9 ms·
Dwarf Fortress and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Interface
- pavel_lishin 10y ago(Second comment, because it's a different topic.) I've found that Kerbal Space Program seems to occupy that same gaming niche for me, of a game that's more of a simulator without defined goals, that rewards both planning and the realization that all of your finely laid plans can go to hell in one second - sometimes because of a wrong microdecision you made, and sometimes because that's just how that universe operates. But with much better controls, and you can fly cool jet planes if you want to.
- goda90 10y agoFor me, Factorio fills the planning game niche really well. If you don't plan right, you'll find your factory grinding to a halt as your resources are trickling in instead of flowing efficiently. "Refactoring" doesn't feel like the worst chore in the world, rather you can quickly tear things down and redesign much quicker than a lot of strategy games.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoThat's one of the more egregious problems, but there's also things like the fact that placing a bed down and placing a workshop down has completely unrelated keys; manufacturing two different types of objects, ditto. I haven't played the recent versions, but organizing a military is something that's hideously difficult, and most of the guides for organizing your dwarves duties - the tasks they're allowed to perform, according to their skillsets - is best done with a third-party program that reads and edits memory directly. (You can do it in game, but you better have a notepad so you can record your dwarves' skills, and then use that data to actually assign them tasks.) I used to play pretty regularly for a long while, and I still kept a notes.txt file with all of the various key combinations required to do the most basic of tasks. If your profession is UX/UI design, you are probably going to take weeks off your life with the raised blood pressure this game will cause you.
- MrMember 10y agoThe in-game job management interface effectively becomes unusable once your fortress reaches a certain size. It requires a third party program to manage jobs without wanting to tear your hair out.
- Natsu 10y agoOdd, I never really felt that way, I just put certain jobs on repeat and kept huge stockpiles of food, booze, etc. The quantum stockpiles of stone help, though.
- RugnirViking 10y ago> bed down and placing a workshop down has completely unrelated keys; b (build) > b (bed) - b (build) > w (workshops) > a specific workshop - I wouldn't say entirely unrelated or unintuitive. However, other examples, such as organizing a military, are particularly egregious and I would agree, although I do love the game.
- cannonpr 10y agoTo be honest, most people play dwarf fortress with considerably plugin assistance, including the much needed Dwarf therapist. However I feel like the complaining over the interface is really unnecessary, any interface would struggle with the level of depth that the game exposes. I feel like most would struggle to come up with a sensible interface for such a game...
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> any interface would struggle with the level of depth that the game exposes But there are plugins that make doing certain tasks much, much easier. So a reasonable interface can be made. DF's interface doesn't struggle, it lays down and moans.
- crooked-v 10y agoFor an example, Dungeon Crawl Stone Soup is a game that took the complexity of content-filled roguelikes (commands for every key on the keyboard, multiple mode-switches for many commands, layered tileset mapping, etc) and added a beautiful and easy-to-understand and accessible mouse-driven UI and graphical tileset to it, without harming pure-keyboard accessibility. It's completely possible, it just takes some effort.
- lfowles 10y agoIt should also be noted that the DCSS devs are pretty aggressive in cutting un-fun gameplay. (Example: One character will _always_ benefit from praying over a corpse? It automatically happens now.)
- chongli 10y agoTo be fair, DCSS's development team have taken a hacksaw to TONS of the game's more complex and esoteric features, all in the name of streamlining. This has made it a lot simpler than a game like NetHack, for example.
- 10y ago
- dexwiz 10y agoDwarf Fortress is a developer game. Last I checked, you need mods to get any graphics beyond basic ascii characters. Practically everything is a keyboard shortcut that needs to be memorized. It makes the player feel like they're an operator from the Matrix trilogy. It's interesting that by completely ignoring UI/UX the developers (2 brothers) have managed to create one of the most in depth worlds imaginable. This makes it completely unaccessible to the wider world, but beloved by the core audience and respected by any nerd that tried to read through a tutorial. It's found success in being the antithesis of a AAA game, which is usually beautiful but shallow. I wonder if there could ever be another Dwarf fortress? Or if the target audience is too small to support another game.
- nathas 10y agoNetHack springs to mind.
- crooked-v 10y agoNethack's menus and extended commands are much better thought-out and consistent than DF's equivalents.
