5 ms·
Why didn't he mention TV when saying "information becomes a distraction, a diversion, a form of entertainment, rather than a tool of empowerment"? Oh wait, he
by jgrahamc 17y ago
Why didn't he mention TV when saying "information becomes a distraction, a diversion, a form of entertainment, rather than a tool of empowerment"?
Oh wait, he mentioned all media in the actual, in context quote:
And meanwhile, you're coming of age in a 24/7 media
environment that bombards us with all kinds of content and
exposes us to all kinds of arguments, some of which don't
always rank that high on the truth meter. And with iPods and
iPads; and Xboxes and PlayStations -- none of which I know
how to work -- (laughter) -- information becomes a
distraction, a diversion, a form of entertainment, rather
than a tool of empowerment, rather than the means of
emancipation. So all of this is not only putting pressure on
you; it's putting new pressure on our country and on our
democracy.
Way to go Economist for taking his quote out of context.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI'm not sure they are taking it out of context. According to your quote, it sounds like he is grumbling about new forms of communication: the "24/7 media environment". That's exactly how the economist described it. (Note: I only read your quote, not the full speech. Please correct me if the full speech elaborates.) Also, the economist does observe that he dislikes some low tech media. Not TV, but radio: "...with his grumbling about the crazy theories circulated by the combination of blogs and talk radio."
- tptacek 17y ago"Talk radio" is just a dog-whistle reference to right wing punditry. I'm sure he has no problem listening to the Sox games on the radio.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoIt's true, he may not be complaining about the media itself. He may just be complaining that his opponents get a voice.
- wlievens 17y agoOh please. If anything, he's shown to be quite well equipped to debate a reasonable opponent, and therefore has no reason to complain about said opponent "getting a voice".
- pyre 17y agoSome of the 'talk radio' conservative pundits are more like cult leaders than talk show hosts. (i.e. they do not hold, nor inspire rationality in their followers/faithful)
- tptacek 17y agoI'm just unpacking the semiotics. I'm not making value judgements.
- philwelch 17y agoIt's hardly a dog whistle reference. Everyone knows there are hardly any left-wing talk shows on the radio. It's too obvious to be a "dog-whistle reference".
- tptacek 17y agoNo, everyone who pays attention to politics knows that. Which is the point of a dog-whistle reference.
- philwelch 17y agoI always thought dog-whistle references were more subtle, like anti-Semitic people denouncing "Zionists", or making oblique Biblical references most religious people wouldn't understand.
- jbooth 17y agoThe quote is clearly a complaint about the quality/truthfulness of various media sources in an environment where the listener gets total freedom to choose their media. It's a warning to students that with more information comes more responsibility to be skeptical. This has been a theme of a lot of Obama's speeches and it's clearly something that's important to him as a former professor. Now you can get all victimized and complain about how he's singling out talk radio for criticism -- but before you do that, I'd like you to wholeheartedly endorse/defend the content of said talk radio hosts. You know, the ones who continually talk about Obama's birth certificate or draw ridiculous blackboard conspiracy theories based on word association between various boogeymen ("liberals", immigrants, black helicopter plans for global government).. Obama's not saying they should be muzzled or have their right to speech taken away, he's saying they're full of shit.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoJGC criticizes the economist for implying Obama was opposed only to particularly new media (ipads, etc), and not also mentioning TV. I pointed out that they mentioned he also opposes some traditional forms of media (talk radio). The economist said he joined "a long tradition of grumbling about new technologies and new forms of media", not that he wanted to censor anyone. I pointed out that the quote JGC provides suggests the economist is correct: Obama is criticizing a new information delivery system, the "24/7 media environment". No one besides you mentioned censorship.
- jbooth 17y agoHe's not criticizing any particular information delivery system, he's pointing out that in a 24/7 media environment and given a number of actors who are wholeheartedly committed to ignoring the truth in pursuit of preconceived agendas, students and individuals have a responsibility to filter and not believe everything they hear/read. That's what the quote seemed like it was saying to me.
- bruceboughton 17y agoI'm not sure this changes the argument The Economist is presenting, which is that Obama is wrong to blame technology for these "pressures".
- asdflkj 17y agoObama didn't even use the word "technology". How do you go from "gadgets" to "technology"? Actually, if you're The Economist, the same way you write most articles about things whose ideology and political affiliations don't agree with yours. This is why I particularly dislike The Economist. They are shrewd. Fox News (or, say, The Guardian) poisons the minds of idiots; The Economist poisons my own unless I am extra careful.
- pradocchia 17y agoAgreed. Appropriately enough: Socrates...feared that relying on written texts, rather than the oral tradition, would “create forgetfulness in the learners’ souls…they will trust to the external written characters and not remember of themselves.”
- jbooth 17y agoYeah, the Economist is good for foreign reporting and business reporting but since Obama's been elected they've been so clearly biased and/or recycling silly 30-year-old Washington conventional wisdom that I actually didn't renew my subscription.
- asdflkj 17y agoActually, The Economist is particularly bad for foreign reporting, because it is here that their fairly intelligent readers are most willing to trust them. Almost all other Anglophone news outlets don't even make a pretense of providing serious foreign reporting, which gives The Economist a sort of monopoly. Also, BS is harder to recognize when it has no implications for you or anyone you know. http://www.economist.com/printedition/displaystory.cfm?Story_ID=1259408 http://www.economist.com/printedition/displaystory.cfm?Story...
- jbooth 17y agoTrue, good points. In a lot of their foreign reporting you do see 2 sides to the story and it's less connected to any general ideological principles that the economist would be concerned with, so I guess I'm generally more impressed with it than the american/british/euro reporting. European stuff I just assume that they're biased and I don't know enough about the situation to pick up on it so I skim it and try not to draw conclusions.