5 ms·
> You can't have more money, AND fewer hours/more vacation. This assumes that productivity is constant per hour worked, which is far from the truth for many pr
by CydeWeys 10y ago
> You can't have more money, AND fewer hours/more vacation.
This assumes that productivity is constant per hour worked, which is far from the truth for many professions. For most professions you the productivity delta not only decreases with too many hours, it even eventually becomes negative. There's no reason to suspect that eight is the optimal number of hours for every profession; it's just a historical quirk left over from the days of predominantly manual factory labor.
- dsfyu404ed 10y ago>This assumes that productivity is constant per hour worked, which is far from the truth for many professions. Even in white collar that's not true. For creative problem solving it mostly holds but it doesn't hold very well in situations where the immediate product that isn't cutting edge and/or isn't mostly aesthetic (basically the artsy people and the R&D people). For everything else there's a pretty direct relationship between time and productivity.
- CydeWeys 10y agoIt's true for most (if not all) white collar professions, not just the creative/artistic ones. You can't stare at Excel spreadsheets for ten hours straight and be as productive in the tenth hour as you were in the first. Or say that you're doing case research -- you're certainly more bored and easily driven to distraction after you've already been reading for many hours in a day. People aren't machines.
- splintercell 10y ago> This assumes that productivity is constant per hour worked, which is far from the truth for many professions. It isn't, but productivity also isn't an inverse function of number of hours worked. At best, productivity is a function of the incentives which drives you, to a limit, after which it comes down for the number of hours worked. Take for example there are many people who had high paying corporate job, but once they quit it and started working on their own startup, despite the long hours they worked, their productivity went up. Similarly, other people work for money, because that's what drives them. The main point is that there is no one size fits all solution. But nearly all these studies about workplace hours studies fail to see that.
- WalterBright 10y agoIt's not a quirk. There were studies done during WW2 that aimed to maximize production. They found that increasing work beyond 8 hours increased productivity for a few weeks, then it fell off below what was produced in 8 hours. They found production was maximized with an 8 hour day, interspersed with occasional longer days.
- autokad 10y agowould I be more productive with 6 hour days? probably. would I get more done? absolutely not (at least for me). 6 hour days would be a huge boon to my personal life, but I couldn't afford to be paid 25% less. even if I was 10% more productive (probably generous), i still couldnt afford to be paid 17.5% less
- awful 10y agoSo, I ask you kindly, where is the tradeoff? 7 hours/day? And what if most decided that that was the norm, and maybe and as competitive forces corrected your wage would rise to match current (or oppositely prices fall to meet less free income)?