3 ms·
Why coding and not mechanical engineering? MEs often have jobs that could be considered blue collar if not for their degree: designing, installing, & building
by mywittyname 10y ago
Why coding and not mechanical engineering? MEs often have jobs that could be considered blue collar if not for their degree: designing, installing, & building the same equipment that many blue collar workers use or maintain.
It's because coding is seen as a trivial job despite requiring the same amount of education as an ME. Society has this imagine of 14 year old hackers that can do it with minimal training. So it's easy to convince them that some mechanic that lost his job can retrain to become a coder, because, if a 14 year old could do it...
Computer Science is poised to get more difficult in the future, not easier. New companies/technologies will come along offering products that eliminate the need for low-skilled programmers, leaving the more difficult, high-skilled jobs. The tasks that get easier will no longer require a specialized developer, they can instead be done by a person with an understanding of that specific domain. Leaving the rest of the programming jobs a little bit more difficult. (I think the skewed ratio of senior to entry level programming positions is evidence of this phenomenon in action)
I got my start as a teenager doing small e-commerce sites for people, but I'm not sure the "dedicated developer for a small e-commerce site" job exists much anymore. They have been replaced by Shopify, WIX and even Amazon. And once these companies out-grow their platforms, they need more experienced people to build something more robust.
I think we are doing society a disservice by convincing people that anyone can A) learn to sling some JS, and B) make $80k a year doing it. Easy jobs that anyone could do are not jobs that pay 2-3 times the median salary of a region.
- nether 10y agoMechanical engineering is not being a "mechanic." They rarely build or install anything with their hands. Usually we sit in cubes running software to analyze physical systems (like air flowing over a wing) and write up the results. We use a lot of math. Technicians, who usually don't have 4-year degrees, handle the actual fabrication and maintenance. (In case you've forgotten, mechanics is a branch of physics dealing with force, acceleration, mass, that sort of thing.)
- mywittyname 10y agoI understand. I was more getting at the fact that, for example, an HVAC technician would develop an understanding of basic engineering principals by virtue of their job. But nobody would come out and say that they should be retrained to be MEs. Those same people would learn basically nothing about CS in their job, yet they should be developers.
- douche 10y agoExcept that they often do have to fab up prototypes, at the least, and the better ones have enough familiarity with the realities of the blue-collar Joe or Jane that's going to have to use and maintain the piece of equipment that the engineer designs.
- gtvwill 10y ago>> but I'm not sure the "dedicated developer for a small e-commerce site" job exists much anymore. They have been replaced by Shopify, WIX and even Amazon. Mate I thought this was the case until over the last 2 years I have met a number of mum and dad "coding" companies that literally make their bread and butter from building websites using these platforms and shit like wordpress. I was actually blown away that a few of them had managed to make enough to maintain/pay off houses in Sydney (and in nice parts of the city too) and still have enough to buy a bimmer and a audi to boot. Like considering over the last few years I have been trying to get myself out of the laboring market and into I.T, I had to actually stop my jaw dropping in obvious exclamation when I found out these people support their lavish lifestyles providing products that are literally DRAG AND DROP forms of production and not exclaim "you get paid for doing that shit?!" its been a real eye opener...there are plenty of luddite's out there willing to pay for crap.
- eddy_chan 10y agoYeah but you need to understand it's not the actual coding they sell, it's the 'online business consulting' which brings in the moolah
- u_wot_m8 10y agoDevelopers need to get out of their bubble and realize that even a basic website is sorcery for 99% of the population. I'm thankful that I started off in online marketing and then learned to code because I remember what it was like to know nothing and can see opportunities that people like yourself overlook. This post reminds me of the infamous HN dropbox comment in terms of how out of touch it is.
- Thrillington 10y agoThis is it exactly, the blue collar programming jobs are using the tools mentioned by the GP to build sites.
- busterarm 10y agoThe downside of the 'sorcery' impression is that they actually think it's magic and once you make magic happen, you can do anything. There are no engineering trade offs to make. Your request isn't unreasonable or infeasible. If you don't cast spells for me, I'll look around for someone who will (try). Cheaper.
- analog31 10y agoWhy coding and not mechanical engineering? MEs often have jobs that could be considered blue collar if not for their degree: designing, installing, & building the same equipment that many blue collar workers use or maintain. Mechanical engineering has become a form of coding. Creating a structured design in CAD strikes me as being similar to creating a software design in code. I'm not an ME, but I work at a site that employs a number of engineers: Mechanical, electrical, embedded systems, software, manufacturing, etc. Granted, the kind of work done by engineers varies from one industry to another. At my site, most of the engineers do very little engineering per se. They spend most of their time creating parts and assemblies in CAD, dealing with suppliers, and engineering bureaucracy (sprints, JIRA, document control, etc.), and troubleshooting manufacturing problems. The software engineers are doing pretty much the same thing, with different tools (IDE instead of CAD). Part of the issue is degree inflation: People who used to attend trade school and became draftsmen or designers, are now getting 4 year engineering degrees, but the work for draftsmen and designers is still the same, albeit with more efficient tools.