12 ms·
Supersonic passenger jets might make a comeback
- djsumdog 10y agoFor those with ad blockers: http://archive.is/U2cOP http://archive.is/U2cOP
- valugi 10y agoor $ curl -XGET "http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-supersonic-jets-20170202-story.html" http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-supersonic-jets-201702... > read.html
- djsumdog 10y agoThere's a really good vox video on why the Concord failed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_wuykzfFzE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_wuykzfFzE
- hh2222 10y agoThat's one opinion, the Concorde was a success in many ways.
- kogepathic 10y agoThe biggest reason Concord wasn't successful was the sonic boom. This is why it only ever flew transatlantic. It was originally envisioned to also fly across the US, e.g. NYC to LA, but this was banned due to noise concerns. Had the Concord been permitted to fly over the continental US, it could have been much more successful than it was.
- hanoz 10y agoThe biggest reason Concord wasn't successful was that it was banned from flying over continental US. How much that was because of the sonic boom is a matter of some debate.
- kogepathic 10y ago> How much that was because of the sonic boom is a matter of some debate. No, it's actually not a matter of debate at all. See FAR 91.817 [0] No person may operate a civil aircraft in the United States at a true flight Mach number greater than 1 [0] http://www.risingup.com/fars/info/part91-817-FAR.shtml http://www.risingup.com/fars/info/part91-817-FAR.shtml
- peteretep 10y ago> A flight from Los Angeles > to Tokyo would take about > five hours, compared with > almost 12 hours today Beating JAL or ANA first class, even with a seven hour reduction, will take some doing.
- Scaevolus 10y agoIt also overstates its effect on total travel time-- which includes all the other nonsense (like the TSA) and planned buffering against uncertain delays that makes it frustrating. You'll burn a day crossing the Pacific either way.
- ghaff 10y agoIt's not even so much TSA--getting through security in the US only takes me 5-10 minutes typically with Pre-Check. But I hate to feel like I'm rushing so I do build in buffer. I have to get to the gateway city (which is almost never Boston), with a reasonable allowance between flights. I'm an hour to the airport. Clearing immigration/customs can take a while. Getting into an Asian capitol from the airport can easily be another hour. As you say, even cutting out 5 to 6 hours isn't that big a deal.
- jrockway 10y agoAll you have to do to beat JAL first class is to set the cabin temperature to something less than 82 degrees. You basically make the mistake of flying JAL transpacific exactly once, cursing yourself for ignoring all the Flyertalk posts regarding their odd cabin temperature policy. I hate to say it, but American is way better in this regard.
- peteretep 10y agoYeah OK, conceded in the general sense, but I've found them responsive to adjustments in the last.
- CaliforniaKarl 10y agoI'd like to see a 3-Dimensional scatter graph, showing what customers will accept in terms of three variables: • Comfort • Speed • Price I wonder how post-Concorde passenger jets would fit in, assuming they ever made it down to our level.
- usaphp 10y agoFor me personally the issue is not with a flight the time but with comfort. The other day I flu JetBlue mint from LA to New York and I never felt better after the flight. The problem with my flights to Europe are incredibly narrow and uncomfortable seats and limited leg space. I just can't physically sit in those economy seats even for 2 hours...I'm 6'3" btw
- hh2222 10y agoAnd since the airlines want you to upgrade to first or business class, they have little incentive to make economy class bearable.
- ghaff 10y agoIt's also driven by the fact that a lot of people (and many corporate travel departments) pick flights strictly based on price so anything you can do to appear at the top of the travel agent listing sorted by price gets you business.
- ghaff 10y agoFortunately I have the status to always fly my default airline with extra legroom seats. But to your broader point. Modern lie-flat business class is far more comfortable with personalized entertainment options (and plugged in via WiFi if you want) than first class on PanAm ever was. Long flights are still kinda boring but I'm not sure they're painful enough that any but a vanishingly small sliver of people who aren't already flying in private jets would pay a huge premium for them.
- Sami_Lehtinen 10y agoWikipedia got nice list of those projects, as usual most of projects never realize. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supersonic_transport https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supersonic_transport List of potential problems with supersonic jets is also quite long. I guess we've all would love to see progress being made.
