4 ms·
Will it be patent encumbered, like Apple's "proposal" for touch events API? > Meanwhile, GPU technology has improved and new software APIs have been created to
by shmerl 10y ago
Will it be patent encumbered, like Apple's "proposal" for touch events API?
> Meanwhile, GPU technology has improved and new software APIs have been created to better reflect the designs of modern GPUs. These new APIs exist at a lower level of abstraction and, due to their reduced overhead, generally offer better performance than OpenGL. The major platform technologies in this space are Direct3D 12 from Microsoft, Metal from Apple, and Vulkan from the Khronos Group. While these technologies have similar design concepts, unfortunately none are available across all platforms.
Oh, really? And who is to blame, that Vulkan is not available on Apple platforms?
- netule 10y agoNot only that, but Apple seems to have decided to stop supporting open graphics standards altogether, including OpenGL [1]. Apple used to be quite vocal and influential as part of the ARB, not sure what caused the shift of the last few years. [1] https://www.g-truc.net/doc/OpenGL%20Drivers%20Status.pdf https://www.g-truc.net/doc/OpenGL%20Drivers%20Status.pdf
- shmerl 10y agoYes, they clearly are deeply into their usual NIH routine. So it's highly hypocritical for them to complain, how open APIs aren't cross platform enough.
- scholia 10y agoApple supported Blu-ray and even took a seat on the Blu-ray board. How many Blu-ray drives did Apple ship?
- jsheard 10y agoThe shift was especially jarring on the compute side of things. Apple literally started the OpenCL initiative, then decided to completely abandon their OpenCL driver in favor of Metal Compute.
- stupidcar 10y agoThe group's draft charter[1] proposes that contributing organisations would be required to agree to the W3C Community Contributor License Agreement[2], which includes a patent licensing commitment for all essential claims. So, if a specification came out of this, then it would not be patent encumbered; at least not by any patents held by Apple. I'm willing to give Apple the benefit of the doubt on this. Like any big tech organisation, I'm sure they have people who want to do the wrong thing, and people who want to do the right thing. Everyone supporting Vulcan would be nice, but a standardised, patent-free, cross-platform, web-enabled, low-level GPU API would still be a major step forward. [1] https://gpuweb.github.io/admin/cg-charter.html https://gpuweb.github.io/admin/cg-charter.html [2] https://www.w3.org/community/about/agreements/cla/ https://www.w3.org/community/about/agreements/cla/
- shmerl 10y ago> So, if a specification came out of this, then it would not be patent encumbered; at least not by any patents held by Apple. So how come they didn't manage to have the same idea for touch events? > Everyone supporting Vulcan would be nice, but a standardised, patent-free, cross-platform, web-enabled, low-level GPU API would still be a major step forward. I'd say design and its roots matter. If they base it off Metal, and use Metal like technology, while Metal itself remains a closed Apple only API, then W3C should reject it. Consider the whole related ecosystem, like shaders and so on. Anything like that should be based on open APIs and related ecosystems, like WebGL is based on OpenGL. If Apple want to help, let them base WebGPU on Vulkan. If not, they shouldn't waste everyone's time. I hope W3C participants will have enough common sense to come to the same conclusions.
- stupidcar 10y ago> So how come they didn't manage to have the same idea for touch events? I have no clue. You'd have to ask them. But they have had this idea for WebGPU. If you think it's better than what they did for touch events, let's hope you approach it with an open mind and-... > I'd say design and its roots matter. If they base it off Metal, and use Metal like technology, while Metal itself remains a closed Apple only API, then W3C should reject it. ...No, you're just going to get mad about a hypothetical.
- om2 10y agoWe're committed to abiding by the W3C Patent Policy for this spec.
- botverse 10y agoExpect some friction :)
- phaed 10y agoExpect the developers that have been abandoned by Apple not to move at all.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shmerl 10y agoThat's a positive thing, but the whole effort looks like an indirect attempt to push Metal, without making it open itself. What about shader tools and etc.? Are there any open ones for Metal? IMHO if anything like that should be created, it should be based on open APIs.
- om2 10y agoWe think the eventual shader language will not be based on MSL. We need both source and binary formats, and MSL doesn't even have a public binary format at this time. However, if we do end up with something MSL-inspired, the same commitment to follow the Patent Policy would apply.
- shmerl 10y agoI think it's a sane expectation to use something that is both open and already available. GLSL, SPIR-V and etc. Using something like MSL won't go anywhere, if there won't be comparable, open and freely available implementation already. You should take that idea seriously, if you want to view it as a truly collaborative project that invites everybody's participation. I.e using MSL from the start was a major mistake.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]