6 ms·
What killed the Linux desktop? Not being preinstalled. For a bit of context from PC history, this is also what killed the GEM desktop, killed the OS/2 desktop,
by bitwize 10y ago
What killed the Linux desktop? Not being preinstalled. For a bit of context from PC history, this is also what killed the GEM desktop, killed the OS/2 desktop, and damn near killed the Windows desktop until Microsoft put pressure on vendors to make a 386SX with VGA the entry-level option and ship Windows 3.0 with every unit.
Preinstalls are an OS's golden ticket to adoption.
- alkonaut 10y agoIf one Linux with one desktop was widely preinstalled, that would help. That would have made that environment the target for desktop developers, which in turn would have added the pressure for backwards compatibility. Now, as a desktop developer I'm surely not targeting Linux desktop because it's not even a single target.
- lumberjack 10y agoDoesn't stop Android adoption.
- closeparen 10y agoUm, what? Phones differ in size and power, but a particular version of Android is a particular version of Android everywhere. Android developers don't have a debian vs. ubuntu vs. centos. vs. gentoo vs. arch type choice to make, only a "how backwards compatible do I want to be" choice.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fooker 10y agoWhy do you think desktop applications have to be different for the distros? It is rather easy to ship libraries with your package or even do static builds.. Even without that, things are relatively portable. (Steam packaged for Ubuntu works on most of the distros)
- alkonaut 10y agoYes. Of the two problems (apis and deployment) apis is actually the easier problem. It's not solved by any means (OS services are just too dang hard to figure out because desktop linux isn't one OS. How do I do desktop notification, printing, service init etc in a way that works for all distros?) but at least that's doable. The deployment is the hard problem imho.
- pjmlp 10y agoLibraries are just part of the picture, then comes the location of files, init systems, lack of standard frameworks for all layers of a modern desktop. On OS X, in spite of CUPS, I can use AppKit Printing API. On Linux I have to resort to somehow generate PS and forward into the printer driver.
- alkonaut 10y agoAndroid took linux and solved the problems: it created an ivory-tower set of API's for applications and it provided an app distribution model that isn't insane.
- shp0ngle 10y agoOoohhh. I still remember the time when I bought Acer netbook with pre-installed ubuntu. It worked. Exactly for one day, before I accepted Ubuntu update, that broke my pc, because of some binary graphic driver. I had to do some kernel magic to get it working again. On a pc with pre-installed Ubuntu, on day two. I wasn't very happy with that.
- int_19h 10y agoFor all practical purposes, desktop Linux is a single target. Use Qt, statically link everything or install to a folder in /opt, and then the only thing you depend on from the OS is libc... which has been plenty stable for a very long time.
- alkonaut 10y agoThat helps with compatibility, but it does not help deployment. Flatpack-like projects try to solve this, but there won't be a "good" way of targeting linux until one of those solutions is widespread enough that you can just show 3 download links on your page (windows, linux, os x) and it all just works. As a developer I have zero interest in trying to get my application into the package managers of various distributions,
- marvy 10y agoThese days you can get computers with Linux preinstalled. What you can't get is a computer that has both Windows and Linux preinstalled in some kind of dual boot or VM setup. That you must still do yourself. You can get the choice to preinstall Windows, or preinstall Linux; never both.
- shmerl 10y ago> These days you can get computers with Linux preinstalled. If you look for them specially, and not from most manufacturers. Try getting one from Dell (any model, not one specific variant), Lenovo and etc. Good luck with that.
- wolfgke 10y ago> If you look for them specially, and not from most manufacturers. Try getting one from Dell (any model, not one specific variant), Lenovo and etc. Good luck with that. Before you complain about that, consider that every GNU/Linux nerd has strong feelings about their preferred GNU/Linux distribution (or version (such as LTS, Stable, Bleeding Edge etc.). So they will probably not be satisfied with the distribution that is installed and install their preferred one. Also there is only one or two Windows versions that the customer wants preinstalled at any given time. Only every few years (much less often than a new version of a typical GNU/Linux distribution gets released) there will be a necessity to offer a new Windows version. So if you are dreaming of PCs preinstalled with GNU/Linux for the mainstream market, first standardize on 1 or 2 distribution for, say, 95% of the market.
- shmerl 10y ago> Before you complain about that, consider that every GNU/Linux nerd has strong feelings about their preferred GNU/Linux distribution (or version (such as LTS, Stable, Bleeding Edge etc.). So they will probably not be satisfied with the distribution that is installed and install their preferred one Those who have such preferences, have zero problems installing their own distro. The fact that it doesn't come pre-installed doesn't bother such users, as long as they aren't forced to pay the nasty Windows tax. We are talking about what's slowing mass Linux adoption (by those who aren't likely to ever install any OS to begin with).
- Twisell 10y agoI work on Win 10, I run Ubuntu Server and some Desktop VM, I have an iMac at home. Due to recent lifestyle change I'll soon buy a laptop and I was highly considering buying a Linux laptop because I will mostly use it for coding. After a few search I noticed that the most cited laptop choice was an ugly old Thinkpad. I really don't want to spend 200 hours checking if hardware and drivers will behave rightly and still end up in an energy efficient result. So guess what I'll just go for a MacBook and run Linux in a VM if needed...
- Jonnax 10y agoThe Dell XPS line officially support Ubuntu. www.dell.com/uk/business/p/xps-13-9350-laptop-ubuntu/pd