2 ms·
Any proposal should be viewed as a constraint-satisfaction problem against the closest possible approximation to the actual reality. Sure, but with the underst
by onion2k 10y ago
Any proposal should be viewed as a constraint-satisfaction problem against the closest possible approximation to the actual reality.
Sure, but with the understanding that "actual reality" is not some fixed point that can never be changed. You're saying that Indian people will always spend this money unwisely because that's what they do now and it's what they've always done. I'm saying that Indian people living in povery are intelligent and can understand a rational argument that basic income would be great for them if they use it well. People can change, especially if they're give the incentive of, say, free money.
- lngnmn 10y agoI have not said anything about people living in poverty. I only said that there exist an ancient tradition and related social norms, which are very real and very strong factors. Perhaps, I failed to emphasize, that in India the "social" is much stronger aspect than Western "personal success". In India it is about finding one's place in society, instead of outperforming everyone else. That is a fundamental difference. Even the decade of third-rate western satellite TV still failed to create a significant shift into western consumerism and obsession with the cosplay of success (and the cosplay of absent intelligence, which we call hipsterism). There are some converts, of course, but not that many.