- philsnow 10y agoI would say that Nethack's are only "better thought-out", not "much better thought-out": Nethack was my first roguelike, 20+ years ago. A year or two ago I played Brogue, and realized just how crufty Nethack is. Let me see if I can remember all the item-specific commands, just from muscle memory. 'w' is for wielding weapons, to unwield you 'w' '-'. For armor, 'W' puts it on, 'T' takes it off. For rings/amulets, 'P' puts it on, 'R' takes it off. For missile weapons, 't' is for throw, 'f' is for fire (be sure you select something to be in your quiver with 'Q' first!). potions are quaffed with 'q', scrolls and spellbooks are read with 'r', wands are zapped with 'z', spells are cast with 'Z', food is eaten with 'e', tools (like candles etc) are applied with 'a'. In Brogue, every kind of equipment is equipped with 'e' and removed with 'r'. Every item that has an effect is invoked with 'a'. There are no spells; instead of memorizing spells you find staves that you then 'a', and they occupy space in your inventory just like a weapon. If you like roguelikes and haven't played Brogue, give it a shot. Also, take a read through nethack's source and Brogue's source, and you'll see that the cleanliness of Brogue's design is reflected in its code.
- piptastic 10y agoIf you like Dwarf Fortress, but hate the interface, you may want to try out Rimworld. http://store.steampowered.com/app/294100/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/294100/ It has a similar playstyle, but with graphics and a UI that isn't too bad. Not the best UI, but not bad at all.
- ClayM 10y agoRimWorld is wonderful, everybody should play it.
- AcerbicZero 10y agoAgreed. I played a little DF, but I just didn't have the motivation to deal with the learning curve. Rimworld on the other hand at least makes a respectable effort to be approachable, even if it can rapidly spiral out of control.
- caconym_ 10y agoRimworld is great. The interface always kept me away from DF, but I had some good times with Rimworld even though it's significantly less complex (no Z-levels, for instance). The first time I played it, I ended up with a Donner party-esque situation in which my medicine had run out, everyone was dying from infected wounds inflicted by raider attacks, and the few colonists still on their feet were fully occupied feeding the spoiled remains of the dead to the barely-living. Colonists were dying faster than the survivors could dig graves for them. It was brutal.
- waiseristy 10y agoAfter you spend some time in DF, the interface isn't bad at all. Actions are separated into semi-logical sections, you get a feel for what keys navigate what menus ect. Tools like dwarf therapist and dfhack alleviate the worst of the UI problems. The real problem with DF is in its performance. Any fort more than a few hours old will grind to a halt as 100+ dwarfs pathing algorithms compete for a single thread. Fluids further impact performance, and if you get invaded? Have fun with 10-15 FPS until you give up. It's extremely disappointing as these late game interactions are usually the most fun.
- schmichael 10y agoI have played hundreds of hours of DF over many years and the interface is still awful. There are aspects of the UI I enjoy as a vim user. At best it can feel a lot like composing vim commands. However at worst it's as this article outlines: obtuse, inscrutable, and lacking in consistency. Stockpiles are bad, but probably not even the worst interface. There are many aspects to job orders and militia management I still don't fully understand how to manage today.
- cryoshon 10y agoi too have stockholm syndrome
- zer00eyz 10y agoDwarf fortress has a UI that is on par with learning regex. If you can master dwarf fortresses interface, then you can learn linux, regex, sed and awk. That having been said, the game is amazing, and has a valuable lesson involved: "loosing is fun".
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoThat's total and absolute nonsense. Speaking as a linux user with a good bit of experience with sed, awk, and regex, DF is way worse.
- norea-armozel 10y agoYeah, I'm going to confirm that it was easier for me to install and run my first Linux distro (Slackware) back in '99 than it was to play Dwarf Fortress. Seriously, anyone who can get a fortress to last a year in-game amazes me.
- slackstation 10y agoAs someone who also first installed Debian in 98 from a single floppy disk netboot image, a memorized FTP site domain, a cable modem connection and a whole night of hoping, I wholeheartedly agree, Dwarf Fortress is way, way harder. Every year I pick it up and play it for a bit just show myself that I can do it. These days, I watch streams of people playing the game on Youtube or I play Rimworld if I'm in the mood for actually playing something myself. I've never been able to have the patience to get to one of the really interesting kinds of fortresses that have steam-powered defenses that tunnel hordes of enemies strategically through your base only have them burned to death. Also, the game is single threaded so there's a very linear limit of how many dwarves and interesting emergent things can happen in your fortress. God, I miss playing that game. When it's good, it's the best there. I've wanted to learn Rust for the express purpose of making a faster, multi-threaded DF-like game.
