3 ms·
If I may summarize the blog post to characterize the allegations more accurately than the House press release: NOAA scientist used as the basis for a major cli
by jcranmer 10y ago
If I may summarize the blog post to characterize the allegations more accurately than the House press release:
NOAA scientist used as the basis for a major climate paper a data set which was in an alpha stage in terms of post-processing. This preliminary data should have been at least indicated as such but was not done in the paper submission. The exact differences between the alpha version and released version is not documented, and the dataset used for the paper hasn't apparently been located, so finding the differences is difficult.
Notably, Bates doesn't seem to be accusing Karl et. al. of actually manipulating the data to get spectacular results. Rather, the allegation is that the rush to put out the paper induced Karl et. al. to bypass transparency rules designed to prevent, well, suspicion of the data being manipulated.