3 ms·
The prof's definition begs the question. Humans can be observed recognising patterns, but that doesn't say anything useful about the process of recognition. I
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
The prof's definition begs the question.
Humans can be observed recognising patterns, but that doesn't say anything useful about the process of recognition.
It seems we have experiences first, and generalise from them later in terms of our experience. So we have common experiences of threeness, circleness, and redness, and from them we generalise what "three", "circle", and "red" means.
But what defines an experience of threeness? Is it really atomic, or is it made of further component parts/relationships? Is it learned, or innate? How does the labelling process influence the experience/generalisation process? (I'm not sure if it's an anthropological myth, but supposedly there are primitive tribes where counting goes "One, two, many..." What's their experience of threeness?)
The exact mechanics of this pattern recognition remain mysterious. It turns out that when we build NNs to recognise patterns, the process is still mysterious. Which seems mysterious in itself. It's remarkable that we have these tools and they seem to work to an extent, but really no one understands why.
- alimw 10y ago> The prof's definition begs the question. It was good enough for Russell so I doubt that. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set-theoretic_definition_of_natural_numbers#Definition_by_Frege_and_Russell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set-theoretic_definition_of_na...
- bmh_ca 10y ago️ <-- Unicode heart
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]