17 ms·
Will We Ever Know What Dark Matter Is?
- ifdefdebug 10y agoA bit off-topic, but not totally: I am so sick of nautil.us spamming my back button into oblivion that I won't click a nautil.us link never more, until they fix that and someone here say it is fixed.
- delecti 10y agoI normally just open things in a new tab, avoids that problem entirely. But just for you, I clicked the link normally, waited for it to load, hit back, and ended right back up at the HN page. So either an adblocker fixes the problem, or they have.
- jansenv 10y agoBack button doesn't work at all for me once I scroll partway down. It just bumps me back to the top of the article and then loops infinitely
- mikeash 10y agoThey seem to be adding history items when you scroll. Try scrolling down the page some, then going back. It took me about ten clicks to get back when I tried it.
- mirimir 10y agoIn Firefox, I just right-click on the back button, and select.
- ifdefdebug 10y agoYeah sure, http://imgur.com/a/iPGOv http://imgur.com/a/iPGOv so which one am I going to select? This is after one tick down with the mouse wheel.
- mirimir 10y agoWoah, that is unreal. And upon retesting, I see the same, sometimes. But sometimes, there are just a few extra nautil.us lines. And for sure, opening a new tab is the safe bet.
- e2e8 10y agoYet another reason to browse with javascript selectively disabled.
- Aardwolf 10y agoI don't think we will ever know the answers to fundamental philosophical questions such as why or how the universe exists. However, dark matter is measurable physics. I'm sure if technology and knowledge keep getting better we'll be able to solve this one, but it won't help with the aforementioned fundamental philosophical questions.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoThe how is likely just another question of physics; I recall watching some PBS special that hypothesized some collision of higher-dimensional branes.
- ghkbrew 10y agoEven if it is a question of physics that doesn't mean it's an answerable one. There may be impenetrable barriers between us and any supposed higher-order multiverse. Even in this universe, it's possible to be entirely cut off from regions. What does a black hole look like inside its event horizon? We have models, but it's impossible to measure. On a larger scale, assuming the continue expansion of the universe, the furthest galaxies will eventually be receding from us faster than the speed of light, making them un-observable.
- StyloBill 10y agoSo how do these branes exist? The fundamental question remains.
- iaw 10y agoI don't think the fundamental question is how these branes exist. The fundamental question is: what's the most basic truths that we can ever know? If there are hyperdimensional branes the likelihood is that we wont be able to learn much about their origins because of their relationship to our universe. An acceptable answer then becomes "We can't know how they exist..."
- flukus 10y agoI was watching a documentary on an early christian sect (forget which one) the other day who believed that the earth/physical universe wasn't created intentionally but the result of a great cataclysm on a higher realm of existence. Brane theory was what came to mind immediately for me.
- arca_vorago 10y agoedit: got reemed for even attempting, read below
- tps5 10y agoI think it comes off as a little crazy to hypothesize about these things if your level of experience is basically reading wikipedia (as mine is). I think you can gain a lot of understanding that way (plus enjoyment), but I don't think that kind of surface level understanding can be easily extended into new theories. In order to generate new theories, I would imagine that you need a background in the math behind all this stuff. Anyway, as to your last point: my understanding is that entanglement in no way implies "close to instant communication." The speed of light is the still the upper limit on transferring information [0]. [0] http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/15282/quantum-entanglement-faster-than-speed-of-light http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/15282/quantum-ent...
- russdill 10y agoYour theory seems to be based on pop-science understanding of concepts like entanglement. A physicist listening to you would just smile and nod their head. There is no need for particles to pass through a single point for entanglement to be a thing. Both the standard model and quantum theory tell us that such an event isn't possible. And as far as I understand, you don't have matter until 10^-12s, well after cosmic inflation. Quantum entanglement is not a force, does not cause particles to do things, and cannot be used to build a quantum internet. It merely refers to the fact that although quantum states cannot be known till measured, even distantly separated particles will satisfy quantum relations (opposite spin for two particles, etc). They satisfy them in such a way that they either somehow communicated, knew all along, or other possible strange options discussed in multiverse theory. Bell's inequalities prove that they did not know all along. Dark matter can't be ordinary matter in a second universe because it doesn't interact with itself. It'd have to be dark matter in another universe. Which would be indistinguishable from dark matter in this universe. Nothing in physics seeks to do anything. The idea that matter would get together and plan to form black holes so that it can transition into some other state is just silly. You are trying to solve problems that don't exist, with physics that don't exist. Please, read up on: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_exclusion_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_exclusion_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncertainty_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncertainty_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronology_of_the_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronology_of_the_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_entanglement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_entanglement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell's_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell's_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter
- Figs 10y agoHave we already ruled out the possibility of dark matter just being huge numbers of black holes without notable accretion disks?
