8 ms·
> US trains appear to get about 2.7MJ per passenger-km, while Portugese ones are about 0.07MJ I'm with you, there has to be some flaw with differing methodolog
by CydeWeys 10y ago
> US trains appear to get about 2.7MJ per passenger-km, while Portugese ones are about 0.07MJ
I'm with you, there has to be some flaw with differing methodologies going on here. It's way too discordant.
I'm surprised at the 2.7 figure; are trains really more than twice as worse as individual passenger vehicles? I can't imagine so. Especially not the trains I use most often, electric-powered urban subways.
- vonmoltke 10y agoI'm on my phone right now so I can't post nice details, but the Wikipedia number for "Portugal" is mislabeled. Per the reference, that is just for the Lisbon rail system. The US DOE report the US number was sourced from averages all passenger rail systems in the US, and specifically notes significant system-to-system variance. The biggest variance is that the Lisbon numbers are based on an average of about 400 passengers per train kilometer, while the US averages only about 40 across all systems.
- david-given 10y agoYeah, that seemed really odd to me, but I thought maybe it was due to diesel vs electric-with-regenerative-braking, which can be disturbingly efficient. Trains should be vastly more efficient than any individual transport. The only US commuter train I've seen was the SFO Caltrain, which was very not electric. Are there many electric trains there?
- ghaff 10y ago>Are there many electric trains there? Yes. For example, Amtrak's Northeast Corridor is electric as is light rail for the most part (entirely?). There's also an electrification project underway for Caltrain. I'm not sure about how much commuter rail in the US is electric in general.
- Someone 10y agoThe higher the speed, the more important avoiding air resistance is to get high efficiency. Planes are efficient, ones they are high up in the sky because there is less air there. Unfortunately, they need lots of energy to get up in the low pressure regions, and we do not have ways to recover that energy in landing. Moving slower also increases the per mile efficiency, as air resistance grows faster than linear in speed. Net effect (highly simplified) is that trains beat high speed trains irrespective of distance, high speed trains beat planes on shorter distances (up to a few hundred miles), but planes beat high speed trains if the distance covered in one hop is large enough. Hyperloop aims to change that by being a train riding at low atmospheric pressure (planes don't only burn fuel to go from A to B, they also burn fuel to stay up; hyperloop wouldn't need to do the latter) (edit: ideally, it also would recover energy on braking)