11 ms·
I found out this the hard way. T-Mobile used to offer 2G internet speeds internationally in 100+ countries included in Simple Choice subscriptions. 2G is limit
by Someone1234 10y ago
I found out this the hard way.
T-Mobile used to offer 2G internet speeds internationally in 100+ countries included in Simple Choice subscriptions. 2G is limited to 50 kbit/s, that's slower than a 56K modem.
While this absolutely fine for background processes (e.g. notifications) and even checking your email, most websites never loaded at these speeds. Resources would time out, and the adverts alone could easily exceed a few megabytes. I even had a few website block me because of my "ad blocker" because the adverts didn't load timely enough.
Makes me feel for people in like rural India or other places still only at 2G or similar speeds. It is great for some things, not really useable for general purpose web browsing any longer.
PS - T-Mobile now offers 3G speeds internationally; this was just the freebie at the time.
- freehunter 10y agoYeah when I used to run over my T-Mobile data allotment (in the US) and they dropped me to whatever speed they throttle you to when your "high speed" data is gone, Google Maps wouldn't load, Facebook wouldn't load, YouTube wouldn't load. I remember using all of those things back in the days when a 3G connection was a luxury, back when Windows was the best smartphone platform. What happened between then and now that suddenly nothing works?
- kuschku 10y ago> What happened between then and now that suddenly nothing works? Single Page Applications with dozens of MB of Javascript, Google AMP (which has a JS runtime taking several minutes to load on 2G), and so on.
- timdavila 10y ago> which has a JS runtime taking several minutes to load on 2G source? the entire goal of AMP is to load pages quickly
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- SquareWheel 10y agoWell, it would have to be downloaded once. It'd stay cached after that though so it's not really a concern. They use version numbers for cache busting.
- flukus 10y agoOn mobile cache sizes are very limited, and with the size of modern web pages it has to get reclaimed regularly. You can't rely on caching to solve poor performance.
- acdha 10y agoMinutes might be slightly overselling it but AMP has a bit over 100KB of render-blocking JavaScript alone before you get the actual content. Here's the current top story when I hit news.google.com in a mobile browser: https://news.google.com/news/amp?caurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.com%2Famphtml%2Fnews%2Fbusiness%2Fwp%2F2017%2F02%2F08%2Ftrump-lashes-out-at-nordstrom-in-a-tweet-for-dropping-his-daughters-apparel-line%2F https://news.google.com/news/amp?caurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.was... Loading that in a simulated 2G connection takes about 80 seconds and at least 30 seconds of that is waiting to display anything you care about. Looking at the content breakdown shows why: ~200KB of webfonts, 1.2MB of JavaScript, 275KB of HTML, etc. https://www.webpagetest.org/result/170208_DV_R2R1/2/details/#waterfall_view_step1 https://www.webpagetest.org/result/170208_DV_R2R1/2/details/... https://www.webpagetest.org/result/170208_5Y_R404/1/details https://www.webpagetest.org/result/170208_5Y_R404/1/details Loading the same page without JavaScript pulls the content render time down into a couple seconds, still over 2G: https://www.webpagetest.org/result/170208_5Y_R404/1/details/#waterfall_view_step1 https://www.webpagetest.org/result/170208_5Y_R404/1/details/...
- kuschku 10y agoOn my throttled 2G connection, it’s ~2½ minutes, and because I rarely visit pages with AMP, it’s never cached.
- rmc 10y ago> What happened between then and now that suddenly nothing works? The average expection changed. Back in the day, everyone was on $SLOW_SPEED, so pages were designed for it. Now-a-days they can, and do design, pages for higher speeds
- 72deluxe 10y agoYes and the average page size has sky-rocketed, despite there being no more actual content (i.e. text). Instead we have animations of images or text fading in as we scroll down a page and lots of Javascript to do things I do not know. Kind of makes me miss the old plain HTML days - much less CPU intensive too.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoBut still should make sure low speed works. But try convincing some privileged 20 something developer of that.