- pvg 10y ago"It certainly isn’t any ordinary object or particle—that has long since been ruled out" is the first sentence of the second paragraph.
- nol13 10y agoNot completely, but seemingly unlikely. http://resonaances.blogspot.ch/2016/06/black-hole-dark-matter.html http://resonaances.blogspot.ch/2016/06/black-hole-dark-matte...
- Figs 10y agoThanks for the link. Just found this one from NASA as well: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2016/nasa-scientist-suggests-possible-link-between-primordial-black-holes-and-dark-matter https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2016/nasa-scientist-sug... So, it seems like it's still an open possibility, and even better, it might be resolvable one way or the other in the near future -- at least for the primordial black hole hypothesis.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoMy favorite pet theory (head-canon may be a more appropriate term) is that Dark Matter is a set of matter that's just as rich and interactive as ours - made up of particles that follow the analogue of our laws, with weak, strong and electromagnetic forces - but slightly different, so that that parallel universe is full of intelligent life, investigating "shadow matter" that only interacts via gravity, wondering how sad and empty and dark it must be for those particles that make up only 10% of the universe.
- antognini 10y agoHeh. The issue is that all the "shadow stars" and "shadow planets" would have been detected via gravitational microlensing.
- QuantumGravy 10y agoUnless, say, there were enough such parallel worlds to smudge the effects on smaller than galactic scales.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI'm not thinking "parallel worlds" in the Sliders sense, just in the "dark matter" sense. If there were "enough" to blur it out, each one would likely not have enough mass to really have a complete universe. On the other hand, if we only make up 15% of the known mass of the universe, that's room enough for 5 more parallel shadow universes living beside us! Or maybe dark matter just doesn't need as much mass for intelligent life to develop. Who says they need stars and planets?
- QuantumGravy 10y agoParallel as in further "up" and "down" along some unperceived Nth-dimensional axis sorta thing, as I'm imagining it. We'd be some percentage of dark matter to every other "known universe", ourselves, in a cosmological principle sense, not particularly unique or special. If the gravitational force also falls off along such an axis, assumptions about what percentage each parallel universe consists of becomes more complicated. The nearer ones could be more massive than otherwise expected. Each successive parallel universe would also contribute a smaller amount to the whole.
- ClayFerguson 10y agoThere is no evidence that dark matter even exists other than the fact that our universe is not expanding at the rate we think it should, based on our current theory of gravity and how much mass we can account for based on the radiation currently reaching us (light). I think it's far more likely that our theory is incomplete rather than some whole new class of invisible matter/energy being conjured into existence just to counter-balance our 1) wrong equations and/or 2) wrong observations. So many non-scientists think dark matter is proven. It isn't. It's nothing but pure conjecture.
- Pica_soO 10y agoEh, those galaxys would fling themselves apart without it? Is this irony?
- ClayFerguson 10y agoNo one knows why space is expanding. The dark energy is just the 'label' they give to whatever is causing it to expand. Both dark matter and dark energy are postulated to be whatever shape of puzzle piece fits into the puzzle slot where the error in our formulas exists. What i'm saying is that it's more likely that the formula itself is wrong than it is that something magically exists to conveniently fit that slot.
