5 ms·
I bet making structural changes so that cost of care is more visible to patients would help a lot in the US. Of course this means disincentivizing health care a
by maxerickson 10y ago
I bet making structural changes so that cost of care is more visible to patients would help a lot in the US. Of course this means disincentivizing health care as a benefit rather than incentivizing it, so it will never happen. It is kind of happening with things like HSAs, but not really.
We should also work on removing arbitrary barriers to entering the supply side of the market. Not just for individuals that want to be a doctor or other sort of provider, but certificates of need and such too. Currently, lots of states dictate who can operate a CT scanner.
- TuringNYC 10y agoI agree, opacity is a big part of the problem. I'm super-excited about Castlight Health (http://www.castlighthealth.com/ http://www.castlighthealth.com/) and how they approach the problem (by presenting cost/value scatters and other ways)...but...how obscene is it that we as a country should even need such a service!?
- huangwei_chang 10y agoGood point. I am a bit sad that Castlight seems to be struggling and the stock price is pretty low. I thought it had a good mission and solution.
- softawre 10y agoMy company uses CastLight and it is pretty great. It has been fairly accurate (+/- 10%) the few times I have used it.
- chicagobob 10y agoOnly partially. Often at the time of consumption cost isn't something one can use to make decisions. But for those other times, sure it would help. Speaking of lack of info about pricing you might find this interesting: https://www.statnews.com/2017/02/06/health-insurance-high-deductible-experiment/ https://www.statnews.com/2017/02/06/health-insurance-high-de...
- triangleman 10y agoGreat article. It's not just about pricing info, it's about the nationwide move to HDHP's and HSA's. Personally I'm pretty happy with my HSA, because now the list of things I can spend my healthcare dollar on is much longer: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p502.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p502.pdf Lots of those things would not be covered by a traditional health insurance plan. But of course, it means we have chosen to forego health care and services in some cases, like the author of the article above. In one case we turned down an ambulance and drove ourselves to the hospital, which saved some money.
- HarryHirsch 10y agowe have chosen to forego health care and services in some cases Only in America do you choose to forgo healthcare when you are at a conference and caught food poisoning because you aren't really sure if the hospital will take your health insurance. Where do I apply for my medal for saving the system some money?
- mgkimsal 10y ago"because now the list of things I can spend my healthcare dollar on is much longer:" Longer than what? 8 years ago, I could use HSA funds to pay for over the counter medications. Not anymore, and OTC is generally the first step before visiting a dr or clinic, but OTC is not HSA-usable.
- MR4D 10y agoThis, times 1,000 !! Imagine you go in for an oil change. You ask how much it costs, and find out it's $20. Great. You get the oil change. One month later you get a bill for "environmental disposal" for $35. The next month you get another bill for "Safety specialist" for $15. This is how healthcare works in the US. If retail worked like this, we'd be in a worldwide depression in about 6 months. Lunacy.
- cmollis 10y agoyes.. another 1K. I blame doctors and insurance companies (but mostly the latter.. the former was taken for a ride long ago by the latter). An example of just how ridiculous this is: my son (who is almost 15), was recommended to have a 'pediatric echocardiogram'. The children's hospital that I took him to (a Tier 2 facility in insurance parlance.. which roughly means that my insurance company doesn't own them) indicated that this procedure MIGHT cost up to $5000. So, I asked my insurance company (which I pay 1000 per month to for my three kids and I, in a addition to a 3500 per year deductible), what Tier 1 facility in NJ I could go to, and how much the procedure would cost. They did not know of a facility where this procedure could be done at first. They had to 'research it'. They found a facility, but when I called, they could not perform the procedure because it called for a 'pediatric echo', which they were NOT allowed to do (mind you, it's like the same echocardiogram that you and I would receive). When I presented this information to my insurance company, they had to again, research it. I ignored it, and found it on my own after calling the heart group at one of the teaching hospitals in my state (NJ). So, I asked my insurance company how much it would cost, they refused to tell me. They indicated that they do not dictate pricing; this is the job of the provider. I noted to them that I did not believe them because I knew that they have contracted rates with all of their Tier1 and Tier 2 facilities and they knew exactly what they would reimburse for. They flatly denied that they had any knowledge of pricing and that this was the responsibility of the provider. My response was a question: so, if the provider charged you 1 MILLION DOLLARS for this procedure, you would, in fact, pay it. They indicated that they did not have any pricing knowledge whatsoever. I ended up getting a second opinion and found out the echo wasn't necessary based on follow up findings. It was one of the most frustrating examples of federally mandated RIPOFF I had ever seen. My son's health was at stake, and they simply wouldn't help me. The doctor's are literally at their mercy because they control the money and EVERYONE lets it fucking slide. It's a crime.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> I bet making structural changes so that cost of care is more visible to patients would help a lot in the US. It would, but it would be politically infeasible. Medicare would never let it happen, because providing price transparency in the private market would undermine the convoluted system that allows them to use private insurers to subsidize the care of Medicare patients.
- triangleman 10y agoExplain how. I thought Medicare was rife with fraud and overbilling, so that they end up subsidizing private payers.
