3 ms·
> The Order represents a significant departure from the principles of fairness and predictability that have governed the immigration system of the United States
by belorn 10y ago
> The Order represents a significant departure from the principles of fairness and predictability that have governed the immigration system of the United States for more than fifty years
Can I derive from this that the 97 tech companies accepts the classified Terrorist Watch List (2mil people), Selectee list, and no fly list? The statement would hold more credibility if the companies acknowledged and denounced the previous system and held a bit more consistent view on how travel between nations should work. A good example of this would be ACLU, who in contrast to the 97 companies has shown a consistent view on this kind of government behavior by bringing lawsuits in the past and the present.
- richardwhiuk 10y agoThe outrage expressed by the public is the large driving factor here - the tech companies are saying 'our potential workforce is outraged so we need to oppose this / be seen opposing this'
- _delirium 10y agoI'm not sure it's only the outrage, also that this impacts their business more than past decisions. Rather than "fairness" (which I agree they don't really credibly care about) I think the key for the companies is the "predictability" part, in that imposing a travel ban for people who already had valid visas and work permits is unwelcome from a corporate-planning perspective. Especially because the initial version applied to even green-card holders, which includes large numbers of people in the tech industry, such as Iranian-Americans. Though the administration seems to have backed down from enforcing the no-entry order in the case of green-card holders. If green-card holders had been exempted from the start, it's possible opposition wouldn't have been galvanized in the same way, because including them brought in opposition from all kinds of people who don't usually see themselves as being impacted by the immigration debate (essentially: affluent, well-integrated immigrant communities with legal residency). The cynical take on it is that Trump screwed up by not confining his hawkish immigration enforcement to the powerless & poor types of immigrants that immigration hawks usually stick to harassing.
- Chris2048 10y ago"potential workforce", or "public"? Because polls suggest many Americans support the ban.
- richardwhiuk 10y agoThe arguments presented in the brief suggest they care more about the impact on their ability to recruit than negative general PR for not supporting the ban.
- toyg 10y agoThose lists were implemented with a bit more runway than 5 minutes. The outrage is not just at what the ban does, but how it's been introduced: suddenly, capriciously, with no preparation or discussion with involved parties, and resulting in all sorts of collateral damage that could have been easily avoided.