- raattgift 10y ago> The dark energy is just the 'label' they give to whatever is causing it to expand This depends on how you look at it. In the standard cosmology we define a preferred frame wherein an observer will see the matter (that's in the most general sense of "not the gravitational field", so it includes atoms and their components, photons, and various types of dark matter (e.g. neutrinos, which are "hot" dark matter, since they move relativistically and do not experience electromagnetism)) content of the universe as homogeneous and isotropic. This is physically reasonable since along every unobscured line of sight we see a lot of galaxies of various shapes, "tilts", sizes, surface brightnesses, and spectral lines. Observations also lead us to conclude that there is a relationship between redshifting of the spectral lines of common types of galaxies (and common radiative occurrences within them, like type A supernovas), and the change of the other observables (angular size on the sky, luminosity, etc.) that correlate with greater distance. This in turn led to the discovery of the Hubble "constant", and provoked ever deeper field telescopic studies to prove its value. So if we assume that along every line of sight, including obscured ones, we have much the same view of many many galaxies at a variety of distances, we can make a variation on the Friedmann equation that parameterize several things that would lead to the observables of galaxies when we model their known (and unknown) components as a set of perfect fluids. We can take the Hubble "constant" and put it into a Robertson-Walker vacuum spacetime. RW spacetimes can be grokked by dimensional reduction. Consider a cylinder that we slice (foliate) along its axis into a set of infinitesimally thin circles stacked on top of each other. We describe the radius of each circle with a function r(h) where h is the height of the circle from the base of the cylinder. Where r(h) is constant, we have a cylinder, but if r(h) increases with h, then we have something like a cone balancing on its apex; r(h) can describe a wide variety of shapes. For an 3+1 RW spacetime that is similar to our universe, we foliate on the timelike axis and define a function a(t) where t_0 == now with the spacelike coordinates set on a chosen observer (us here on Earth, for example). "t" counts upwards as we go into the past from t_0, and a(t) goes to zero as t increases. "t" is the lookback time and a(t) is the scale factor. The chosen observer is the special observer mentioned above, who sees the matter of the universe as isotropic and homogeneous at the largest scales. The most useful coordinates on such a spacetime are comoving, that is each gravitationally bound galaxy cluster stays at the same coordinates at every time t. If we mix together the Friedmann equations, the Lemaître idea of spacetime having a zero radius at some large lookback time, and the RW spacetime that can model that, we get the FLRW model of the standard cosmology. We take the RW case where there is no extrinsic curvature, that is, when we foliate on the timelike axis each spacelike hypersurface is spatially flat; that is similar to saying that when we slice up our dimensionally reduced solid along its height, we get a set of circles of the same radius (i.e. a cylinder rather than a cone). We absorb the expansion parameter into a(t) as another of the fluids. We then consider two types of fluid: those that dilute away as t -> t_0 -> future and those that do not dilute away. The former is "matter", including dark matter; the latter is "dark energy". When we consider them as components of an action, diluting-away fluids are attractive and non-diluting fluids are repuslive. When we consider them in terms of the matter tensor T in General Relativity, the diluting-away fluids have positive pressure and the non-diluting fluids have negative pressure. It's important to return to the point that this model has a preferred frame, and that translating the non-diluting fluid into "the same for all observers in all frames of reference" physics leads one to assume that dark energy is just a feature of the Lorentz-invariant vacuum. So dark energy arises in the cosmological model but corresponds to the ground state of the empty-of-matter spacetime in frames of reference other than the preferred one picked out by the cosmological model. That is, the statement that "dark energy drives the expansion (via negative pressure or repulsion)" is frame-dependent, and thus observer-dependent, and with a change of frames of reference (and even a change of coordinates on the preferred frame), the statement becomes untrue. What is true in all frames is that there is an intrinsic property of space in an expanding spacetime that has a constant energy-density no matter how large a volume of space is considered. The exact equation of state of dark energy is an area of active research and also tests to make sure that the assumptions that inevitably lead to it (isotropy at huge scales, homogeneity, spatial flatness, redshift-distance relations and other things implying expansion) are not blown up by evidence from ever finer observations. So it's not so much a 'label' as a phenomenon whose microscopic details have yet to be discovered. There are lots of those in physics, and we've had a good century of probing the microscopic details of phenomena discovered at the end of the 19th century and since, so this shouldn't really be causing anyone sleepless nights.
- Zigurd 10y agoDark matter as particles, rather than some undiscovered gravitational effect at galactic scale, seems like a difficult case to make. If it is particles, the distribution of dark matter in a galaxy has to be highly dependent on the distribution of ordinary matter, or vica versa, and yet there is no interaction. I'd bet on gravity waves and/or quantum mechanical gravity effects leading to an explanation, rather than the discovery of a new class of matter.
- millstone 10y agoDark matter as particles seems like a natural case to me: 1. We know that some particles don't see some forces, e.g. leptons don't experience the strong nuclear force. So it's natural to expect particles that don't see the electromagnetic force. 2. Dark matter and ordinary matter do interact through gravity, which is the force that governs cosmic structures. So the distribution of dark and normal matter will be naturally related.
