2 ms·
I really don't understand the complaint in the article. > He claimed to have developed a way to raise sea-temperature readings that had been collected by buoys
by viraptor 10y ago
I really don't understand the complaint in the article.
> He claimed to have developed a way to raise sea-temperature readings that had been collected by buoys: He would adjust them by using higher temperature readings of sea water collected by ships.
So actually it's due to ships being used before, that the data needs to be corrected. And they're using comparison between the buoys and the ships running at the same time. This is the same story as the sensors which were running in the cities and needed to be moved into the remote countryside in the US to account for city heat. I get that he doesn't like that the bouys readings were raised rather than ships, but relatively, why would it matter?
The linked article says:
> Now, some of those same authors have produced the pending, revised new version of the sea dataset – ERSSTv5. A draft of a document that explains the methods used to generate version 5, and which has been seen by this newspaper, indicates the new version will reverse the flaws in version 4, changing the buoy adjustments and including some satellite data and measurements from a special high-tech floating buoy network known as Argo.
Soooo.... basically exactly what he wanted?
- nonbel 10y ago>"I get that he doesn't like that the bouys readings were raised rather than ships, but relatively, why would it matter?" I highly doubt they just raised all the buoy data by a single constant. The value probably varied over time and the "reverse" operation would not have exactly the same effects on any trends. We would have to look closer at the paper to see what was actually done though.
- nonbel 10y agoAfter looking it up quickly, it seems that one step really was raising the buoy values by a single constant, but this was only a tiny part of a much more involved process. "The SSTs from ships or buoys were accepted (rejected) under a QC criterion that observed SSTs differ from the first-guess SST from ERSST.v3b by less (more) than 4 times standard deviation (STD) of SST (Smith and Reynolds 2003). The ship and buoy SSTs that have passed QC were then converted into SSTAs by subtracting the SST climatology (1971–2000) at their in situ locations in monthly resolution. The ship SSTA was adjusted based on theNMATcomparators; buoy SSTA was adjusted by a mean difference of 0.12 C between ship and buoy observations (section 5). The ship and buoy SSTAs were merged and bin-averaged into monthly ‘‘superobservations’’ on a 28 3 28 grid. The number of superobservations was defined here as the count of 28 3 28 grid boxes with valid data. The averaging of ship and buoy SSTAs within each 28 3 28 grid box was based on their proportions to the total number of observations. The number of buoy observations was multiplied by a factor of 6.8, which was determined by the ratio of randomerror variances of ship and buoy observations (Reynolds and Smith 1994), suggesting that buoy observations exhibit much lower random variance than ship observations. The SSTAs of superobservations were further decomposed into low- and high-frequency components. The low-frequency component was constructed by applying a 268 3 268 spatial running mean using monthly superobservations where the sampling ratio is larger than 3% (five superobservations). An annual mean SSTA was then defined with a minimum requirement of two months of valid data. The annual mean SSTA fields were screened and the missing SSTAs were filled by searching the neighboring SSTAs within 108 in longitude, 68 in latitude, and 3-yr in time. The search areas were tested using ranges of 158–208 in longitude, 58–108 in latitude, and 2–5 yr..." http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/10.1175/JCLI-D-14-00006.1 http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/10.1175/JCLI-D-14-00006.1 It would be much easier to understand if they just showed us the code...