7 ms·
Question to Libertarians... Is this statism? Or legitimate penalties for externalities? Kinda hard for all those parents of kids with asthma to sue all those dr
by EGreg 10y ago
Question to Libertarians... Is this statism? Or legitimate penalties for externalities? Kinda hard for all those parents of kids with asthma to sue all those drivers and manufacturers after the fact. Isn't this reported result a benefit that wouldn't have arisen in a purely anarcho capitalist society?
- mark_edward 10y agoI am certainly no libertarian but I think the framing is a bit uncharitable, anarcho-capitalism is a radical fringe, the vast majority of ideological libertarians (my estimate) are okay with the state internalizing externalities, although there would be objections to its ability to do this fairly and effectively
- aoeuasdf1 10y agoIn this case, it isn't fair - the externality is pollution, but the fee is unrelated to the emission levels of the vehicle. But even such an inefficient system is still superior to doing nothing and letting the public suffer the externalities.
- lend000 10y agoIt's astounding that these politicians and bureaucrats who ostensibly have the right idea almost exclusively come up with these complex schemes full of mis-incentives, instead of using simple, correct solutions, like raising gasoline taxes. An example: the Obama administration set forth a regulation that forces automakers to produce one 50 MPG vehicle in their line-up within the next five years. Of course, this is a stealth tax which has similar negative effects (and positive ones) to a higher gasoline tax, but the negative effects -- like higher car prices -- are less traceable to the mandate, which is good for politics. However, there are less obvious negative effects, like raising the barrier to entry for competition (it is no coincidence that the heavily regulated auto industry has very few startups -- Tesla being an anomaly.) A new company that only produces 30-45 MPG SUV models cannot compete, whereas it would be relatively competitive with a higher gasoline tax.
- J-dawg 10y agoIn Europe we have high taxes on fuels and CO2 emissions, but London and Paris still have worse air pollution than many US cities. Mostly because automakers focussed on Diesel engines to maximise MPG at the cost of everything else (NOx, particulates etc)
- jabl 10y agoYes, and many European countries tax diesel less than gasoline. I think when these sorts of policies were enacted only heavy vehicles like trucks, buses and cars that were driven a lot (taxis, mostly) used diesel, and there was an extra yearly per-vehicle "diesel tax" that made buying a diesel car economically unfavorable unless you drove a lot. I think this sort-of ties into the political ideology where "luxury consumption" is bad. I.e. truckers transport Important Stuff(TM) and thus deserve a tax rebate on fuel, whereas a private person driving their own vehicle is bad, and should be discouraged. But, the world changed (or, lets say the balance between the different taxes, incomes etc.) and at some point it started to make economic sense for the average Joe to buy a diesel car instead of a gasoline one. But of course, changing the tax policy by getting rid of the diesel tax rebate runs into fierce opposition by the trucking/taxi/etc. lobby. So here we are.
- Brakenshire 10y ago> It's astounding that these politicians and bureaucrats who ostensibly have the right idea almost exclusively come up with these complex schemes full of mis-incentives, instead of using simple, correct solutions, like raising gasoline taxes. It's because the issue they're directly trying to tackle is congestion, not pollution (which is only being tackled as a secondary issue). Also, in Britain there are already high petrol taxes, they make up about half the price of fuel. In general it's a good thing, and it does discourage a completely car dependent society - people to live closer to the centre, closer to work, use alternatives like walking, cycling, public transport etc - but it's not a particularly direct way to tackle air pollution, or at least it doesn't tackle the particular spikes in air pollution you get in the cities. In order to tackle air pollution in London using only fuel tax, you'd have to make driving in the countryside ruinously expensive. So you get layered policy - medium fuel tax nationwide, congestion charge for the centre (where it is the biggest issue), and an air pollution charge, or limit, covering the whole city. I do agree that often politicians are not that great at designing these things (the proposed air pollution charge in London is rather strangely designed for instance), and the complexity is partly incompetence, but it's also partly because the problem is complicated.
- lend000 10y ago> Is this statism? No, this is maximizing net freedom. Pollution infringes on the rights of others... a libertarian solution would have been more efficient and penalized the source on a consumption basis (gasoline tax), but the incentive would be similar. Here's a libertarian-ish analysis on the formerly proposed Washington state carbon tax: http://www.leolinsky.com/2016/11/06/carbon-tax-initiative-732/ http://www.leolinsky.com/2016/11/06/carbon-tax-initiative-73... I hope to erase a lot of extremist misunderstandings about freedom (as defined by the broadly interpretable nonaggression principle), because I think a lot of those on HN who currently identify with the Democratic Party would find they actually have more in common with independent, moderate libertarians (or even the LP) than they realize.
- Symbiote 10y agoSweden already has a high petrol and diesel tax. 1L of petrol is $1.61, compared to about $0.56 in the USA. That tax doesn't take account of where the fuel is used. The pollution caused by a long journey through the countryside is less damaging than driving within a city. Additionally, reducing congestion improves journey times for other road users. How much should that be worth? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline_and_diesel_usage_and_pricing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline_and_diesel_usage_and_...
- lend000 10y agoI'm all for capturing externalities in the form of consumption-based incentives, but at some point you need to draw a line for added benefit/complexity. Yes, they do have relatively high gasoline taxes, but perhaps not high enough. Theoretically, perhaps the cost should be such that the government can use the revenue to "undo" the damage (via carbon capture + ventilation infrastructure in congested areas, for example). If there was truly a compelling case that city congestion, per liter, is so much worse: just levy an additional city petrol gasoline tax. Similar to city vs state sales taxes.
- alkonaut 10y agoSweden is a large and sparsely populated country. In the north, many have 1h, 60 mile commutes. In Stockholm a commute might be 1h and 10 miles. There is pretty stiff opposition to raised gasoline taxes because it is seen as an unfair on rural people. It's also regressive since income is much lower in rural areas. If "city pollution" and "congestion" are the externalities then congestion taxes actually make more sense - and are extremely popular compared to gasoline tax. City gasoline taxes would make sense, but they don't allow hour by hour control of congestion. I don't work in the city but I can drive in "for free" e.g late in the evening.
- facepalm 10y agoNot sure what would be libertarian, but it sounds like an obvious externality?
- 08-15 10y agoThe fee goes to the state, not to the victims. Therefore, it's statism. Nobody knows what would have happened in a "purely anarcho capitalist society" for lack of experimental data. (That's assuming the study is even correct, and I don't claim to be a libertarian or speak for them.)