5 ms·
In any all-out war between two nuclear nations there will be no winner, just two losers.
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
In any all-out war between two nuclear nations there will be no winner, just two losers.
- protomyth 10y agoWell, we better get pretty good at shooting down missiles because North Korea has a bit of the crazy and nuclear weapons. I get the feeling that someone has looked at the Aegis combined with XR standard missiles. I'm not worried about China. I'm worried about the last days of a dictator.
- mikeash 10y agoShooting down one missile is a lot easier than shooting down a hundred. The US has had the ability to defend against an attack from North Korea since the W Bush administration. That capability would barely dent a Chinese attack.
- protomyth 10y agoI wasn't talking about China, just the "any" nuclear power is hopefully becomes a false statement given NK's instability. Do you have a source on the "The US has had the ability to defend against an attack from North Korea since the W Bush administration." for ballistic missiles?
- mikeash 10y agoThis is the system in question: https://www.mda.mil/system/gmd.html https://www.mda.mil/system/gmd.html The interceptors are expensive, so there aren't very many. That's why it can defend against a country like North Korea but not China.
- protomyth 10y agoOk, but why do you keep mentioning China, I said I wasn't worried about China. I'm worried about the crazy folks (e.g. NK) with limited launch capability. China is pretty stable.
- mikeash 10y agoBecause the overall context here is China, the potential for war with China, and the devastation that would result. I want to be clear that our defenses would not prevent that.
- protomyth 10y agoFine, but that wasn't the parent message I was responding to and had nothing to do with my original reply.
- mikeash 10y agoReally, you think "In any all-out war between two nuclear nations there will be no winner, just two losers" in a discussion about war with China wasn't talking about China?
- protomyth 10y agoI provided a counter-example that is much more likely and frankly a lot more worrisome. Plus, I specifically mention what I was worried about. Comments on HN expand out from the topic all the time, and I was pretty specific in my response.
- mikeash 10y agoOk. I responded to what you said and tied it in to the larger conversation. I don't get what your problem is here.
- m3ta 10y agoNot necessarily. It depends on defensive capabilities. It's very possible that two countries get into a conflict thinking it is a mutual assured destruction scenario, only to find out one country is better at neutralizing attacks in-transit.
- rybosome 10y agoAs a resident of Seattle, I'd really rather not have the US' missile defenses tested.
- tokenizer 10y agoActually that's naive. Missile sites, response times, stockpiles, missle tech, defensive shields Nuclear submarines. I get discouraged talking strategy with people who have no clue about modern capabilities. Russia VS US would be game over. Pakistan VS India would decimate 50-70% of World Population - but not game over. China has a very small stockpile of missiles. Also, All of them would get shot down, while Nuclear Subs of the coast of China would destroy every population center. Not to mention, first strike with this capability by the US could mean no war... Just absolute and total victory. So again, per my original point. Trade will be restructured. China KNOWS this!