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> If it is particles, the distribution of dark matter in a galaxy has to be highly dependent on the distribution of ordinary matter, or vica versa, and yet there is no interaction. Incorrect. The distributions do appear to be interdependent, in exactly the way you'd expect if the two kinds of "matter" interacted only gravitationally.
- Zigurd 10y agoYes, that's true. But are there arrangements of dark matter that are not holding visible matter galaxies together? Does dark matter appear anywhere else?
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoHow would we know? The only thing it would do is create some extra gravity where there is no visible source of it. You could infer its existence from indirect effects, but it would be extremely tricky.
- twilightfog 10y agoAnother promising theory is that dark matter isn't even necessary, we only assume its present due to its gravitation effect, and that can be explained by other phenomenon. Gravity decreases in proportion to distance squared between objects, but its not observed beyond a certain distance. To compensate, that space was assumed to be filled with dark matter. This theory suggests that gravity switches from a inverse-square law to a different set of rules after a certain distance. https://www.quantamagazine.org/20161129-verlinde-gravity-dark-matter/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/20161129-verlinde-gravity-dar...
- lutusp 10y ago> Gravity decreases in proportion to distance squared between objects, but its not observed beyond a certain distance. This isn't true. F = GMmr^-2 has infinite range. This is true from a theoretical standpoint, and it's also borne out in observations. The Andromeda Galaxy, presently 2.5 million light-years away, is being pulled toward our galaxy and will eventually collide with it. Observations on an even larger scale support the idea that the equation has infinite range. The above theoretical construct could in principle be contradicted by observations, and if it were, someone would win a Nobel Prize, so there's every incentive to find persuasive evidence that contradicts it.
- martincmartin 10y agoThe Andromeda Galaxy, presently 2.5 million light-years away, is being pulled toward our galaxy and will eventually collide with it. To support an inverse square law, we'd need to know the mass of our galaxy, and the mass of the Andromeda galaxy. We have the speed, computed from various blueshift methods. We'd also need to know the rate at which the speed changes. Do we know any of those three? The mass of the Andromeda galaxy is very different if you assume its filled with dark matter, vs. only has visible matter. Which mass is used to confirm the inverse square law? If it includes dark matter, you have circular reasoning: dark matter is hypothesized to make the inverse square law work within the Andromeda galaxy. If it doesn't include dark matter, then why does the dark matter in the Andromeda galaxy contribute to its rotational motion, but not the attraction to the Milky Way?
- platz 10y agoI like to look through the lens of quantum field theory instead of 'particles'. Dark matter may be some field or interaction of existing fields that we don't understand yet.
- mattlogan 10y agoHaving just finished reading Lisa Randall's "Dark Matter and the Dinosaurs," I was a bit disappointed to not see any mention of her new "dark disk" hypothesis. Maybe her research is a bit more "fringe," but it seems like all of these experiments are pretty far out there. The "dark disk" hypothesis basically says that there are actually multiple types of dark matter particles, and there's a disk made of heavier or more strongly interacting dark matter particles in a disk shape overlapping with the milky way disk. More on that here: https://www.quantamagazine.org/20160412-debate-intensifies-over-dark-disk-theory/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/20160412-debate-intensifies-o...
- WhoBeI 10y agoOf course we will or rather we will understand what causes the phenomenon which we attribute to dark matter. I don't really see the failures mentioned in the article as failures. We had an idea about how nature works, tested it and showed that we were wrong. It's just the scientific method at work.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoYup. This is how the sausage is made (the scientific sausage). Some do not like it, but others find it fascinating.
- lutusp 10y agoI wish nautil.us would fix their broken page design so it doesn't fill one's browser history with duplicate links and keep one from leaving the site. This isn't a design choice, it's parasitic.
- tyfon 10y agoPersonally I think that "dark matter" is not matter at all, but ripples that form valleys and hills in the space-time membrane like a plastic bag that has been stretched (by the big bang) and crumpled slightly back. But I am not a physicist so it is purely speculation from my part and I have no math to back it up. It's just the way I picture it in my head :)
- bborud 10y agoThe Big Fudge Factor In The Sky Without Which We Look Silly.
