4 ms·
I think having partially self driving cars that require active driver engagement are a huge safety problem, because if drivers are able to just sit there and no
by empath75 10y ago
I think having partially self driving cars that require active driver engagement are a huge safety problem, because if drivers are able to just sit there and not doing anything 90% of the time, they just aren't going to pay attention ever. Some driver aids like automatic braking are probably fine, but 'getting from a to b' is probably something that shouldn't be available until it's as reliable as a human driver.
- falcolas 10y agoI'm thinking less "90% automation" and more "Jeeves from Ironman's Suit". Something to help make the driver aware of anomalies from when they're normally under highway hypnosis or futzing around with the radio. After driving around in Montana today, I'd love for something to be able to tell me with a high degree of confidence if that's really water or ice on the road. Or what speed that car in front of me is going - have they decided it's ice and are driving 30mph slower than I am? Or is that car disappearing into my blind spot going to merge right into me? The answers were, mostly water (thankfully, see 2 and 3), yes they do think its ice, and yes, he is going to.
- jessaustin 10y agoWhen in doubt, slow down. Jeeves would tell you the same.
- falcolas 10y agoThe problem is that such drastic differences in speed create accidents. Someone going 40 on roads where everyone else is going 75 is going to create emergency braking, panic merges, and a bunch of other potential problems. Jarvis telling me to slow down when the surrounding traffic is going 75 would not be useful, and would (if followed) make me more prone to be hit or cause other accidents. Instead, what I want Jarvis to tell me is "this car <highlighted in a HUD> is going 30mph slower than you." This is useful, actionable data that a vision or radar system could provide.
- coredog64 10y agoI would think there would be a huge market for something like this as a chaperone for teen drivers. They need reminders to check blind spots. They haven't built up experience in picking out subtle signs from other drivers.
- jfim 10y agoThis is also an issue for other autonomous systems where there's a human in the loop. The solution for that is well known: dial down the automation every once in a while and ask the human to do something, so that they stay aware of their surroundings and don't doze off. Unfortunately, a car that turns off the cruise control, asks you to recenter the car in the lane or increase the distance with the car ahead wouldn't sell that well, as people would consider it defective.