9 ms·
Can we stop with the implicit assumption that children are the only valid reason to have a life outside of work? I cook dinner, read fiction, take weekend live
by closeparen 10y ago
Can we stop with the implicit assumption that children are the only valid reason to have a life outside of work?
I cook dinner, read fiction, take weekend live audio gigs, took motorcycle class and bought one. I plan to learn to sail, get an amateur radio license, pick up an instrument, and (money permitting) earn a private pilot rating. Oh, and see friends who are not coworkers. And date.
When I program outside of work, it's in a domain or part of the stack I wish I knew more about, i.e. not what I'm doing at work.
My on-call shifts are scheduled well in advance. When I'm not on call, work stays in its timebox.
We all deserve to live full lives, not just parents.
- jdmichal 10y agoI think it's just an easy fallback from an emotional perspective. It would be a "political suicide" of sorts to argue against a parent wanting time with their children. Not so much about a sailor wanting time with their boat, etc.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rootlocus 10y ago"political suicide" or not, I'm paid for 8h/day. What I do with my free time is nobody's concern and I sure don't have to defend myself for respecting my contractual obligations.
- closeparen 10y agoSure, but I'm pretty sure the problem being discussed here is specific to at-will salary workers, who do not have specific contractual obligations and are not paid for specific hours.
- rootlocus 10y agoI'm not familiar with "at-will salary workers". How does that work? If they don't have contractual obligations, what do they get paid for?
- jon_richards 10y ago"at-will" refers to the employer being able to fire the employee "at-will", meaning for any reason or no reason (excepting reasons that it is illegal to fire for) and without warning.
- jdmichal 10y agoTechnically, it also affords the similar right to the employee to leave at any time for any or no reason. However, with employee / employer relations and power balance as they are, it is a tool that is drastically more powerful for the employer.
- closeparen 10y agoOh boy, welcome to employment in the United States. At-will: either party may alter or terminate employment at any time for any reason, and the other has no legal recourse. There is no contractual specification of what you're paid for because the employer does not need to prove anything about the relationship between actual and expected behavior to fire you. You get paid the rate that was agreed upon for time already worked, and then you're done. In effect, you get paid for not having been fired yet. Salary: your compensation is per unit of time elapsed on the calendar, not at your workstation. These conditions describe the vast majority of professional, intellectual, and managerial work in the United States. Working 40 hours per week, working 9am-5pm Monday-Friday, etc. are merely cultural norms, not legal standards, and some industries (like tech and finance) have very little respect for them. Working 40 hours per week is encoded as a legal standard for hourly workers (via overtime pay requirements), but only below a certain wage threshold. Many fields, including programming, are exempt from overtime requirements even when paid hourly.
- ouid 10y ago
- Retra 10y agoBut what that salary covers is obviously only enough to maintain satisfactory employment under a certain number of hours. My employer simply doesn't pay me enough for me to work more than 40 hours per week, crunch time or not.
- tlow 10y agoAre you sure? I've seen many salary situations where employees were repeatedly coerced into extra work hours with the rational given by HR that's what Salary meant. I don't know if this is accurate or not, I just am asking if you have somewhere that specifies 8h/day. What would happen if you had a contract stipulating 10h/day in California 3 days/week. Are the 2 extra hours per day OT? edit: it seems this is discussed below, apologies. The OT question is one I am still curious about though.
- cosmie 10y agoIt depends on if the employee is exempt or nonexempt[1], not just if they're salary or hourly. The majority of professional positions are exempt, salaried positions. Even in California, they'd be exempt from any overtime eligibility. > What would happen if you had a contract stipulating 10h/day in California 3 days/week. Are the 2 extra hours per day OT? If they're in a non-exempt position, whether salary or hourly, then they'd qualify for overtime. If salaried, California has a formula for how to calculate the hourly rate for overtime calculations[2]. Note that those 2 hours/day are particular to California, not universal to all states. California has some robust overtime laws with multiple triggers, including days >8 hours, >40 hours per work week, and > 6 consecutive days of work in a workweek. You can get a whole lot of overtime pay with far less than 40 hours of work in a week. It gets even more complex because you can't double count hours for overtime. Many states don't have explicit overtime laws like California, and just default to the federal laws[3]. In that case, it's simply 40 hours per work week. If you work more than 40 hours per workweek, you get overtime. If you work less, then you don't get overtime. The per-day distribution of those hours are irrelevant. Again, only applicable to non-exempt employees. Exempt are still not qualified. [1] https://justworks.com/blog/understand-differences-exempt-non-exempt-employees https://justworks.com/blog/understand-differences-exempt-non... [2] http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/faq_overtime.htm http://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/faq_overtime.htm [3] https://www.dol.gov/whd/overtime_pay.htm https://www.dol.gov/whd/overtime_pay.htm
- imesh 10y agoAs a parent I can say that children are a great excuse that I use for my boss to not stay late when I really want to get home to watch The Young Pope; my kids at soccer practice.
- manyxcxi 10y agoI agree fully, though, I honestly thought parents were kind of a pain in the ass to work with in the early years of my career. "Wait, it's crunch time and you're not sleeping under your desk as well?" I felt a lot of resentment like they were leaving the 'kid' to do all the heroics. It didn't take me having kids to get it, it came much before that when someone I really respected had their first and they could basically tell me my future word for word. But I did get it, at least as much as you can pre-kids. I've had some crunch times before where I practically didn't see my kids for four days because I was getting home late and leaving early- I can honestly still handle the physical toll. The mental toll is just something else. Now, if that's going on I still peel out for dinner and bed time and head back in to the office when they're all taken care of- then it's 'just' my wife getting neglected. Your boat won't resent you, won't ask you where you've been, or be on the other end of FaceTime crying because they miss you when you've been on a work trip for a few days. Your boat doesn't depend on you for its survival on a minute by minute basis, and your mechanic doesn't need all the physical and emotional support you can muster (and probably more). Your kids and partner do. Parents' lives aren't full, they're literally exploding with shit (often times quite literally) they have to deal with that makes work look like a freaking vacation. There's a huge emotional component to all of it that's practically unquantifiable, but suffice to say that if I'm feeling as if I've neglected my family for a few days, I may as well just pack my shit up and go home, because I'm not getting anything else actually done, even if my body and mind should still be good to go. At the end of the day, we're agreeing to work for a determined price for a determined period of time. Now, at salary it gets fuzzy, and you hope that it all evens out, but in practice it won't unless you decide to make it so. Whether you have kids or not, you should be fighting to keep the balance- and any boss who can't accept that is a real jerk. We all love team players and rock stars, but it doesn't mean you also have to be a doormat and afraid. I think the person we should all be looking up to is the person that is REALLY EFFING GOOD at what they do and also has a variety of interests and hobbies that are seemingly disconnected from the day job.
- doodyhead 10y agoI'm completely fine working with people who have kids. I don't have a problem with them working from home some days to look after a sick child, or taking time off during the day to pick them up from school, or coming in late because they were up all night with a crying baby. What I detest is the sanctimonious, holier-than-thou attitude that, just because you have kids, you a superior or more evolved human being. I admire that you made the decision to have and raise kids. I understand it takes huge dedication and effort, and it eats most, if not all, of your free time. What if I choose not to have kids, and I spend the rest of my life "pre-kids"? What has that got to do with my job? Absolutely nothing. And it shouldn't come into it. Having kids is a choice, and not a path everyone chooses to walk.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]