3 ms·
> It's very reasonable to assume that everything, EVERYTHING, you do on the internet is recorded and stored by the government. This bill does not address that.
by loeg 10y ago
> It's very reasonable to assume that everything, EVERYTHING, you do on the internet is recorded and stored by the government. This bill does not address that.
I mean, that's hard to believe. I work for a large storage vendor. If this was true, the feds would be our largest customer by far. They aren't. I don't think SE Asia makes enough disk to store everything indefinitely, and given exponential network traffic growth, even storing the most recent few years is a problem.
- dv_dt 10y agoI might consider that they're just not buying it from your company, or you aren't privy to the transactions to those gov't customers. How much storage does 1.5 billion buy? (Ok it's not all just storage...). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_Data_Center https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_Data_Center The explosion of data you mention is a real problem; though thinking about it, one might manage with a mix of light filtering, leaning on organizations that already store the relevant data, etc.
- pbasista 10y agoThat is just one opinion against another. With little fact to support any side. In your comment, for example, you seem to suppose that those agencies do not buy storage on secondary markets. Can you confirm that? Because if they do, then your sales statistics are almost meaningless in this regard. Also, it seems like you assume that everything the agencies collect is stored "as it was transferred" (i.e. if the same YouTube video was viewed millions of times, they would store it in millions of copies). I think it is safe to assume that these agencies are a little bit smarter than that and if they store everything, they have some kind of compression in place to minimize redundant storage of the same chunks of data. In any way, I think that until someone like Snowden speaks up again and brings evidence from inside of these agencies, we are only left with speculation.
- hendersoon 10y agoThere's no speculation on the UK. We know the GCHQ does this. Of course they generate quite a bit less traffic than the USA, given their smaller population. We don't know whether the NSA does "Full Take" today. That's speculation. I would be astonished if they didn't, and it is reasonable to behave as if they do. It's possible, it was possible 4 years ago, and storage is not getting _more_ expensive over time.
- smellf 10y agoExclude all the audio and video data streamed over the internet, as well as the contents of torrent traffic and other data useless to the panopticon (just keep the metadata), and I'd imagine the amount of data you'd be left with would be very possible for the US government to store.