- lngnmn 10y agoWe know what it is. It is a socially constructed abstract concept, like "god" or "afterlife" or "pure substances" of Spinoza. BTW, the "substance propositions" Spinoza has been developed are perfectly sound, except one small flaw - no such phenomena as pure substance ever existed. Dark Matter and related crap is of exactly the same nature - much more sophisticated phantoms of the mind supported by a sect of believers.
- iaw 10y agoI've downvoted your comment because your tone isn't constructive and you're making a rather illogical jump to the philosophical arguments of Spinoza in comparison to questions around modern measurable/observable phenomena in science. If you'd like to make a less hostile post with a clearer justification of your reasoning I'd be more than happy to debate the subject with you.
- lngnmn 10y agoI do not have anything to add. As a student of philosophy I have seen way to many socially constructed chimeras and memes to not notice modern ones. The only criteria for establishing a scientific truth is still a replicable experiment which proves an implementation according to some established law. Any simulation does not account for such kind of experiment, being mere a "cartoon" made according to some abstract model. The difference between experiment and simulation is of the same kind as between a cartoon and actual reality.
- iaw 10y ago> " As a student of philosophy I have seen way to many socially constructed chimeras and memes to not notice modern ones." There's a willful ignorance in this sentence that belies your youth and intelligence. I suspect you don't have an adequate background to understand the observational evidence for our expectation of dark matter (I barely do to be quite honest). I don't think you can fairly dismiss offhand the conclusions drawn by hundreds of expert physicists based on your experience. I've known more than one physicist that were also well-studied students of philosophy. If you have reached a brilliant and well-justified conclusion that they failed to see you should clearly write it to justify your case. >"The only criteria for establishing a scientific truth is still a replicable experiment which proves an implementation according to some established law. Any simulation does not account for such kind of experiment, being mere a "cartoon" made according to some abstract model. The difference between experiment and simulation is of the same kind as between a cartoon and actual reality." Science (and philosophy for that matter) are defined from consistency of observation. I fail to see your point about an experiment measuring a "cartoon" when that is the reality in which we intrinsically exist and for which prediction will provide the most value.
- ww520 10y agoTwo crazy ideas: 1. Dark matter is the "gravity echo" from the past. Gravity is the structural bending of spacetime by mass. The effect of the bending is supposed to travel at the speed of light. What if the effect has been delayed and is added to the present effect? 2. When a mass is moving through spacetime, the bending of spacetime is asymmetric in the leading and trailing directions, where the leading direction forms a leading crust and trailing forms a flatter tail, just like the blue-shift and red-shift effects on light. The leading gravity wave crust adds to the strength of the gravity.
- bronlund 10y agoMost people like to think that science is all about sharing information and that the popular theories are as far as mankind has come to understand the universe. Sadly this is not true. For every scientific discovery which has the potential to be used as a weapon, there will be forces trying to keep it hidden. Instead of looking forward, it may sometimes be more productive to look backwards - especially pre-Einstein. James Clerk Maxwell and his luminiferous aether is as good as theory, if not better, than any modern explanation about what's out there. He even provided us with the math describing it (though is was removed later on). The years after, towards the end of the nineteen century, is full of scientists claiming incredible discoveries - like anti-gravity, free energy, wireless transfer of information as well as power, apparatus for remote viewing and more. Nikola Tesla being the most famous I guess. Think how different the last hundred years would have been if any of it had reached the public domain. On the other hand; making an atom bomb isn't really that complicated (the difficult part is surviving doing it). If every person you know had one, that would probably not work out. My point being that there are arguments for keeping information restricted. Put capital in the mix and it's bound to be some collusion. Imagine you had a grid of antennas and that you could adjust the phase and frequency of each as to get the signals from all of them to be in-phase at a specific point. Everyone visiting this site could probably think of a handful of ways to do exactly that. Then imagine you had a lot of antennas and a lot of juice - you could more or less focus an insane amount of energy wherever you wanted on this planet without anyone being any wiser. What would you do with a power like that? Would you share?
- solipsism 10y agoWhat in the world does all that have to do with the hunt for dark matter? No one has any reason to think dark matter might be usable as a weapon. Any indication that it might would surely become general knowledge long before we could put it to use. Just like e=mc^2
- thethirdone 10y ago> ... ames Clerk Maxwell and his luminiferous aether is as good as theory, if not better, than any modern explanation about what's out there. ... What about the Michelson–Morley experiment? Aether theories have a major flaw that the light does not have a constant speed in all reference frames.