- nindalf 10y agoIt's really not about a privileged youngster, it's about business priorities. Most of the time the cost benefit ratio doesn't justify the effort to optimise for high latency high packet-loss connections. Let's say 1% of your potential users use such connections. It only makes sense to support them if your total userbase is a large enough number. For Google, it's a no-brainer. For other sites, it's something to consider. At work we did something similar a few years ago with our Android app. We dropped support for Android 2.3 users because we only had a couple hundred of them and it didn't justify the developer cost to maintain it. WhatsApp only dropped support a month ago. I don't think that was because they were somehow less privileged than us. The casual ageism in your comment is unbecoming. You could reconsider it.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoI could, but I've worked with too many examples that only care about writing new code in whatever is the latest hotness and moving on. They[0] don't want to fix their bugs. They don't care about anything but "works on my machine." They certainly don't care about using bandwidth. [0] The ones I've worked with
- 5ilv3r 10y agoHigh paying customers are going to have high speed connections. No one will talk about it, but it's discrimination. If you are on a slow connection, they don't want your kind on their site. If you try, they will mock you for not knowing your place.
- iamdave 10y agoNo one will talk about it, but it's discrimination. This will make a few segments of people cringe because much like the topic of racism, there's a school of thought that it only counts when things are exhibited in severe forms like water cannons, attack dogs or restrictive housing covenants or otherwise people being directly being told 'no' because of superficial topics like race, gender or sexual orientation. But as a tech guy who's slowly pivoting towards law, I've long held the belief that technology will become the next battle ground for civil rights-and has the potential to even change (in the sense of expanding the definition of) how we talk about civil rights. Think along the lines of people being left behind when it comes to accessing information they need to request public resources as more and more cities move towards online only forms, or even utilization of "entitlement programs" to pay for internet access (http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2016-03-31/fcc-expands-obamaphone-program-to-include-internet http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2016-03-31/fcc-expands-o...). Now it may not be active discrimination in the sense that one will be outright told 'no', but disparate impact deserves to be at the table of discussing this sort of thing.
- emodendroket 10y agoIt seems more plausible to me that they just don't want to take the trouble to support low-bandwidth connections than that they're actively pumping up the space to keep out poor people.
- Jakob 10y agoDisable JavaScript. You’ll be surprised at how most of the web still works and is much faster. Longer battery life on mobile, too.
- zeveb 10y ago> You’ll be surprised at how most of the web still works and is much faster. And you'll be more secure, and you'll retain more of your privacy. I find 'this site requires JavaScript' to be another way of saying, 'the authors of this site don't care about you, your security or your privacy, and will gladly sell all three to the highest bidder.'
- davesque 10y agoPractically speaking, I think it's much more appropriate to just assume the admins are lazy.
- CaptSpify 10y agoI'll respectfully disagree with you. It takes more work to have a bloated JS mess of a site, than it is to have a small, simple, clean site. If they were lazy, they wouldn't have gotten to that spot in the first place.
- 5ilv3r 10y agoPerfection is achieved, not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away. Antoine de Saint-Exupery
- davesque 10y agoYeah, but it takes diligence to know that.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 10y agoNot really. It's very easy to get bloat if you integrate ad-networks, analytics tools, social media tools etc. willy-nilly without looking at all the resources they fetch. The lazy approach WILL lead to bloat. No news agency is running a plain jane HTML website.
- 23443463453 10y agoIt's what makes me wish designers and developers would work with artificial constraints. Sure, it's easy to design and develop without really thinking of bandwidth constraints, but reality is you are and will always be a better developer and designer by setting artificial bandwidth constraints in your mind and choices. Seeking out or thinking as though you have bandwidth constraints can push you to find better solutions and thereby make your services better. The west and the tech centers in particular is really rather blinded by the glutinous bandwidth that keeps eating up greater and greater amounts of data with only marginal improvements in outcome or user experience.
- CaptSpify 10y agoI say this so much that I should probably just copy/paste it in the future but... I used to work at a place that had a <1mbps modem, and a ~7 year old destkop. If their software didn't work on that, it needed to be optimized. I wish more places would test this way. Your sight may work fine in downtown SF, but that doesn't mean it's going to work well anywhere else.
- flukus 10y agoDatabases too. Hosting the database on a fast machine with a lot of RAM and an SSD will hide performance problems that should be immediately apparent.
- Nition 10y agoWith games, it's way easier to see problems in the profiler on the minimum spec PC than it is on your dev machine. Everything is magnified.