- maxerickson 10y agoMedicare is about 1/6 of US healthcare spending so it obviously isn't subsidizing private payers, even if you make a ridiculous assumption like 100% of payments are fraudulent. And then in reality fraud rates seem to be quite low, at most a few percentage points of overall Medicare spending.
- triangleman 10y agoWhat I meant by fraud, was not cases of outright fraud where someone bills Medicare for services never performed, although I'm sure that happens all the time. I meant cases like the late night commercials "call now and get a free motor scooter! Just fill out a simple form and we will bill Medicare." And more relevant are the cases where hospitals bill medicare huge amounts for long patient stays. Medicare always pays what they are billed, after all it's the government paying, they just write a check. Meanwhile if you bill an insurance company they will negotiate, argue, refuse to pay, deny coverage, etc. If you bill an uninsured person they can also just decide not to pay in favor of paying more important bills like food and shelter. So, the hospital is actually fine with this, they simply write off the unpaid amount on their taxes as a charitable expense, and increase rates, which Medicare will pay. So, as you can see, Medicare (plus tax breaks) create a situation where the government subsidizes and distorts everyone else's health care costs.
- HarryHirsch 10y agocost of care is more visible to patients In the US you get to see the cost of care every time you have reason to see the physician - there's the copay for the physician visit and medications, and then there's the explanation of benefits, where you, as a patient, get to reconcile accounts. In NIH Britain OTOH, you get to see nothing of that sort (except a small copay for medication), and healthcare costs are better contained. It's the US that is the outlier, and shifting even more burden on the patient won't fix matters, it hasn't fixed matters in the past.
- maxerickson 10y agoPeople with employer provided insurance don't have much reason to figure out how much their employer is kicking in for the insurance and if they have a modest deductible they also won't care a great deal about the EOB. I do agree that a single payer system that mandated prices would also likely result in lower prices, but I think that is less likely for the US than incremental changes to our current system.
- CaptSpify 10y ago> In the US you get to see the cost of care every time you have reason to see the physician I feel it's important to point out that you see the cost in the bill. There's no reliable way to see the cost beforehand.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoWhat's seeing the expenses going to do, what mechanism is supposed to lower cost? When you need healthcare you need healthcare. No one goes to the physician for fun, elective procedures like breast enlargement or Lasik excepted.
- DanBC 10y agoThe free market argument goes that informed consumers will chose healthcare services, and thus will either drive up quality, or drive down prices. The problem is that the customers cannot see the prices, and thus can't negotiate before hand. This isn't just for emergency care, but for stuff that shouldn't be too hard to get pricing for. There's a nice Vice(?) video about a couple having a baby. They find it impossible to get even an indication of cost before hand. This patient choice stuff made its way to England, and frankly it's dumb. People don't change their utility suppliers even though they'd save large amounts of cash. They don't change their GP unless they've moved house; they don't have enough information to make an informed choice of hospital if they need to go for surgery. It's a lot of bureaucracy that has very little benefit.
- jartelt 10y agoMaybe it would help, or maybe it would do the opposite. Having an HSA and seeing prices upfront can also make one not go to doctor because they do not want to drain their HSA. This can cause people to skip preventative care steps and to not nip potential problems in the bud before they get bad (and expensive). A lot of diseases/conditions are much cheaper to cure/fix if you catch them early, so maybe you don't want to incentivize people to stay away from the doctor.
- PKop 10y agoAnd if more and more people were not going to the doctor, the providers would lower the price (to some degree no?)
- Sanddancer 10y agoOr they raise their prices to get money out of a smaller pool of subscribers. Medical care has a pretty inelastic demand curve.
- DanBC 10y ago> but certificates of need But they came about to protect the consumer from high prices. If I own a hospital and buy a $300,000 MRI machine I need to make that money back over the 10 year life of the machine. I charge one price if it's used by 10 people a day; I need to charge double if it's only used by 5 people a day. The extra supply reduces demand and thus increases prices to the customer. And it's unethical to just scan more and more people, because of the problems of overtesting and overdiagnosis. EDIT: Citation that CONs came about to reduce prices: http://www.ncsl.org/research/health/con-certificate-of-need-state-laws.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/health/con-certificate-of-need-... > The basic assumption underlying CON regulation is that excess capacity stemming from overbuilding of health care facilities results in health care price inflation. Price inflation can occur when a hospital cannot fill its beds and fixed costs must be met through higher charges for the beds that are used. Bigger institutions generally have bigger costs, so CON supporters say it makes sense to limit facilities to building only enough capacity to meet actual need or demand.
- maxerickson 10y agoSure, in theory. In practice it just means that hospitals that do not have local competition use them as a revenue center (MRIs in the US often cost $1000-$2000...paying off your 10 year machine in a few months with 5 patients a day). The US Federal government tried them in the 1980s and quickly decided they were counterproductive.
- arohner 10y agoYou are literally creating a monopoly (one hospital) to justify that will produce lower prices. Please give me one other example in an unregulated market where your MRI machine example makes sense. It sounds good on paper, but that doesn't happen in any other market in the western world. If there are two competing gas stations, prices get cheaper. Two competing airlines, prices get cheaper.
- DanBC 10y agoI don't agree with it! I'm literally quoting the Americans who support certificate of need laws.