6 ms·
That NSA was tracking flight data was no great reveal. When we fly we share that fact with countless international organizations. Government boarder services.
by sandworm101 10y ago
That NSA was tracking flight data was no great reveal. When we fly we share that fact with countless international organizations. Government boarder services. Airport secuity. Credit card companies. Insurers. And certainly the airlines. Anyone who thinks that air travel was ever private, pre or post-911, doesnt appreciate the number of information systems involved with moving people across boarders via aircraft. The data was always open to whatever organization could express a reasonable need.
- wheelerwj 10y agojust because it is this way doesn't mean we can't do better.
- seanp2k2 10y agoSure, but rolling this back now, especially in this political climate, seems exceedingly unlikely.
- sandworm101 10y agoBut to what advantage? Before governments knew who was arriving on thier shores travellers would be held for days, even months, sometimes on dedicated islands. Even in the 90s, 10+ hours to clear customs and immigration was not unussual in many countries. Today, law enforcement and immigration officials can rely upon advance data and do away with lengthy in-person background checks for all. This is why land crossings, which are unannounced, take so much longer and are more unpredictable than air crossings. Fly to Dubai. Then try driving to Dubai. Same boarder, vastly different inspection.
- nemesisj 10y agoSpoken like someone who rarely crossed borders in the 90s. I spent significant time crossing borders in the 80s and 90s and it never took much time. This was primarily between PR China and the USA so not your friendliest border but also involved land crossings between Hong Kong and PR China. Most of these tickets were purchased in cash months in advance. I'm not sure why you think it was so onerous without info sharing.
- sandworm101 10y agoTry Saudi, or russian boarders, or vietnam. I spent a great many hours in long lines to see stonefaced boarder guards carrying more bullets than brains.
- cloakandswagger 10y agoWhat would be better in this case? Should anyone be able to show up to an airport, pay for a ticket and board a flight anonymously? I'm a pretty staunch libertarian and even I can see the benefit here. Until we reach the border-less, one-world utopia that so many people seem to be gunning for, it's valuable to know who is coming/going from your country.
- hrehhf 10y ago> Should anyone be able to show up to an airport, pay for a ticket and board a flight anonymously? Yes.
- ryanlol 10y ago>Should anyone be able to show up to an airport, pay for a ticket and board a flight anonymously? This is the reality in large parts of EU, I've flown several times without having my real name on the ticket. Hell, when I fly private it's even better. Show up at airport, meet pilot, get on the plane, hand the pilot a pile of cash. No passport control or security at any point, and this isn't just EU. So far no massive disasters have resulted from this.
- refurb 10y agoHmmm... I've flow a ton in the EU and always had to show ID that matched the name on the ticket. I did fly in SE Asia a few times where no ID was required and the name didn't have to match.
- ryanlol 10y ago>Hmmm... I've flow a ton in the EU and always had to show ID that matched the name on the ticket. Yeah, those are the rules. However, the only place where your passport and ticket will be compared is at the gate and they certainly never look very carefully.
- icebraining 10y agoAt the very least, the DHS shouldn't have free reign over flights that don't actually go into, from or even over the US.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 10y agoI agree with your general point, but we really need a better approach to saying these types of things. In general, it seemingly comes across as justification, hipsterism, or even a personal attack. When really the intent is more "I wish you had listened to me earlier, but I am glad you're here now. Let's try to rationally tackle this problem within its longer term context, rather than being alarmed over a single news cycle". Similarly, Snowden didn't really reveal much that wasn't already known or trivially inferable from what was. But qualitatively, what he did was a "great reveal". It doesn't actually matter what had been keeping people from being aware - overt conspiracy ("classified"), or just their own cognitive dissonance. What matters is that many more people are now aware of the surveillance society.
- EternalData 10y agoValid, though travelsWith is something that I didn't think the government would be able to systematically canvass unless they had access to passenger manifests.