- qwertyuiop924 10y ago
- jfoutz 10y agoIMHO, the interface of dwarf fortress enhances the medieval fantasy experience. Each little detail has to be managed in it's own arcane way. It's the UI equivalent of the vice chancellor explaining to a cooper that buckets and barrels should be stored in separate locations. The cooper would of course go on a long tirade about how his father, and his father's father stored things this way, and that worked flawlessly for them. Perhaps i just let my imagination run a little wild while i wait for those little 'g' s to come and try to kill my guys. The UI is terrible. The UI is part of the charm. You get the experience Tarn wants, not the experience you want. Art is not required to be accessible. (it often is, and that's often good) but some experiences can't be handed to you in a gift wrapped package. There is no royal road.
- logfromblammo 10y agoHmph. You're not really having fun until you're having !!XxXFunXxX!!.
- caconym_ 10y agoYou can get a good feel for how ridiculously complex the simulation of Dwarf Fortress is just by reading the bugs: http://www.bay12games.com/dwarves/mantisbt/view.php?id=9195 http://www.bay12games.com/dwarves/mantisbt/view.php?id=9195 Cats were walking through spilled beer, licking it off their fur (as cats do), and dying of alcohol poisoning.
- patmcguire 10y agoThe best bug was an old one where carps would get stronger from swimming, which, living in water, they did constantly, thus making them invincible murder fish.
- phaedrus 10y agoIIRC this was exacerbated by the fact that their bite was coded as (or similar to) a "punch" which actually would not have been so bad, except (1) a dwarf hit by it had a 50/50 chance of falling into water and (2) carp appeared in packs...
- intended 10y agothe bug was exacerbated by carp having teeth, thus giving them a bite. except they were able to bite across the water tile and onto the shore, thus engaging combat. this resulted in death because dwarves, as a rule, dont know how to swim unless trained.
- kaybe 10y agoI've never laughed so hard at a bug list. It's hilarious, and that's only the first glance at the open issues.
- AcerbicZero 10y agoI gave up on DF, and get my crazy colony simulator needs met by Rimworld now....but I did get addicted to LCS for awhile, which is another horrible interface attached to a gem of a game, made by the DF devs.
- RugnirViking 10y agoI have not heard of this game. can you link me to it?
- danielvf 10y agoThe best part about this article is that the author left all the quality levels disabled. After all that work, the stockpile still won't accept any goods.
- VLM 10y agoThat was a refreshing article in that far too many historical articles were along the lines of "If only it had pretty art and maybe some celebrity voices then it would be awesome". Those articles are very annoying. Note that not all of DF is as obscure as the example in the article. I've never tried doing what the author tried and I salute the author for bravery in trying it. Most activities in DF are fairly straightforward. This article did remind me that I haven't sent the brothers some $$ in awhile, if you send them $$ they send you hand drawn art vaguely inspired by DF. http://www.bay12games.com/support.html http://www.bay12games.com/support.html
- patmcguire 10y agoDoes the author play console games? This is about average for a PS4 menu.
- gnidan 10y agoDwarf Fortress is definitely a developer game. I love how the game allows you to creatively stand-up industries of scale. For instance, (shamelessly plugging), the game has minecarts, which transport goods point-to-point, following some track. To avoid having to lay track for each route separately, I devised a system of logic components that will allow routes to share track, via automated routing: http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/User:Gnidan#Minecart_Routing http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/User:Gnidan#Minecart_... The routing system uses synchronization primitives to ensure that each shared track segment is only occupied by at most one minecart at a time. Using this guarantee, I have my system switch track exits accordingly, so each minecart in transit gets sent to the right place. GIF for anyone who might be interested: https://i.imgur.com/nC3dfLK.gif https://i.imgur.com/nC3dfLK.gif And the save file: http://dffd.bay12games.com/file.php?id=11721 http://dffd.bay12games.com/file.php?id=11721
- robohamburger 10y agoI think the UI is the least of the game's problems. It seems like each release Toady introduces more bugs and game design problems than solutions. It is still worth playing for the weird level of detail and depth but I have a hard time having as much fun as I once had. I recommend rimworld if you just want to have fun, though it doesn't quite have the level of emergent shenanigans happening in it yet.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI haven't played in awhile; what sorts of new bugs and design problems have cropped up? I used to read the blog posts regularly, but I don't really care about the art-and-history simulator, or the single-player mode, so I stopped keeping up with it.
