3 ms·
"Profit" is a technical term with a specific meaning; in this context it's the money left over after paying wages, rents, interest, and investing in the busines
by rahimnathwani 10y ago
"Profit" is a technical term with a specific meaning; in this context it's the money left over after paying wages, rents, interest, and investing in the business.
Investments aren't fully deducted from profits in the current period. So if you're measuring profit over any finite period, investments during that period may not have been fully reflected in reduced profits. For example, if a business buys a printer this year for $500, the business's profits will not be $500 lower than if they had not bought the printer. They would likely by $166 lower (assuming 3-year straight line depreciation).
they get a lot of money, then they spend it, so there's nothing left to return to the investors which means by definition there's no profit.
You're confusing cash flow with profit. When you return money to investors, you return cash, either in the form of dividends, or in the form of share buy-backs. You don't need profits in order to return cash (e.g. you could borrow money secured on your factory, and then pay that money straight to shareholders) and having profits doesn't mean you have cash (e.g. you might have just spent a load of money on new machinery, which would reduce your cash flow without as large a reduction in current year's profits).
- dingaling 10y ago> They would likely by $166 lower (assuming 3-year straight line depreciation). Only if they consider it as an asset, in which the $500 moves from the 'liquid assets' column to the 'fixed assets' column and is then depreciated away over time at $166 per year. The other method of accounting is to immediately deduct that $500 from assets as a cost in the year of acquisition. There's then no need of depreciation or spreading over several accounting years. Any residual value gained by resale at the end of the printer's life can then re-enter the accounts by means of 'other income'.
- SilasX 10y agoI'm no accountant, but I'm pretty sure a business doesn't have unlimited discretion to accelerate depreciation on equipment they buy, deferring or eliminating taxes (due to lower effective profit).
- rahimnathwani 10y agodingaling is technically correct, even though the point s/he makes is irrelevant to mine. Companies do have discretion about their own accounting policies, e.g. about whether to expense printers in the year of purchase, or over how many years to depreciate them. Regarding your tax point, your country probably has rules about what can/cannot be deducted from profits. Complying with those rules may require a different calculation of profit. So your company's 'profit' may differ between your accounts and the accounts you use to calculate your corporation tax.
- SilasX 10y agoTo follow up -- I understand why, for business purposes, you may have your own theories about how fast something is depreciating. I was responding to the parent's implication that you can somehow, at a whim decide, "oh, that thing I just bought is worthless so I can deduct 100% of its cost immediately and report lower taxable profits". No, the tax laws stipulate in which cases you can do that, and you generally don't have discretion, except perhaps by taking on some other downside.