8 ms·
I can understand that a company wants to do away with the distraction of having to worry about running a datacentre but is using one of the major cloud services
by cm2187 10y ago
I can understand that a company wants to do away with the distraction of having to worry about running a datacentre but is using one of the major cloud services cheaper than running your own? Amazon and Microsoft seem to be making healthy profits off their cloud services. That's part of your cost.
Now it may be that even if more expensive, it is a better use of your capital (renting instead of owning so that you can invest your capital in higher return investments like hiring better people). But is it cheaper, at an equivalent level of service / redundancy?
- rubber_duck 10y ago>Amazon and Microsoft seem to be making healthy profits off their cloud services. That's part of your cost. Only if you can do it more efficiently than them. If they are more efficient then they can make a profit and you still save money.
- throwaway13337 10y agoOnly if they are so efficient that after they get their cut, it's still more efficient than rolling your own. Because these cloud services have inherent lock-in, they don't have enough incentive to keep margins low. Indeed, Amazon's margins are extremely high after factoring in bandwidth costs.
- cm2187 10y agoAgree, but that's my question. Does the savings achieved by these cloud providers more than offset their margin, or is the motivation to move to the cloud solely a return on capital / removing a distraction?
- acqq 10y agoIt seems that their motivation was enabling the use the "machine learning" as they say or the "Big Data Analytics" as the user threeseed recognized in his post here.
- fuzzybeard 10y agoReminds me of the "buying locally grown food" argument that's premised on the assumption that buying locally grown food requires less carbon emissions because the food doesn't have to be transported from far away. HOWEVER that argument ignores that even after factoring in transportation, those larger industrial farms are farm more efficient than your local farm. So even with transportation the industrially sourced food might be more carbon efficient.
- eicnix 10y agoFirst of all it is important to understand that building/running your own cloud isn't only huge investment and high risk but also comes high cost of opportunity because every cent you spend in infrastructure you hope will be cheaper is not spend to increase the real value of your product. Not making this investment until your organisation and IT are "cloud-ready" decreases this risk. I have seen companies invest more than double the cost of a cloud provider to build their own cloud without having access to the features that a public cloud provider provides. For me the questions come down to the proportion of resources to revenue and how "cloud-ready" you are.
- yourapostasy 10y agoHm, but how much of those features they don't have access to would actually be used? After a few decades in the trenches, I've come to (mostly, kind of) accept that on average, most companies do not push the leading edge, and settle for relatively baseline feature sets of all of the software they use. As long as a deployment hits those feature points, they don't aggressively push for learning, testing, deploying and using new features. This is of interest to me because no matter how I slice it, when analyzed from this "baseline feature" perspective, cloud solutions of conventional software that require deploying upon conventional platforms are expensive, and I figure I must be missing the picture. I'm much more excited about cloud solutions like AWS Lambda that de novo solutions are built around, as those do seem to have more promise delivering the much-talked-about 2-10X cost improvements compared to conventional software, but still at a high cost of vendor lock-in due to lack of cloud API standards adoption by vendors.
- eicnix 10y agoThere were a lot of basic features missing. After 2 years of initial Openstack deployment there was no DNSaaS available and the loadbalancer solution was very unstable. This was partly caused by the organisation because nobody knew how to build a cloud system and first first few iterations of this private cloud were build like traditional bare metal infrastructure. If the investment for the private cloud had been used to adapt a public cloud provider for all non critical applications the benefit of the organisation would be greater. There are tools like Kubernetes / Mesos that can help abstract the infrastructure layer so you can move between different providers. I have seen kubernetes federations setups between kubernetes clusters on AWS and kubernetes clusters that were hosted inhouse.
- threeseed 10y agoIf all you are using Amazon/Microsoft for is EC2 style hosting then yes it's expensive. But if you are interested in Big Data Analytics as well (as Evernote would be) then it is a bargain. It is very expensive to run your own managed Hadoop cluster, build the data ingestion and scheduling components, event store, NoSQL store, machine/deep learning pipelines not to mention AI technologies and have them all integrated and cohesively packaged.
- acqq 10y ago> if you are interested in Big Data Analytics as well (as Evernote would be) They seem to call it "machine learning" "to help you get the most out of your Evernote experience." https://techcrunch.com/2016/12/14/evernotes-new-privacy-policy-allows-employees-to-read-your-notes/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/12/14/evernotes-new-privacy-poli... As one author once wrote "Whenever a company says 'In order to serve you better', you can be pretty sure they're about to do something that will make your life more miserable." I like the point of xkcd 1150 too. But Evernote actually does take money from their note taking customers.