- chx 10y agoI find the unbridled optimism just unfathomable. Here's two examples of plain old jet programs, small jets at that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitsubishi_Regional_Jet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitsubishi_Regional_Jet 1.5 billion dollars. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardier_CSeries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardier_CSeries 5.4 billion dollars. This is not a piece of software app that you can just launch whenever you feel ready full of bugs. You can't pull an Uber and say, hey fuck regulations, we will just do it (https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/19/uber-self-driving-cars-bike-lanes-safety-san-francisco https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/19/uber-self...). Yeah, sure, if you want to fly between Inner and Outer Camelstan then you might get away with the very fashionable "disrupt" shit but if you want to fly airspaces controlled by the FAA, EASA, CASA -- and let's face it, the money is in New York, London and Sydney -- then you need to do better. This is going to cost 5-10 billion dollars at least just based on the very fact that the C Series costed 5B and I can't see what here would make it cheaper. And it's not easy to see how are you going to recuperate that much money, this is not a big market and while obviously time is money, it's a very big question of just how much money. Gulfstream delivers 140 planes a year https://www.wsj.com/articles/general-dynamics-profit-rises-9-1453905234 https://www.wsj.com/articles/general-dynamics-profit-rises-9... with about 2-2.5b profit a year. I absolutely can not see how these numbers will stack up. Is this another venture capitalist fueled hype? VC invests, hypes it up, gets rid of the stock, small investors at the end get to hold the bag.
- mabbo 10y agoThe C-Series was a mess because Bombardier owned it. Thank goodness that company hasn't gotten into the pizza business because they sure as heck can't deliver on time. (Still waiting for the rest of the promised street cars here in Toronto, years behind schedule)
- kogepathic 10y agoYes but I think things have gotten a lot better under Alain Bellemare. Obviously they aren't hitting all their delivery targets, and that's worrying, but what struck me is that Bellemare said shortly after he took over the company was only a few weeks from bankruptcy. It seems he has managed to put them somewhat back on track, TTC deliveries aside of course...
- cyberferret 10y agoNice to hear. Concorde was a beautiful airplane, but limited to '60s technology (it even had vacuum tubes in the flight deck computers). But it did pave the way for a lot of technological advances at that time, such as carbon brakes etc. Be good to see what engineers can come up with using current technology to make things stronger, faster and lighter. Always intrigued by the fluctuations in the airline industry. I remember a time when it was said 'smaller aircraft were dead, and it is the time of the super jumbos', and now the reverse is true with airlines shunning huge aircraft for smaller aircraft that can do regional hops. Given that the R&D and deployment process for a new aircraft type is measured over decades, it would be incredibly difficult to build a plane today that will fit the market in 10 years time. Hats off to Boeing, Airbus, Embraer et al for their efforts.
- agumonkey 10y agoThey never replaced the computers with transistors ?
- cyberferret 10y agoThey did on most of the flight systems, but I believe I read somewhere that even on their retirement date, many of the aircraft still had tubes in the avionics bays. A complete replacement programme was just too expensive, and what they had worked, so they stuck with it. Had Concorde been a profitable aircraft, then it might have been a different story...
- Baeocystin 10y agoI'm not saying this was necessarily true for the Concorde, but sometimes you really do need a vacuum tube. All commercial x-ray sources use tubes, for example. The magnetrons that power our microwave ovens are vacuum tube oscillators. And by their nature, tubes are much faster than semiconductors, which has its uses.
- foobar__ 10y agoWhere are tubes faster than semiconductors?
- WalterBright 10y agoI wonder what the cost effectiveness of ballistic sub-orbital flights would be. That would solve much of the fuel efficiency problem.
- vkou 10y agoAt the expense of 'Everybody dies if the slightest thing goes wrong.' And 'Everybody better be wearing space suits... Unless you want to get Souz-11'ed. There is more then an order of magnitude of complexity between designing a vehicle that can travel at Mach 2, and one that can travel at Mach 22. Personally, I'd pass on the risks of hypersonic re-entry for my SEA->NYC flight... And on having to pee into an astronaut diaper. Space travel (And a ballistic suborbital hop is 90% of the way there) is, as a mode of transportation, incredibly dangerous.
- dreamcompiler 10y agoWhy space suits? Just pressurize the cabin so everybody can breathe. As for Gs, just make sure they're pointed toward the back of the seats and you won't need G suits.
- mikeytown2 10y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soyuz_11 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soyuz_11
- dreamcompiler 10y agoDidn't know about that one. Thanks for the link. Still, passenger jets are pressurized today and they rarely lose pressure. The technology is much more reliable now.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 10y agoIIRC pressure loss incidents are common, but not newsworthy because nothing really bad happens. The air pressure is still high enough to allow people to breathe, so you just need to supply oxygen-enriched air while the plane descends to 10000 feet. With suborbital flights, neither breathing nor descending more quickly would be an option.