- digler999 10y agosort of OT of the post, but on topic of all the cool discussions about physics we've had here, I want to share one my favorite channels on youtube[1]. Eugene Khutoryansky has put together an amazing collection of very intuitive explanations of all kinds of physics, including cosmology. I also recommend his series on math and electromagnetics. [1] https://www.youtube.com/user/EugeneKhutoryansky https://www.youtube.com/user/EugeneKhutoryansky
- sunstone 10y agoWe will if it isn't.
- acqq 10y agoYes, up to now there's nothing directly detected, but we should also not forget that just two years ago a pessimistic article could have been written about the detection of the gravitational waves, this is how it could have looked like: "predicted 100 years ago, never detected, even if there was some investment in the detectors and specific scientific work for 40 years, and in spite of some indirect evidence." It is also easy imaginable somebody claiming that LIGO shouldn't be funded only to "measure the change of a 4 km length in a tiny fraction of the size of a single proton." But then... hundred years after the prediction, the magnificent thing did happen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_observation_of_gravitational_waves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_observation_of_gravitati... And then another one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GW151226 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GW151226
- ClayFerguson 10y agoSo much of what you said is hilariously wrong. Probably the most acute example is your claim "Standard Model is mute on gravity". Are you kidding me? Page one of any book of the Standard Model discusses the 4 fundamental forces. Guess what one of them is: GRAVITY.
- raattgift 10y agoReally? So what's the gravity term in the Standard Model Lagrangian? [1] > Page one of any book of the Standard Model discusses the 4 fundamental forces. Guess what one of them is: GRAVITY. Well, let's just test this assertion of yours. Right at hand I have Halzen & Martin [2] and "gravity" appears in the index (on p. 389) pointing to pp 27 and 348. Section 1.8 (pp 27-28) explains why gravity is not addressed in the book, and at p. 348 there is a brief discussion following the Weinberg-Salam unification scale at eq 15.58 about whether, given it is large, the gravitational interaction can still be neglected. The treatment there is unsurprisingly fully classical. Maybe you don't like this particular textbook. How about Cottingham & Greenwood [3]? This is an excellent book aimed at grad students, and has the advantage of having its introductory chapter online: Quoting: https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/Cottingham/Cott1_1.html https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/Cottingham/Cott1_1.html "The Standard Model excludes from consideration the gravitational field." Well, at least that's on page one. Who next? How about Griffiths [4]? In the middle of page 50 we find: "This is all adding up to an embarrassingly large number of supposedly 'elementary' particles: 12 leptons, 36 quarks, 12 mediators (I won't count the graviton, since gravity is not included in the Standard Model)." Above are three standard textbooks introducing the Standard Model, and they all support my assertion and not yours. Let's see, here's another item for your consideration: https://home.cern/about/physics/standard-model https://home.cern/about/physics/standard-model "The Standard Model includes the electromagnetic, strong and weak forces and all their carrier particles, and explains well how these forces act on all of the matter particles. However, the most familiar force in our everyday lives, gravity, is not part of the Standard Model, as fitting gravity comfortably into this framework has proved to be a difficult challenge" I would be very keen on any evidence that supports your claim that the Standard Model is not mute on gravity. I'd also be keen on what else you believe I was "hillariously wrong" about. I'd be happy to expand upon, back, or source most of the statements as I do here, if you particularize your complaints and are reasonable and polite about it. And finally, what really are you trying to accomplish here? [1] here's Cottingham & Greenwood's[3] write-down of the SM Lagrangian: http://einstein-schrodinger.com/Standard_Model.pdf http://einstein-schrodinger.com/Standard_Model.pdf which provides the straightforward answer that there is no gravity term. [2] https://www.amazon.co.uk/Quarks-Leptons-Introductory-Particle-Physics/dp/0471887412 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Quarks-Leptons-Introductory-Particl... [3] https://www.amazon.com/Introduction-Standard-Model-Particle-Physics/dp/0521852498/ref=pd_sim_b_1 https://www.amazon.com/Introduction-Standard-Model-Particle-... [4] https://www.amazon.com/Introduction-Elementary-Particles-David-Griffiths/dp/3527406018/ref=pd_sim_b_1 https://www.amazon.com/Introduction-Elementary-Particles-Dav...