4 ms·
My favorite pet theory (head-canon may be a more appropriate term) is that Dark Matter is a set of matter that's just as rich and interactive as ours - made up
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
My favorite pet theory (head-canon may be a more appropriate term) is that Dark Matter is a set of matter that's just as rich and interactive as ours - made up of particles that follow the analogue of our laws, with weak, strong and electromagnetic forces - but slightly different, so that that parallel universe is full of intelligent life, investigating "shadow matter" that only interacts via gravity, wondering how sad and empty and dark it must be for those particles that make up only 10% of the universe.
- antognini 10y agoHeh. The issue is that all the "shadow stars" and "shadow planets" would have been detected via gravitational microlensing.
- QuantumGravy 10y agoUnless, say, there were enough such parallel worlds to smudge the effects on smaller than galactic scales.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI'm not thinking "parallel worlds" in the Sliders sense, just in the "dark matter" sense. If there were "enough" to blur it out, each one would likely not have enough mass to really have a complete universe. On the other hand, if we only make up 15% of the known mass of the universe, that's room enough for 5 more parallel shadow universes living beside us! Or maybe dark matter just doesn't need as much mass for intelligent life to develop. Who says they need stars and planets?
- QuantumGravy 10y agoParallel as in further "up" and "down" along some unperceived Nth-dimensional axis sorta thing, as I'm imagining it. We'd be some percentage of dark matter to every other "known universe", ourselves, in a cosmological principle sense, not particularly unique or special. If the gravitational force also falls off along such an axis, assumptions about what percentage each parallel universe consists of becomes more complicated. The nearer ones could be more massive than otherwise expected. Each successive parallel universe would also contribute a smaller amount to the whole.
- russdill 10y agoInteresting, but it'd need to interact in ways we don't understand. If it interacted and formed life like we know it, it would need to clump, which it doesn't. For a dark matter candidate to behave correctly, particles need to fly right past each other, heedless of one another except for gravitational effects. Never even collecting into clouds as interstellar gas does. Who knows though, the interactions between them may not alter their trajectory, but may be so complex that they can support self replicating patterns.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoYeah - perhaps they don't need to clump together as much to develop intelligent life. We need stars and planets; they could work on much smaller scales. If I were writing a science fiction novel, I'd love to talk to enough scientists to posit a plausible mechanism.
- QuantumGravy 10y agoI've heard ideas thrown around explaining both the relative weakness of gravity (compared to other forces) and parallel universes. Gravity would be strong, but prone to "leaking" along a hidden dimension, and the gravitational sum of those invisible worlds would explain the blobby, non-interacting nature of dark matter. I don't know of any scientists actually giving this consideration, but it does make for a fun head-canon.
- interknot 10y agoYou might enjoy Stephen Baxter's "Xeelee" books. I started with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_Diagrams https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_Diagrams and enjoyed it, but could see its various stories coming across as too jumbled up and disconnected for some.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoHe paints a grand vision of almost unparalleled scale and scope. I really liked his Xeelee cycle, even though the writing is quite arid. But holy cow, this is a writer who thinks BIG. Unfortunately he takes a few liberties with physics. Dark matter could never produce and sustain life. It's just too poor in terms of interactions. You need richly interacting matter for that, producing the most richly interacting atom of all - carbon - in order for life to appear and evolve.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI've read a fair amount of them, and loved them! I hope other people see your comment.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoIf it interacted with itself in ways other than just gravity, it would make clumps. The problem is, it doesn't make clumps. Its distribution is very clearly non-clumpy. Also, if this was gravity leaking between parallel universes, I believe it would produce measurable artifacts, and therefore could be tested.
- raattgift 10y agoIt's useful to add to this that "interacting with itself" in a way that allows clumping implies radiative dissipation of momentum or elastic collision or both. Without that it takes much longer to ditch enough momentum to fall into an orbit closer to the centre of mass around which it's moving. That is, the non-clumpiness implies that if there is dark chemistry, the reactions must take a long time compared to the present age of the universe.
- flukus 10y agoCan we say it doesn't clump or can we only say it doesn't clump on the galactic scale? Could it clump but then go into it's equivalent of a super nova with very small clumps?
- raattgift 10y agoThis is a pretty good question. There is a limit to the changes in the momentum of cold dark matter before it produces visible effects in galaxies of different ages. Explosive processes in the dark matter sector must be rare, whatever their mechanism and whatever their daughter products (even if it quickly decays to cold dark matter again, but on a different trajectory).
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoAsimov's The Gods Themselves runs along those lines: The main plot-line is a project by aliens who inhabit a parallel universe (the para-Universe) with different physical laws from this one. By exchanging matter with Earth, they seek to exploit these differences in physical laws. The exchange of matter provides an alternative source of energy in their dying universe.