- kps 10y agoChrome's Developer Tools has throttling options immediately available in the Network tab.
- mfarris 10y agoUX guy here. I've always kept performance in mind. One of my pet phrases is that speed is part of design. I've gotten a lot of blank stares. That's why more designers don't bother: decision makers usually respond only to look/flashiness/branding.
- stuckagain 10y agoHaving used both, I'll take the 2G mobile over the 56k modem every time.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoI just looked up EDGE. It's crazy to think that the first iPhone topped out at double the speed of a 56k modem. And that I actually used my iPhone on that network sometimes, when 3G wasn't available.
- Humdeee 10y agoI had a blackberry a bit before the first iPhone. I remember getting an update wirelessly that was something like 3MB and just thought "Good, it should only be about 10 minutes this time."
- _delirium 10y ago> PS - T-Mobile now offers 3G speeds internationally; this was just the freebie at the time. I don't think this has changed, at least not in general. The included roaming package is still free international 2G roaming everywhere except Mexico and Canada (which get free 4G), with "high-speed data pass" upgrades available for a daily or weekly fee if you want faster. They did have a promotion for the 2nd half of 2016 (initially for the summer, then extended through the end of the year), where international 3G, and in a few areas 4G/LTE, was free without buying the upgrade passes for most of Europe and South America [1]. But that's now over, and I believe it's back to free 2G internationally now. [1] https://newsroom.t-mobile.com/news-and-blogs/t-mobiles-endless-summer.htm https://newsroom.t-mobile.com/news-and-blogs/t-mobiles-endle...
- virtuallynathan 10y agoOn the new "One Plan" it's now 128Kbps, and 256Kbps if you pay for the One Plus International plan ($25/mo).
- CoolGuySteve 10y agoI was in rural China with an EDGE connection on Google Fi last month. Hacker News was pretty much the only site I visit that could reliably load quickly. m.facebook.com had a slight wait but was still bearable. I had to leave my phone for 10 or 15 minutes to get Google News. WeChat and email worked well. Everything else was horrible, especially ad networks that would ping pong several requests or load large images. Opera has a compression proxy mode that helped a bit when it worked but it was still painful. For search results, Stack Overflow, and YouTube, it was easier to easier to ssh into an AWS node and use elinks/youtube-dl. Using SSH as a socks proxy/compression was insanely slow due to something with with the great firewall.
- r00fus 10y agoI mainly used it for things like slack, skype and emails, and mapping. With iOS9+ content blockers and things like Google AMP, I think the web is a lot more usable. Apps tend to be less bloated in terms of bandwidth as well, since they usually don't load as many assets on request.
- megablast 10y agoYou have just discovered why apps are so good, they can download content in small amounts.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoMy 35Mbit cable got shaped down to 0.25 Mbit/s yesterday because we went over our download limit. It was like having no connection. I just gave up using it. I hate the all-or-nothing approach to shaping. At least give me 5Mbit or something!
- lucb1e 10y ago5mbps is a perfectly fine connection, they might as well not throttle you at all then. If they want to give you barely-usable internet, about 500kbps might be reasonable. 250kbps is quite slow indeed.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoI wouldn't call 5mbps "perfectly fine", but I could do basic web browsing and email etc. And that's my point. I don't want to be shaped down to a barely-usable connection. Why do they need to shape at all? The only argument is congestion. And if there's congestion, they should shape us down to a reasonable level like 5mbps. No reason it should be all or nothing, 35Mbit or zero.
- Figs 10y agoI use T-Mobile as my ISP because the only landline choice in my apartment building is AT&T and I absolutely refuse to do business with them. I regularly hit the monthly bandwidth cap on my plan and get booted down to 2G. I live in California -- this is not just something people internationally are dealing with. Annoyingly, T-Mobile's own website doesn't work properly when you're throttled to 2G speed. Found that out the hard way when I ran out of minutes on Thanksgiving and couldn't talk to my family, and couldn't load their website to add more minutes.
- archagon 10y agoFYI, I had the same connection and I'm pretty sure T-Mobile simulates 2G by switching 3G on and off to get the correct speed on average. Breaks a lot of stuff. Almost unusable!