5 ms·
In chess this makes no sense. I can see that in other sports women are physically at a disadvantage but chess?
by maxxxxx 10y ago
In chess this makes no sense. I can see that in other sports women are physically at a disadvantage but chess?
- 1_2__3 10y agoThe simple fact is yes, for whatever reasons, women are physically disadvantaged at chess. Regardless of how shocking that is. (Cue "differ t oppprtunities", "different emphasis" etc. which I am very much willing to listen to cited arguments for).
- dsacco 10y agoEven if you intend to have a good faith discussion about gender dimorphism in chess (whether it be intrinsic or extrinsic), the resulting thread has a high potential for descending into ideological chaos. I'd recommend not taking the stand that "women are physically disadvantaged in chess" is a "simple fact." You welcomed citations for reasons why that may or may not be - but much like sociological studies across ethnic differences in accomplishment, studies across gender differences accomplishment for non-physical activity are going to be, shall we say, "muddled." People may not be able to levy citations that argue against that thesis, but it's still a very difficult thesis to defend both socially and rhetorically. Engaging in dialectics about it is unlikely to be productive, and I think it's probably more fair to take an even ground in the absence of compelling evidence on other side. Extrinsically, yes, women display collective disparity in overall chess accomplishment. But we cannot infer anything about womens' chess ability intrinsically unless we have more women in chess. Specifically, we cannot infer anything physically about the female brain that would demonstrate a disadvantage. This doesn't mean you're wrong; it just means that it's so emotionally loaded, and so devoid of clear, replicable data that even a debate with citations will probably be disappointing at best, and personally insulting at worst.
- wallace_f 10y ago>This doesn't mean you're wrong; it just means that it's so emotionally loaded, and so devoid of clear, replicable data that even a debate with citations will probably be disappointing at best, and personally insulting at worst. That's right. If one said women are better home makers, teachers, and parents, people would either agree with you or say you're being sexist. What is wrong with teaching, parenting or home making? Without taking a position on whether men are better than women at chess, why does it even matter if women are better at some things and men at others? It's so overwhelmingly political and emotional, and why should women be ashamed to be good parents or home makers? Those are no less respectable than any other occupation. However, as you said, you can't even touch this topic without getting in trouble.
- maxxxxx 10y agoI can't even parse what you write here
- wallace_f 10y agoThe fact is the top 100 chess players in the world are men. That may be due to higher variance in men's mental abilities; however, the fact is the reason you are downvoted is for failure to abide by political correctness.
- praneshp 10y agoI heard Viswanathan Anand on TV a long time ago (when he had just become world champion), he claimed getting physically fitter had a definite impact on his game. Maybe that implicitly means there is physical fitness is a factor, hence women are disadvantaged? (I'm just trying to reason against you, I don't think the fitness Anand was talking about requires crossing the boundary where being male is an advantage.)
- pmoriarty 10y agoThe physical training is for endurance, as at high levels chess can be an exhausting sport. This is because winning chess competitions involves concentrating intensely for hours, days, or even (in rare cases like Kasparov vs Karpov) weeks while being under enormous and constant stress. That can be very draining if you're not prepared for it both physically and mentally. I would liken competitive chess to an endurance sport like marathon running instead of to something like boxing or sumo wrestling, where physical mass and brute force can be deciding factors. There's no reason that women can't be as physically or mentally prepared for such as sport as men.
- maxxxxx 10y agoPhysical fitness is certainly important but I doubt for chess it's on the level that's not achievable for women. Unless you are talking about chess boxing which is an interesting sport.
- praneshp 10y agoThanks for wasting my time. TIL about Chess boxing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kK5TQSKmS3o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kK5TQSKmS3o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nkf83hwMSyA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nkf83hwMSyA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chess_boxing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chess_boxing
- losteverything 10y agoI have to ask. Is this really real???????
- paulddraper 10y agoDon't be so surprised. It's easy to look and say, that group is taller and has bigger muscles so that's an obvious advantage. It's harder to see mental advantages. Statistically, men have better spatial reasoning and are possibly better at the kind of logic (and intuition) chess requires. Or maybe it's environmental. One way or another, every single one of the top 100 chess players in the world are men.
- ythn 10y ago> Statistically, men have better spatial reasoning and are possibly better at the kind of logic (and intuition) chess requires. Couldn't this same argument be applied to programming? Yet people would flip their lids if you suggested it.
- paulddraper 10y agoSshhhh. Programming is more employable than chess; it would be far more problematic for there to be any difference between genders.
- rayiner 10y agoI've brought up that issue before on HN and nobody "flipped their lid." The problem is that it tends to prove the opposite of what you might want to use it to prove. For a long time, there has been a gender difference in the SAT Math. The average is about the same between genders, but the standard deviation for men is larger, so they earn more of the highest score and the lowest scores. 2/3 of people with perfect score are men. But what does that prove? Most working programmers didn't pull a perfect SAT Math score. And programming teams tend to be much less than 35% women. In other words, even if aptitude for programming was determined purely by mathematical ability (and arguably programming involves many mixed skills unlike chess), women are dramatically underrepresented.
- paulddraper 10y ago> But what does that prove? Well, you're the only one bringing up the SAT math gap. But let's see... > the standard deviation for men is larger As is frequently pointed out, men are also overrepresented in homelessness and insane asylums. > Most working programmers didn't pull a perfect SAT Math score I did :) But seriously, I don't think anyone is interested just in the perfect score #s, preferring to look at averages instead, where there is still a gap. > And programming teams tend to be much less than 35% women. True. I think 8-10% is a typical number. There are several other factors to consider, e.g. there is a 10% gender gap in labor force participation as a whole, not just programming. --- More often than not, people point out the SAT math gap because it seems a struggle for some to even acknowledge there even could be statistical difference in mental ability (innate or developed early) between men and women. It doesn't "prove" anything, except that tabula rasa is not the only game in town.
- Noumenon72 10y agoOne common story that is told is that men have more variance in outcomes than women; regardless of whether men are taller, the very tallest and shortest individuals are both male. So if you select for the people with the most board memory, the most pattern recognition, the most patience, and whatever other weird traits, you could have entirely equal representation if you take the top 50% or the top 10%, but the top 0.1% could be all male.
- MengerSponge 10y agoMen exhibit more variance in traits that are expressed on the X-chromosome, as they only have one of them. Something as complicated as intelligence is not strongly tied to a single genetic marker, so while there may be some variance, it won't be nearly as broad as in something simpler (but still complicated), like height.