4 ms·
Non-American here, I read the whole article and I still can't tell if it's satire or not?
by flukus 10y ago
Non-American here, I read the whole article and I still can't tell if it's satire or not?
- erikpukinskis 10y agoI'm an American and I have no idea.
- MaxLeiter 10y agoIt's clearly satire
- Buge 10y agoThe article is clearly satire. But it's unclear if the ad actually aired or not.
- randpeck 10y agoIt aired during the pregame show. Just a potato with the word "ADVERTISEMENT" on it for 30 seconds. There is a chance they only bought slots for Chicago, as a lot of the twitter feeds mentioning it are located in that area.
- theparanoid 10y agoIt's satire.
- atsjie 10y agoHad the same doubts... although the ad obviously makes no sense with no company/product name being shown. Pretty sure it's satire, but as a non-american I don't understand it either.
- rralian 10y agoI don't think it's American-ness that dictates whether or not you get it, but rather your familiarity with cards against humanity, their product, and their marketing style.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- niftich 10y agoIt's a bit a both, although probably best termed 'art'. It's satire by proxy in the sense that nearly all 'projects' Cards Against Humanity and the ad in question were, and the prose mirrors the structure of similar post-mortems undertaken by legitimate companies in similar situations. It may have elements of truth (although hard to confirm at this point), but the purpose is to hook the ad (which was context-free) to the cause, and thus generate buzz, speculation, and more analysis. In other words, a publicity ploy intermixed with a pick-your-own-layers of social commentary.
- dguaraglia 10y agoDefinitely satire, although I was surprised they mentioned a well-known ad agency by name. Just check their past marketing efforts (and the general idea of Cards Against Humanity.)
- jslabovitz 10y agoThey're giving props to W+K in a backhanded way: "They wasted over six months of our precious time pitching concepts like people laughing while playing the game, and amusing card combinations coming to life on screen." That "conventional thinking" likely would have worked well and made the ad successful in conventional terms. So I don't think they're dissing the agency (maybe that's not what you implied), but rather saying W+K does well at a different kind of advertising. Non-potato advertising, say.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shurcooL 10y agoAnyone who watched the super bowl, did they actually air that 30 second ad or not?
- josephpmay 10y agoI didn't see the ad, but a look at Twitter suggests it was actually broadcast (almough it appears to have been pre-game and quite possibly only in certain markets)
- fullshark 10y agoDidn't see it either, my guess is they aired it only local market somewhere.
- foobarbecue 10y agoThese are the same people that dug The Hole. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/nov/28/cards-against-humanity-hole https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/nov/28/cards-aga...
- couchand 10y agoIt's definitely not a truthful retrospective of a failed ad (I would be shocked to hear that they were actually going out of business), but it is made to follow the style of one. However, it's simply using that form as a vehicle, not mocking or shaming the subjects of the imitation, so I wouldn't describe it as satire. Perhaps irony, verging on sarcasm? The ad and the article are part of a single, original marketing campaign, done very much in their style: part spectacular and part absurd.