3 ms·
How about we demand accountability? That is more important than protecting a political party from criticism. We also need to stop thinking down logical chains
by epistasis 10y ago
How about we demand accountability? That is more important than protecting a political party from criticism.
We also need to stop thinking down logical chains of "well if I accept criticism of this decision, than that means criticizing my side, which weakens that side, so maybe I shouldn't try to hold my party accountable." That's an excessively partisan way to deal with these things.
We can't not criticize the party in power that's doing things just because the other party might have done some things too at some point.
Also, love to see what Democrats have done on this so I can complain to my Democratic congresspeople. Please share!
- exabrial 10y agoRefusing to collaborate with the Republicans: http://www.thewrap.com/democrats-and-republicans-battle-over-competing-net-neutrality-plans http://www.thewrap.com/democrats-and-republicans-battle-over... The "my way or the highway" attitude is something that both parties suffer from. Whoever wins changes every 4 years. Whoever loses stays the same: The people
- epistasis 10y agoYour link does not support your contention that they're refusing to collaborate with Republicans. In fact, your link describes them talking about the loopholes in the proposed legislation. This would seem to actually be cooperation in improving the legislation. >Congressional Democrats and Republicans offered widespread agreement Wednesday that the time has finally come for the government to step in and take action to preserve net neutrality. Then again, they disagreed strongly on the shape that protection should take. I have yet to see party-based Republican support for solid net-neutrality proposals. I have seen some proposals using the name "net neutrality" that in fact undermined it deeply. If you give me some examples of this "my way or the highway" that's something I can push back on my congress people with. It matters who we vote for, "the people" don't lose equally no matter who is in office. This "all politicians are bad" thing comes up frequently when criticizing them, but it's simply not true that all politicians are equal, and it's not an excuse fro their bad behavior. The difference between the Pai and Wheeler are clear and stark. And that's not to say that Pai is innately evil, he still could do some good for the internet, and some of the things he says I agree with. Wheeler was intensely criticized as a shill for cable companies when he entered, however he turned out not to be one in the least. Was it our criticism that had an effect? Who knows, but by calling him out as a former lobbyist, people were at least aware of what was going on. Perhaps if we publicly shame Pai for his bad behavior we'll see the same thing. Let's forget whether we are a D or an R, lets focus on the policies. That's what non-partisanship is.
- exabrial 10y agoAnd that's exactly close minded thought process at the root of the problem. You don't even consider the fact there's another method: let elected members of Congress decide. The problem with wheeler and Pai is that they don't report to us, the people.
- epistasis 10y agoNo, I did consider that congress decide, when I read the news article you linked about it. Any evidence that I didn't consider it? Any evidence that I'm "close-minded"? Or further, any evidence for your original contention, that was unsupported? Or have you just silently admitted that there's no stonewalling, and gone on to other accusations? But considering that Pai is also acting, his actions must also be considered.