm pretty sure that's exactly the matter. Only Apple apps can multitask. It's an understandable design decision, but it's certainly a parallel. (And to be completely fair it's changing, but you're being intellectually dishonest.)
- DrSprout 17y agoI have to say, the Air applications I use regularly (Hulu and Pandora One) both work very well on Linux and Windows. They are kind of resource hogs, but then so is iTunes, so it's really a case of the pot calling the kettle black on the performance front too. When Apple does cross-platform, they're not really that good at it. Google and the FOSS community is fantastic at it, and Adobe is middling. Really, the primary thing that bothers me about Flash is the way it locks in my content. However, it's clear that I'm not getting the content served via Adobe Air without kill strings attached, so it's a symptom of a larger problem in the market, and not itself the source.
- tomlin 17y ago+1. Hooray for neutral-based perspectives and criticism.
- stcredzero 17y agoWhen Apple does cross-platform, they're not really that good at it. Google and the FOSS community is fantastic at it, and Adobe is middling. For some value of 'fantastic' which is close to meh. In general, the FOSS stuff that has zero-effort portability isn't the prettiest, especially when evaluated in terms of the native platform they're running on. The prettiest FOSS software is far from zero-effort portability. (Yes, this includes my own beloved Smalltalks.)
- leviathant 17y ago"Here's a list of some major PC software products. Do you know what they all have in common? They were first successful on Apple systems, and only later took off in the PC world." Call me crazy, but maybe the PC is easier to develop for. At least the software listed there is still available for the Mac. When Apple bought Emagic, production of the PC version of their digital audio workstation Logic ceased. I remember the year Photoshop's sales for PC were higher than Photoshop's sales on the Mac. More and more, the myth that Macs are better for creative software eroded. Nonetheless, it does basically boil down to philosophical differences. I'm still a big fan of my iPhone and will probably even get the iPhone HD (or whatever), but Apple's made it very difficult for me to transfer that enthusiasm to anything else they do.
- stcredzero 17y agoCall me crazy, but maybe the PC is easier to develop for. Not crazy, but maybe confused. Wouldn't market share be a better explanation? The profit motive is the primary motivation to develop for any platform. It easily trumps ease of development.
- vetinari 17y agoAt the time, Win32s/Win32 was definitely easier to develop for than MacOS classic. While Win16 was definitely very similar to MacOS classic, Win32 brought better multitasking and memory management, so developers could tell good bye to memory handles and locking/unlocking them. The tools for Win32 development were also better. There was a range of compilers and IDEs you could choose from (not only Microsoft, but also Borland or Watcom). For MacOS, you had the terrible Apple tools or Codewarrior kit. Note that the apps that were created on PC, never crossed to Mac (e.g. AutoCAD or 3D Studio). I'm not saying that PC market share was not primary motivator, but at the time, PCs were technically better.
- stcredzero 17y agoAFAIK "is" is present tense!
- 17y ago
- neovive 17y ago"Unfortunately, the development of those standards has been incredibly slow and political" I think this is a critical point. It appears that most large software companies participate in standards bodies, simply to look out for their own interests.
- raganwald 17y ago"The civil service was united in its desire to make sure that the common market didn't work. That's why we went into it." http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pIXH3-A8zMI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pIXH3-A8zMI
- jonhohle 17y agoWith the exception of Tamarin, I don't recognize any of Adobe's open source contributions (perhaps that's because I'm not a Flash developer). Apple on the other hand has released a lot of great software under open source licenses: WebKit, launchd, bonjour, Darwin, libdispatch, etc. Adobe calling Flash open compared to the corpus of actually open software that Apple has produced is disingenuous, in my opinion.
- vetinari 17y agoOn the other hand, Apple had to release WebKit, due to KHTML license (the same for CUPS). Other Apple open source software has exactly zero adoption outside OSX, which is also a reason why they are open source. Apple knew they will be not adopted.
- glhaynes 17y agoI believe some substantial chunks of Apple open source (Grand Central Dispatch and LLVM) have been or are being adopted by FreeBSD. I'm not sure how much, though, these are part of the FreeBSD project itself.
- Tamerlin 17y ago"A platform vendor is responsible for articulating exactly what developers will and will not be permitted to do, before they invest time and money." Apple has a history of being very capricious about that.