3 ms·
If I could sell a Mercedes at $20k, that would only be profitable if I could pay <$20k for the car. Mercedes and the economy are missing out because of the com
by briandear 10y ago
If I could sell a Mercedes at $20k, that would only be profitable if I could pay <$20k for the car.
Mercedes and the economy are missing out because of the commerce not being transacted right?
The idea that work that's profitable at $100k and not at $120k -- that means that the work isn't profitable if the market cost is $120.
Everything is profitable if the cost of inputs is less than the sales price. It's an absurd argument.
Essentially, your statement singlehandedly destroys minimum wage arguments. "If I could pay less, then I could be profitable, otherwise I am not profitable and thus won't hire anyone."
But you are also admitting that the purpose of H1 isn't to fill shortages -- it's to fill shortages of people willing to work at a rate below what the market dictates. It's like the illegal immigrant advocates that claim that Americans don't want to pick fruit -- at $5 per hour, probably not. But at $15 per hour, suddenly there isn't a shortage.
Except in rare cases, H1s are not used to fill actual shortages but to lower costs. A junior level Tata engineer isn't filling a shortage of skills, they're filling a shortage of engineers willing to work for $50k per year.
- aianus 10y ago> Essentially, your statement singlehandedly destroys minimum wage arguments. "If I could pay less, then I could be profitable, otherwise I am not profitable and thus won't hire anyone." Yes, it does. Minimum wage laws are not good economics. We would be better served scrapping them and instituting a basic income to ensure a quality-of-life floor instead.
- mmirate 10y ago> Essentially, your statement singlehandedly destroys minimum wage arguments. "If I could pay less, then I could be profitable, otherwise I am not profitable and thus won't hire anyone." Yes. That statement shows exactly why minimum wage is economically unsound in the long-term. e.g. why else would McDonald's feel the need to automate their cashiers?