5 ms·
Don't be so surprised. It's easy to look and say, that group is taller and has bigger muscles so that's an obvious advantage. It's harder to see mental advant
by paulddraper 10y ago
Don't be so surprised.
It's easy to look and say, that group is taller and has bigger muscles so that's an obvious advantage.
It's harder to see mental advantages. Statistically, men have better spatial reasoning and are possibly better at the kind of logic (and intuition) chess requires.
Or maybe it's environmental. One way or another, every single one of the top 100 chess players in the world are men.
- ythn 10y ago> Statistically, men have better spatial reasoning and are possibly better at the kind of logic (and intuition) chess requires. Couldn't this same argument be applied to programming? Yet people would flip their lids if you suggested it.
- paulddraper 10y agoSshhhh. Programming is more employable than chess; it would be far more problematic for there to be any difference between genders.
- rayiner 10y agoI've brought up that issue before on HN and nobody "flipped their lid." The problem is that it tends to prove the opposite of what you might want to use it to prove. For a long time, there has been a gender difference in the SAT Math. The average is about the same between genders, but the standard deviation for men is larger, so they earn more of the highest score and the lowest scores. 2/3 of people with perfect score are men. But what does that prove? Most working programmers didn't pull a perfect SAT Math score. And programming teams tend to be much less than 35% women. In other words, even if aptitude for programming was determined purely by mathematical ability (and arguably programming involves many mixed skills unlike chess), women are dramatically underrepresented.
- paulddraper 10y ago> But what does that prove? Well, you're the only one bringing up the SAT math gap. But let's see... > the standard deviation for men is larger As is frequently pointed out, men are also overrepresented in homelessness and insane asylums. > Most working programmers didn't pull a perfect SAT Math score I did :) But seriously, I don't think anyone is interested just in the perfect score #s, preferring to look at averages instead, where there is still a gap. > And programming teams tend to be much less than 35% women. True. I think 8-10% is a typical number. There are several other factors to consider, e.g. there is a 10% gender gap in labor force participation as a whole, not just programming. --- More often than not, people point out the SAT math gap because it seems a struggle for some to even acknowledge there even could be statistical difference in mental ability (innate or developed early) between men and women. It doesn't "prove" anything, except that tabula rasa is not the only game in town.
- brianwawok 10y agoMy career female programmer coworker ratio is wayyy under 10%. Maybe 3%
- paulddraper 10y ago25% of jobs in computer science and math are done by women. 19% of CS graduates are female. http://www.ngcproject.org/statistics http://www.ngcproject.org/statistics Fortunately, it appears your experience is the exception.
- brianwawok 10y agoI guess it depends how broad you go. For example worked with many female web designers. And qa testers. But ratio of say backend programmers is very very low. Guess your stat doesn't say that. Graduate rate doesn't matter because it feels like many women do the programming thing for 2 years and drop out. (All this is sad and I wish we had more females. Businesses with more healthy male to female ratios tend to be less bro)
- 10y ago
- rtpg 10y agoSo this might be statistically true, but it doesn't mean that men are inherently better. Just like people born rich aren't inherently better at being rich later on. I think people talk a lot about the gender gap in these things. But there's a decent amount of proof from other domains that these differences are more likely to be caused by environmental differences than otherwise. Remember, programming used to be a lady's job!
- nikdaheratik 10y agoThere is alot we don't know about both general intelligence and what traits specifically makes a chess player good. Certain kinds of reasoning help, but so does the discipline to study and remember many different chess positions and then apply those to the situation at hand. There's nothing in science that says women should be worse at it than men, or that there aren't enough good women who play chess, and could crack the top 100. We just don't know is the bottom line and anyone who says differently probably has an agenda. Separate tournaments were added as way to get more women playing than anything else as the sport has alot of educational value even if it's not the only way to develop those same intellectual "muscles". Hopefully, it will expand to the point where enough good players of both genders come in and we finally see more women at the highest levels. But that may not happen.