- jogjayr 10y agoI've made 3 separate attempts to get into DF: read tutorials, watched Youtube videos, the whole shebang. The incomprehensible UI drove me away every time. Having said that, I love that something like DF exists, even if I can never enjoy it. I think the world is better off for it, in some small way.
- fapjacks 10y agoI can't decide if this guy is being serious or just deadpan. It's very well-executed if it's just a deadpan delivery of a typical gamer -- who is used to mashing no more than six different buttons -- trying DF for the first time. Well, maybe the fortieth or fiftieth time, if he's a really quick learner.
- epaga 10y agoAs I do whenever Dwarf Fortress comes up, let me retell the tragic story of Môsom. Remember that nothing in this story is embellished. It all happened within the simulation. Dwarf Fortress is at the very least the best story generator game of all time. I needed to tap a source of water to create a nice waterfall in my dining room. Everything was prepared: the waterfall would fall through the dining room, and then a channel under the dining room led off the side of the map through a fortification. All I needed to do was open the wall of the tunnel which was touching my water source. Feeling too lazy to channel in from above (and slightly evil), I decided to go ahead and sacrifice a dwarf for the effort. I had the dwarf wall itself in and then open the wall. Two seconds later multiple bad things were revealed about this decision: - The dwarf was actually a mother carrying her child under her arm - The water was under high pressure. - I had forgotten to make a floodgate to stop the water if needed. The water shot out of the wall, instantly killing the baby and smashing the mom against the wall of the tunnel. She was dragged along by the water, fell down the waterfall and was pushed up against the fortification on the edge of the level with two broken legs and a bruised spleen. The baby's corpse was caught under the waterfall right underneath the dining room and wasn't going anywhere. The mother kept trying to run upstream but was unable to. I felt pretty bad at this point. But thinking there was not much I would be able to do since the mother would certainly die soon anyways, I just tried to quiet my bad conscience and focus on other things, awaiting the inevitable message the mother had died. A day later the baby's corpse started to fill my dining room up with miasma, making me have to wall out the waterfall to keep my dwarves from vomiting. Quite poetic justice, really: the stench of death was on my waterfall. I was still waiting for the message that the mom had died. It didn't come. After a week of game time or so I looked to see what she was doing and my jaw hit the floor. She was FISHING. The mom was fishing to stay alive while drinking the water. She was in an obviously really bad mood having witnessed death and the decomposition of her child. But she was barely staying sane because she was being "comforted by a lovely waterfall". That did it for me. I finally decided to launch a rescue mission to save her. Not 2 seconds after I had given the command to dig a tunnel to where she was, she went insane and died of thirst shortly after. I was too late. sniff Her name was Môsom.
- RugnirViking 10y agoI love these stories. DF is truly my favorite game.
- Eric_WVGG 10y agoSad to see so many apologists for bad interface, but I didn't expect any better. "It's an amazing game" and "It's for developers" are not excuses for poor UI. Complexity is not any more of an excuse than the inconsistent order of arguments or use of underscores in PHP is defensible. Reminds me of an argument I once had with my brother-in-law, a psychologist, over academic writing. He argued that the obtuse, frequently unreadable style was simply "how they're done." Good writing is simple and logical — every academic would benefit from a semester of journalism, where deliberately bad writing isn't tolerated.
- imode 10y agoI've always wondered how Dwarf Fortress stores its three-dimensional world... anybody have any information on that? considering the size of the worlds involved, I'd imagine some interesting methods are in play to keep the worlds at a suitable size. Dwarf Fortress is kind of this interesting standard of complexity over interface design. prioritizing depth over a pretty UI seems to really do wonders in development..
- xuejie 10y agoI'm just curious: am I the only one thinking that Dwarf Fortress actually has acceptable(if not good) UI? In most cases the screen will hint you what keys you can press to perform action. Yes I admin the UI is not so good whatsoever and in certain cases it's confusing, but it really is a question which you are comparing it to. For example in roguelikes such as Nethack, there's no hint on the screen at all and you will have to go to a specific long help page to read about it. The result is: you will have to first memorize a lot of commands to be able to play the game. If I'm programming using vim, I certainly agree that memorizing all those commands will boost my productivity and I'm willing to do so. But for fun time, I'm not sure if I want to memorize those many commands first to have some leisure time.
- Zandikar 10y agoI would say it has good UX, but not good UI. There is a difference.
- xuejie 10y agoYeah of course, I agree
- RugnirViking 10y agoInterestingly I would agree but after trying to play adventurer mode, that one has some more immediately obvious problems, like no prompt for how to eat.