4 ms·
"shortly after the US Senate voted away the right of Habeas Corpus" I guess you would have blamed Google if it had rained that day too.
by edw519 19y ago
"shortly after the US Senate voted away the right of Habeas Corpus"
I guess you would have blamed Google if it had rained that day too.
- gruseom 19y agoCould you come up with a more obvious straw man? What he said was that it made him not want to move to the US. He didn't say why. Since habeas corpus was hardly "voted away" for Canadian researcher emigrés who work at Google, it must have been on principled (or ostensibly principled) grounds. I could understand why someone might object to that, but if you're going to take issue with it, at least respond to what he said.
- cperciva 19y agoI guess you would have blamed Google if it had rained that day too. I don't blame Google for the US Senate's lack of backbone, either. However, the legal situation, my dislike for what I saw of Silicon Valley weather (I like humidity), and the urban sprawl were all factors in my deciding that it wasn't an environment I would enjoy.
- edw519 19y ago"US Senate's lack of backbone" Take this argument to reddit, please. (Of course, if this gets downmodded immediately, then we'll all know that won't be necessary. Reddit has arrived here.)
- cperciva 19y agoTake this argument to reddit, please. Someone asked why I didn't accept a job at Google; I answered. I don't come here to debate politics, but I don't think politics are automatically off-topic here -- particularly when they influence questions like "should I move to Silicon Valley?" or "should I launch a startup company?".
- davidw 19y agoThe problem is that, as you can easily see from the results, what was a fascinating look at one person's experience with Google has degraded into a relatively uninteresting tit-for-tat session, which does not reflect well on anyone. I'm not sure what to say really... you answered honestly and certainly weren't concentrating on that aspect of it. Perhaps the best thing is if people have the fortitude to not respond to politically themed things even if they strongly disagree.
- edw519 19y agoIt wasn't the politics I challenged. It was the business logic. You aren't going to conduct business with an entity in a given country because another entity in that country did something you disagree with? Then it looks like you'll never be doing any business with anyone ever. This is a place where we hackers get together to encourage each other to leverage our technological (and other) skills to build great businesses. When someone posts a remark like that, it needs to be challenged. Left unchallenged, it stands as "accepted". (Funny, OP won't go to google because of the actions of the U.S. Senate, but still chooses to conduct that argument in a forum which is based in the U.S. Logic, please?)
- davidw 19y agohttp://xkcd.com/386/ http://xkcd.com/386/ :-)
- ardit33 19y ago""shortly after the US Senate voted away the right of Habeas Corpus"" I am foreign living in USA, and this troubles me a lot. I basically have no right, and can wisked away at will from any american agency, and have absolutely no right to do anything about it if I was labeled a terrorist. I come from a allay country of USA, but still the lack of abilities to appeal in court, is very frightening, almost fascistic.