3 ms·
An easy way to demonstrate the truth of the "paid protesters" claim is to show any way one can sign up to be a paid protestor. I have been doing some unpaid pro
by geofft 10y ago
An easy way to demonstrate the truth of the "paid protesters" claim is to show any way one can sign up to be a paid protestor. I have been doing some unpaid protesting and wouldn't mind a check, to be honest.
Until then: FAKE NEWS!
- jonknee 10y agoYou're 100% correct, but even if there are "paid protestors" I really don't get why that's a bad thing. Everyone working for the pipeline is getting paid!
- zo1 10y agoWould you say the same if said "paid" action was driving/directing public policy? There is a reason there are strict laws regulating money in regulations and public service. This is of course not quite the same but it essentially boils down to "money buys votes". The assumption being that who sends more money wins. That is why I would argue it bothers people. Edit: grammar.
- jonknee 10y agoPaid action drives public policy every day, it's the normal way things work. Do you think the people who are fighting for the pipeline are doing it for fun? Like these guys: https://daplpipelinefacts.com/ https://daplpipelinefacts.com/ Business interests have a huge leg up here because there is money to be made, anti-business interests like not building a pipeline are the ones that have to rely on volunteers. I sure hope there are some paid organizers helping out because they're up against a machine.
- geofft 10y agoIt discredits the protests: it implies that opposition isn't coming from a large number of intrinsically motivated people, but from a small number of people with money. It's the same philosophy behind paid votes being a bad thing. Even in our capitalist society, we believe that one-person-one-vote leads to a better society than one-dollar-one-vote. You can imagine systems that aren't one-person-one-vote (and they exist; see e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_constituency_(Hong_Kong) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_constituency_(Hong_... in which one real estate chairperson has equivalent voting power to fifteen thousand private citizens), but for whatever reason, America's ideal is one-person-one-vote. In particular, when the opposition holds adherence to one-person-one-political-voice as one of its own principles, the opposition can't say "So what" without appearing hypocritical. They have to actually address that criticism directly.
- zo1 10y agoI don't think it's the same as getting paid to do it like a job. It's more along the lines of your group or committee or activism organization gets sponsorship from someone. The assumption being that now you(the group) are getting money, you're 'funded' therefore you need to 'do something' that your group advocates or represents. If you are a pro environmental rights organization you would have to send someone to protest a pipeline for example.
- geofft 10y agoThat's not what's being claimed: > paid protestors who are going to get in trouble for working in North Dakota and not filing their taxes The only way you'd be liable to state taxes in ND is if you are literally paid to do it like a job.
- zo1 10y agoIsn't it more likely that that individual was just being a bit facetious rather than seriously claiming these people are getting a "paycheck" for protesting? That is how I took it, and was more trying to expound on how "paid protesting" could at the very least work hypothetically.
- geofft 10y agoNo, I don't think that's more likely. The accusations of "paid protesting" have been very consistent that they literally mean getting an individual paycheck to go and protest. http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/jan/30/north-dakota-wants-hired-pipeline-protesters-to-pa/ http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/jan/30/north-dakota... The Washington Times (note that the Times is a Unification Church-run paper, not the Post) quotes the North Dakota Tax Commissioner as saying he's "looking at the entities that have potential paid contractors here on their behalf doing work," and writes that he's "keeping an eye out for tax forms from environmental groups that may have hired protesters to agitate against" the pipeline. http://heatst.com/politics/north-dakota-may-take-tax-action-against-professional-protestors-at-standing-rock/ http://heatst.com/politics/north-dakota-may-take-tax-action-... Heat Street also quotes a spokeswoman for the tax commissioner as saying, "Since the protesters earned income in North Dakota, they would owe income tax to the state on that income tax per North Dakota tax law. If they do not file for tax year 2016, they would be subject to penalties and interest." https://twitter.com/foxandfriends/status/828570204670091264 https://twitter.com/foxandfriends/status/828570204670091264 Sean Spicer says that protesting is "a profession" and it's become an "astroturf-type movement", and specifically contrasts it with the Tea Party protests (which consisted of funded organizations, like you suggest—enough funded organizations that the IRS could flag them). https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/796900183955095552 https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/79690018395509555... The president refers to "professional protestors". http://abcnews.com.co/donald-trump-protester-speaks-out-i-was-paid-to-protest/ http://abcnews.com.co/donald-trump-protester-speaks-out-i-wa... Literal fake news website "abcnews.com.co" (i.e., not "abcnews.go.com") has a story about a protestor receiving a $3,500 check. I appreciate that you're trying to extend good faith, but the way to do that is to believe they mean what they say. If the mechanics of "paid protesting" don't make sense to you, that's because the people you're arguing with are wrong, not because you're misunderstanding them.
- Natsu 10y agoThere was a place to sign up, but it was totally fake and it got exposed in this hilarious interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGxwizzUbfw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGxwizzUbfw