5 ms·
Honest not antagonistic question, why is it important to get right?
by mistermann 10y ago
Honest not antagonistic question, why is it important to get right?
- sp332 10y agoYou'll miss out on less talent. Your teams will be better at problem-solving if they have diverse backgrounds and outlooks (not just genetic "heritage" but that can be a half-decent proxy). You're not going to contribute to racism, sexism etc in society at large which might be driving groups apart culturally or denying certain opportunities to certain groups of people. And the DoL won't sue you :)
- FT_intern 10y ago> You'll miss out on less talent. This is assuming that the diverse candidates who actually have talent aren't being hired. That's the argument you need to be making > Your teams will be better at problem-solving if they have diverse backgrounds and outlooks If you want teams that are better at problem-solving, why don't you directly judge applicants based on their problem-solving abilities in a team environment instead of using diversity as a proxy for problem solving ability (which has not been proven at all)?
- logfromblammo 10y agoBecause then your employees can make it into the all-important business stock photos, and be PowerPoint stars forever.~ If companies cared about real diversity rather than the illusion of diversity, they would blind their own interview process to any factors not directly related to job duties. A truly diverse company can potentially produce a wider variety of creative options, as a lesser overlap in skills and experiences produces greater coverage of a problem space with the same number of people investigating it. It isn't just about age, sex, color, or religion. It's about the cities lived in, the neighbors barely tolerated, the pets kept, the hobbies enjoyed, the music listened to, the crazy acquaintance stories, the routes taken on the daily commute, and quite a lot of other things selected against when seeking out "culture fit". Otherwise, "head of diversity" sounds like a nice, cushy sinecure, with a gratuitously large budget to waste. Diversity is the responsibility of the entire personnel/HR department, and can't be meaningfully delegated to one figurehead.
- sp332 10y agoIf companies cared about real diversity rather than the illusion of diversity, they would blind their own interview process to any factors not directly related to job duties. That would be good for cases when you need someone who can jump in immediately, and you have their job requirements nailed down ahead of time. But sometimes you need to gauge a person's potential for growth into a position. And as FT_intern pointed out, often you want to know how the person will do with a particular team. That's really hard to do in a blind test.
- logfromblammo 10y agoEssentially saying that the biases of individual teams trump the diversity goals of the entire company? Blind testing is not so difficult that it isn't worth doing. Last week, the spouse and I did a blind taste test of nine different beers. We got someone else to pour them into numbered cups and rated the contents of the cups without pre-existing biases. You just have to interview in such a way that no one can see the candidates' labels. Would it really be that awful to use a telepresence robot with text-to-speech in an interview? That would allow the candidate to see and hear everybody else, but no one would know anything about them other than what they typed in a chat box.
- anigbrowl 10y agoIt's both more effective and a remediation of past discrimination. Bear in mind this is only an obligation insofar as companies wit to contract with governmental entities.
- ihsw 10y agoRemedying past discrimination is not any company's responsibility, not by a long shot.
- anigbrowl 10y agoHave you tried reading comments all the way to the end before replying? I wrote two sentences in the post above, and the second one addressed that very objection.
- sp332 10y agoThere are laws that prohibit discrimination even for private companies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employment_discrimination_law_in_the_United_States#Federal_laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employment_discrimination_law_...