4 ms·
Cheap labor isn't the only issue here. Wage theft in the form of capping competition is the big issue. Assume the rate of salary change dS(t)/dt is propotiona
by Chris2048 10y ago
Cheap labor isn't the only issue here.
Wage theft in the form of capping competition is the big issue.
Assume the rate of salary change dS(t)/dt is propotional-to/a-function-of (average_labor_demand - average_labor_supply)
Now, if you keep topping up supply from overseas, salary never increases as much as it might, as such it is limited - as such, salary rate increase is also capped; and it's not employees can have any relief from a lack of demand, other than maybe fewer visas, but I doubt there would be many lobbyists for that... complaints about unemployment or lack of jobs falls on deaf ears - ears stuffed full of money by happy employers...
- okreallywtf 10y agoJust to play devils advocate, wouldn't it eventually even out then because high demand and lower wages here would mean that other countries with a tech sector would have high wages and would then be more appealing, which would encourage H1B visa seekers to consider going elsewhere or would even lure more talent from the US overseas. Granted, like many market-based arguments I make a lot of assumptions about how easily people can move around. Immigrating is hard and once you've immigrated successfully you may not be willing to take the risk of ending up back in the repressive regime you came from (hence, a lot of the issues we have right now) and people in the US may not be nearly as willing to leave the US and go elsewhere. But theoretically (if not in reality) more mobility and access to labor is a good thing.
- Chris2048 10y agoThis would work if all countries were equally desirable, and capable of supporting the same economy. Maybe the US is competing with Europe? But at the moment US salaries are considerably higher.
- strainer 10y agoBy way of an unrealistic formalisation there you actually assumed that salaries are determined exclusively by labour supply and far more predictably and linearly than possible. The complexity of the economy, greatly confounds simplistic formulas.
- Chris2048 10y agoSo you're complaining because my post above isn't a more comprehensive analysis? I was responding to one specific point, not implying that the above formula is a complete model of the economy.
- strainer 10y agoExcuse me it was not a complaint it was a criticism breifly and carefuly explained to be constructive. I was pointing out that if you had wrote: "Assume salaries are determined exclusively, predictably and linearly by labour supply..." the position for your observations would be clearly flawed, so you would have to examine them more and find a better footing for them (which there may well be - i havent wondered). But you did write precisely that case in symbolic form - the technical value of formulas is that they are precise and we write them to be precise, so look at what you assumed there! Good day :)
- Chris2048 10y agoYou are suggesting that a symbolic form implies "precision", further implying "exclusive determination"? I disagree, in this case I used a symbolic form to prevent ambiguity, that is all. The relationship outlined is done so in a precise manner, but it is not comprehensive. also, you'll note I described the relationship as "is-a-function-of", which provides sufficient cover in any case.
- strainer 10y agoIf you used a symbolic form to prevent ambiguity how are you now calling on magic inside of an anonymous function? You even alluded to calculus with "dS(t)/dt" This use of maths was clearly completely stylistic.
- Chris2048 10y ago> You even alluded to calculus with "dS(t)/dt" yes, to allude to a relationship to rate, hence reducing one form of ambiguity, (but not all possible ambiguities!). non-clarity, and purposeful ambiguity is different. Also, be specific on one aspect (in this the on the point I was trying to make) and general else where (any other unrelated economic stuff) is not uncommon or inconsistent.