4 ms·
No. I have a ton of closed-source software in my projects folder. That's not a business model. Neither is open-source software, where I take some of that stuff
by wpietri 10y ago
No.
I have a ton of closed-source software in my projects folder. That's not a business model. Neither is open-source software, where I take some of that stuff and throw it up on GitHub.
A business model is where I repeatably create value for others and receive money in exchange. A modern software company can do that in a variety of ways, including selling training, documentation, support, custom features, consulting, services, and licensing.
Both open- and closed-source companies do that. They have business models. But open source on its own is not a business model, and neither is closed source.
And what's definitely not a business model is releasing something as open source and hoping that somebody gives me money. Businesses don't just happen. Somebody has to build them.
- pjmlp 10y agoThe difference with open source, is that I can take you out of business with the code you wrote yourself.
- wpietri 10y agoSure, there are differences, but I'm not sure that's one of them. Can you name some companies where that has happened? I'm pretty sure I can name a lot more where it hasn't.
- pjmlp 10y agoI don't keep track of it. It is however a possibility.
- ccozan 10y agoThe biggest counter-example is RedHat.
- pjmlp 10y agoYou mean CentOS and Unbreakable Enterprise Kernel ?
- anigbrowl 10y agoRepetition of your assertions isn't an argument. I make some software. You like what it does and want to use it. I ask for money. If the price is right you give me cash and I give you an executable file. How is that not a business model? And what's definitely not a business model is releasing something as open source and hoping that somebody gives me money. Businesses don't just happen. Somebody has to build them. I never claimed open source was a business model. I said the inability to easily monetize OSS is a limiting factor on its development because people need to eat and pay rent.
- wpietri 10y agoIf you are now saying that open source is not a business model, then we agree. As far as I could tell, you were arguing vigorously that it was. > I make some software. You like what it does and want to use it. I ask for money. If the price is right you give me cash and I give you an executable file. How is that not a business model? That business model is selling executables that let your customers do some unspecified thing they care about. I have paid money to people who give me executables for both open- and closed-source software, so that description applies to both. Making and releasing open-source software to the public, though, is not a business model. Which is why the Octave developer is struggling. > I said the inability to easily monetize OSS is a limiting factor on its development because people need to eat and pay rent. Right. But that's not specific to open-source software. Needing to eat, etc, is a limiting factor on making all software. And making almost anything else.