- ChuckMcM 10y ago> is using one of the major cloud services cheaper > than running your own? Depends on the size and to some extent the distribution. Above a certain size (and this varies based on the mix of memory, storage, and CPU cycles) it is cheaper to run your own stuff in a space leased from a data center. However that size generally has to be achieved at every data center you want to run in. For example, if your function was that it saves money above size 10, And you need 7 units in the US and 7 units in Europe, it is probably not cost effective to run your own even though your up to 14 units of capacity, but if you're running 15(US) and 12(EU). That said, you still have to have the the operational expertise to run it and with that expertise will come an understanding of the actual costs. For example, at Blekko we were running 1500 machines in a data center and had just over 12,000 hard drives. Those drives are going to fail over time so you need build process around continually renewing the drives. You assume that you'll be able to get some replaced under warranty but you should also simply depreciate the cost of drives over 3 years. So you spend $110 on a drive, you depreciate it at cents per day. That is an "expense" you incur as you buy replacement drives. So your storage is "costing" you $36,000/month ($0.10 * 12,000 drives * 30 days). At the time it was the 2TB generation and our system used simple triple replication for data protection so it represented 8PB of data protected storage, of which, at any given time we were utilizing roughly 5PB. S3 from Amazon [1] is .021/GB per month so 5 petabytes (just what we were using) would be $105,000 per month (so roughly triple the cost). And there is the network 'in/out' costs which raise the prices further and you don't pay for your own storage. Most of our storage management costs (detecting bad drives, reformatting, scheduling for RMA) was done automatically but it did take an data center engineer one day each weak to work through the list of drives that had been determined to be bad, swap in replacements from the 'incoming' drive box, and put the outgoing into the 'rma' box (40 drives in the box) and once the outgoing box was full, print out the list of serial numbers and generate a standardized RMA to Western Digital and to then put the shipping label on the box. So in addition to the depreciation cost you add 20% of the cost of a date center engineer who is doing the mechanical work of moving dead drives out. So you can cost it out this way for your own infrastructure and figure out which is cheaper, and for a lot of people it will be cheaper to run it in the cloud because you really don't need multiple petabytes of data or thousands of cores on line or terabytes of RAM. And some people build their systems in efficiently so that they are spending way more on people keeping them running than they might if they had designed them differently. glindahl had honed a set of scripts and tweaked Nagios bits that made running lots of machines fairly efficient but not everyone has someone like that on staff. But the place where it is a real win, and I think this was the economic story that got Evernote to move, is that when you downsize your infrastructure needs it is trivial when you are in the cloud, and it is non-trivial when they are your own assets. Data center leases are generally multi-year and they are loath to let you sublet space or reduce space. Since Evernote has been shrinking this makes a lot of sense for them, when their user base shrinks their costs shrink with it. And that is the "killer app" for cloud based infrastructure. [1] https://aws.amazon.com/s3/pricing/ https://aws.amazon.com/s3/pricing/
- vidarh 10y ago> but is using one of the major cloud services cheaper than running your own? At list prices? Pretty much never. Nobody sane with installations like Evernote are paying remotely close to the published prices, though. The cloud providers rarely make sense in terms of cost for smaller businesses unless you heavily rely on batch jobs (spinning servers up/down) or other of their more advanced services. There are many valid reasons for smaller companies to consider cloud deployments, but I've yet to see one where it was the cheaper alternative.
- koolba 10y ago> The cloud providers rarely make sense in terms of cost for smaller businesses unless you heavily rely on batch jobs (spinning servers up/down) or other of their more advanced services. There are many valid reasons for smaller companies to consider cloud deployments, but I've yet to see one where it was the cheaper alternative. The cost of a server isn't just the hourly/monthly fee for running it. It's also the cost of waking up at 3am to turn it back on. If you're managing your own bare metal then you have to deal with that one yourself and I can assure you it's never cheaper than the cloud unless you value your time at $0. Sure you can save some money by running a server yourself but if your business it as the point where that's the deciding factor in being solvent than you might as well close shop.
- chatmasta 10y agoThis is why you should run your entire application on bare metal (colo or dedicated) with failover to the cloud. The benefit of the cloud is its elasticity. You can handle a 2000% traffic increase by spinning up VMs instantly; no need to wait a day or week or month for bare metal provisioning. And you should do this! But once you've structured your application this way, you are already horizontally scalable. There is no reason the core of your capacity cannot be on bare metal, especially now that container orchestration platforms are bringing feature parity to cloud and bare metal. Only provision VMs for handling temporary traffic spikes. You can generally predict traffic costs for next 1, 2, or 3 months. You can't predict traffic spikes as easily. So why not invest in dedicated servers or collocated hardware, just enough to cover your expected traffic? Send any excess capacity, whether due to traffic spike or hardware failure, to dynamically provisioned cloud services. This way you capture the economic advantage of elastic cloud pricing while achieving full utilization of your capex investment.
