5 ms·
Neoliberal Capitalism has failed to create the circumstances necessary for large swathes of the population to survive, Wait, what??? Capitalism has been ludicr
by mindcrime 10y ago
Neoliberal Capitalism has failed to create the circumstances necessary for large swathes of the population to survive,
Wait, what??? Capitalism has been ludicrously effective at creating wealth and raising standards of living. What it hasn't necessarily done is guarantee equality or ensure that the very lowest (economic) class of citizens have a SoL that's above the baseline that a lot of people want. And given that Capitalism isn't a prescriptive system anyway, that's hardly surprising. It's also less than surprising given that we don't live (at least in the US and most of the Western world) in a truly capitalistic society to begin with. Most of this world is a mixed economy which features massive government regulation and other elements which work against pure laissez-faire.
Personally, I don't consider a certain measure of inequality to be a problem, with the caveat that nobody is artificially restrained from achieving economic success.
To me, we aren't waiting for "the left" (whatever that is) to present some new anti-capitalist plan... we're waiting to find a way to evolve society so that we can avoid the extremes of inequality that we have now, and create that baseline SoL for everyone. And I see no reason to think that Capitalism isn't the foundation those things should be built on.
The biggest thing that worries me right now is the whole "technological unemployment" issue. I remember worrying about that as far back as 7th grade... and while, so far, robots haven't replaced jobs to such an extreme that it's rendered human labor useless, one does wonder what will happen if/when that comes to pass. And there, to be honest, I will say that I'm not sure if the Capitalist approach will be workable. But on the flip-side, I'm not sure what other approach we can construct that doesn't require use of violence to redistribute wealth.
I've been trying to think about what something better might look like, and I hope people more versed in these subjects than I are doing so as well.
Likewise. Mainly I wish I had more time to think about this stuff.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoI agree that living standards have been raised, but if massive inequality and a corrupt political order has been created in tandem, this is something like the pursuit of short term profits over continued viability. If nothing else, the failure to take action on climate change under this ideology should demonstrate this. If the system is unable to meaningfully address existential threats, any other guarantees it makes about the future ring false. And less abstractly, this of course ignores the emergent downward trends in American lifespans, wages, and job security.
- gloverkcn 10y agoI don't think the OP was bashing capitalism in general. He was commenting on the specific policy of neoliberal capitalism which means little to no regulation, free trade, and fiscal austerity. Agree with you on the unemployment cliff. I think about it a lot. Currently I think if we don't fix our educational system we're have no chance of making it through without severe upheaval
- lhopki01 10y agoHow much of the advancement in SoL is the responsibility of capitalism and how much is because of technological development? The two are not necessarily linked. Personally, I don't consider a certain measure of inequality to be a problem, with the caveat that nobody is artificially restrained from achieving economic success. This is a bit of a straw-man. You'll find that most people accept a certain measure of inequality. The key point is that when people are presented with a range of income distributions they usually end up with something closer to Sweden than the US.