This is basically the same argument in general against basic income, prepended with "in the case of India, it won't work because... " I don't know if basic inc

This is basically the same argument in general against basic income, prepended with "in the case of India, it won't work because... " I don't know if basic income works, but that's why experiments in the field are required. None of the reasons you have pointed out seem to be apply only to India.