- zhte415 10y agoPerhaps phrase the question differently, to challenge the premise it is 'cheaper': "Could they set up a datacentre as an independent subsidiary that they were client to, but that was run on a commercial basis for other customers too?" i.e. commercially viable. If the answer is "Yes" as it was for Amazon years ago, then it seems like a no-brainer - do it yourself. Otherwise, such decisions calls for greater scrutiny. For example, should HR services be run internally, or outsourced. Outsourcing some functions don't work even they're more expensive on first analysis, like the network effects internal HR can have, or the answer may be "No" for some services, Payroll a common example.
- jaypaulynice 10y agoYou know Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, Google, etc and other major companies use CDN's like Akamai to deliver their content to users right? Building a few data centers may not be not be hard and may be cheaper, what's hard is serving content fast and as close to your users as possible in the world. For that how many data centers could you really build?!
- aiiane 10y agoGoogle runs its own CDN.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jaypaulynice 10y agoI think Youtube is still using Akamai but not as much anymore and Google's CDN is in beta last I checked. Google partners with other major CDN's also. https://www.quora.com/What-CDN-does-YouTube-use https://www.quora.com/What-CDN-does-YouTube-use https://cloud.google.com/interconnect/cdn-interconnect https://cloud.google.com/interconnect/cdn-interconnect
- boulos 10y agoCDN Interconnect isn't the same as Cloud CDN (sorry, the names aren't great). Cloud CDN itself (https://cloud.google.com/cdn https://cloud.google.com/cdn) has been GA for a while, but support for reaching GCS directly from our Load Balancer (https://cloud.google.com/compute/docs/load-balancing/http/using-http-lb-with-cloud-storage https://cloud.google.com/compute/docs/load-balancing/http/us...) and therefore CDN support is in Beta. Disclosure: I work on Google Cloud.
- macroblocks 10y ago> but is using one of the major cloud services cheaper than running your own? Discovery Communications recently announced moving all infrastructure for linear broadcast playout to AWS to replace their data centres. AWS re:Invent 2016: Discovery Channel's Broadcast Workflows and Channel Origination on AWS (MAE303) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6iao7Zcq1-s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6iao7Zcq1-s 25:30 - Rationale, background 53:00 - Discussion of financial models, move from capex to opex Keep in mind that the volume of data in terms of video assets for broadcast quality linear playout as well as numerous continuous high bitrate outgoing video streams is very large. As they note in the video, their financial modelling showed that it made financial sense to move to AWS if it was "all-in", allowing them to fully close down a number of large data centres.
- mbesto 10y ago> That's part of your cost. Except, I get to share one person across several systems. Simplified example: $100k/year for a Linux engineer That same person can upgrade 10 Linux servers (on-premise company) or 1000 linux servers (cloud provider). It may take the 1000 linux servers slightly longer, but the cost to service is still significantly lower. There's also a lot less variability in skills of the Linux engineer. I don't think people quite understand that cloud computing is a consolidation and elimination of backend computing jobs, not the increase. The only reason there is an increase in the market, is because the overall pie is growing.
- ma2rten 10y agoIs using a catering service cheaper for a company than building your own kitchen and hiring a chef? For what it's worth, Google's cafes are run by third party vendors. I am sure they make healthy profits as well.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoI think economy of scale will kick in at some point allowing the cloud providers to profit while being a cheaper service than what the clients could have done themselves.
- bluGill 10y agoIt is cheaper for my company. We have very high seasonal demand on one of our websites. Our busy months need 10 times as many servers as the low months. With amazon we pay for the servers only when we use them. When we did it ourselves the servers spent most of the year idle, but using electricity and maintenance but earning us nothing just so we could handle out peak demand. Now we pay nothing for them when we are not using them. December is one of our low months: those servers we were hitting hard in September are now helping some online store keep up with the Christmas rush. I believe this is factored into the price we pay. We do a lot of our own work in house. In general we have enough IT staff that it is more cost effective to keep our own servers in house, but that is for loads where the variation is relatively small.
- user5994461 10y ago> is using one of the major cloud services cheaper than running your own? Short answer: Yes. Long answer: HELL YES! People commonly underestimate what it would take to have their own AWS/Google by multiple orders of magnitude.
- CaptSpify 10y ago> But is it cheaper, at an equivalent level of service / redundancy? I see people saying yes to this all the time, but I've never seen it come true. I'd love to see some hard stats, but I've never seen them.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]