4 ms·
Fourth, terrorism can also bring much more horrible outcomes than the regular gun death, even more than a mass shooting. Some crazies can kill literally tens of
by maxerickson 10y ago
Fourth, terrorism can also bring much more horrible outcomes than the regular gun death, even more than a mass shooting. Some crazies can kill literally tens of thousands via some (not that elaborate) plan. And while it might not always be possible to predict or prevent such a thing, one can still fear it (and fear to further stir the conditions that might make it happen).
I've only done the lazy thing of looking at Wikipedia, but it appears that the attack on the Twin Towers on 9/11 is the only event carried out by non state actors in recent history that killed more than 1000 people.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_battles_and_other_violent_events_by_death_toll#Terrorist_attacks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_battles_and_other_viol...
(my wishy washy language is an attempt to acknowledge that definitions about this stuff are hard, not an attempt to quietly exclude other events. Many actions taken by nations have resembled terrorism in their intent and effect.)
- coldtea 10y ago>I've only done the lazy thing of looking at Wikipedia, but it appears that the attack on the Twin Towers on 9/11 is the only event carried out by non state actors in recent history that killed more than 1000 people. That doesn't offer much guarantees though. Before that one, the ceiling was much lower for attacks in the US (or even elsewhere), but it suddenly got to 3000 at one go. Here's a kind of disaster that can be caused by an attack (it was caused by corporate greed at the time), and which claimed thousands of lives: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster Note that, as the article says: "Union Carbide Corporation (UCC) contends water entered the tank through an act of sabotage" -- even if its BS, as I believe it is, it could just as well have happened under an attack to such a facility. But on the general issue of the past as a predictor, let me use Scott Adams' words, which can be fitting: I keep seeing tweets and articles saying the odds of an immigrant killing a citizen of the United States are approximately zero. Obviously those calculations assume that our past experiences do a good job of predicting what happens next. And this is good news. Really, really, good news. It’s good news because I used to be afraid of lots of stuff that never happened in the past. For example, I have never died from a nuclear attack, but now I understand that risk to be zero. We can dismantle our nuclear deterrents and relax. If a nuclear bomb hasn’t killed me in the past, I can safely conclude that it will never kill me in the future. I feel sorry for all of you science-deniers who think otherwise. I built a complicated prediction model to prove my point. The model only has one variable – the number of times I have died in nuclear blasts in the past. That number equals the number of times I will die in nuclear blasts in the future. Skeptics might doubt the credibility of my prediction model, but I would argue that it fits the past quite well. And that means it predicts the future too, unless you are ignorant of science and whatnot. More good news: Climate change is not a risk in the future. Man-made warming has never destroyed civilization in the past, so that means there is no chance it will happen in the future. That’s how the past works; it tells you what happens in the future. And boy is that handy. Before I learned that secret I was just guessing. We all learned as kids that history repeats itself. You know it is true because you heard it when you were young and stupid, and it stuck in your head. That’s proof right there. And it fits your observations too. For example, look how many times the Wright Brothers invented the airplane. They must have done it thousands of times by now, just like they did the first time. You might think the airplane would stay invented. But that’s not how the past works, you ignoramus. The past repeats. Those brothers just keep inventing that airplane, over and over. Even after they died, which obviously they did not see coming because they had not died in the past.
- maxerickson 10y agoHis analogy is specious. One reason that there is little violence caused by legal immigrants is that there have been screening processes in place. Equating the status quo of US immigration policy with dismantling nuclear deterrents is ridiculous.
- coldtea 10y ago>One reason that there is little violence caused by legal immigrants is that there have been screening processes in place. He talks about odds of being "killed by an immigrant" though -- doesn't say "by a legal immigrant" specifically. Plus, in places like France and Germany it's often not even immigrants, it's citizens that have been born there (of immigrant parents) that have been radicalized post-facto.