- astdb 10y agoThe challenge facing Boom Aero is making it economically viable, which was Concorde's weak point.
- cknight 10y agoI think this lesson has been learned. After making losses for a while, British Airways did the research and found that people who were willing to pay for the Concorde's pricier tickets were actually willing to pay substantially more. After BA upped the ticket prices and the wealthy customers just kept paying, the service quickly became profitable for them, and remained so until the crash. For any new entrant to this market, it will need to remain an expensive niche.
- dingaling 10y agoConcorde made money for British Airways in every year it flew. Originally, however, they had to return 80% of any operating profit to the UK Government in exchange for a 'Condorde Subsidy' After BA had been privatised they bought themselves out of that agreement, ending the subsidy but pocketing the profit directly. They then proceeded to operate the fleet for another 20 years. So, in a British context, on an operating basis Concorde absolutely was economically viable. On a program basis, considering all the development costs, it was not; but then again the Boeing 787 program is > $30 billion in deficit right now and is unlikely to ever clear that.
- pmyteh 10y agoYeah; on privatisation they were transferred the airframes as a 'fully depreciated asset'. I'm full of admiration for Concorde as a technical achievement, but it's certainly easier to make a profit if you don't have to pay for your aircraft or initial stock of spares, let alone the development costs of the plane...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- api_or_ipa 10y agoSurprised nobodies posted 'The Submarine', one of PGs many excellent essays[0]. tl;dr: PR is a big submarine, always hiding beneath the surface. [0] http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- nether 10y agoIsn't everything PR?
- Ericson2314 10y agoI feel like increase in inequality between the 1970s and now alone could be enough to make a new Concoard succeed. Once the powerful are hooked there will be no going back.
- omegaworks 10y agoI was thinking along the same lines - what changes in society have occurred since then that would make any one person need to expend this much fuel to get from point a to point b marginally quicker? You'd think with advancements in telecommunications - the internet, etc - there'd be even less reason to need to be physically present in a place.
- ghaff 10y agoPeople are social. There's still lots of reasons why people want to meet with each other in person.
- ghaff 10y agoThe thing is that First/Business class has also been upgraded considerably as well. As has in-flight options like WiFi. And there are, for example, Business-class only BA flights between City airport in London and New York. Even among executives/investment bankers/international lawyers, there really isn't that much demand to go back and forth from the US East Coast to Western Europe in a day which was a big pitch from the Concorde. A faster plane starts to look more interesting Trans-Pacific but that's a whole other set of tech challenges. (It's greater than the Concorde's range.)
- janwillemb 10y agoMaybe I'm a bit pessimistic, but these 'might' headlines are never followed up by the real thing. It helps me to read these headlines a bit different: might = won't. In casu: Supersonic passenger jets won't make a comeback
- bamurphymac1 10y agoJanwillembs Law of Headlines
- _ph_ 10y agoThe Concorde was an incredible achievement considering the time it was built and a very beautiful airplane. It was very fuel inefficient, both because at the time of construction the oil crisis had not happened yet, and the limitations of jet engines back then. However, modern cheap air travel is mostly possible because modern jet engines are so much more efficient than their ancestors from the Concorde times. So it is very unfortunate, that the Concorde was built but that it did not trigger any iterations of the concept, just picking up all the advances in jet engine and body material construction.
- trhway 10y ago> It was very fuel inefficient my understanding is that Concorde engines are among the most efficient built to date - they had something like 70:1 compress ratio. It is juts the nature of high speed flying that you have to burn much more fuel. >modern jet engines are so much more efficient because of high-by-pass. Wouldn't work for supersonic. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thrust_specific_fuel_consumption#Significance_of_SFC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thrust_specific_fuel_consumpti... : "For example, Concorde cruised at Mach 2.05 with its engines giving an SFC of 1.195 lb/(lbf·h) (see below); this is equivalent to an SFC of 0.51 lb/(lbf·h) for an aircraft flying at Mach 0.85, which would be better than even modern engines; the Olympus 593 was the world's most efficient jet engine.[2][3] However, Concorde ultimately has a heavier airframe and, due to being supersonic, is less aerodynamically efficient, i.e., the lift to drag ratio is far lower. In general the total fuel burn of a complete aircraft is of far more importance to the customer."
- WalterBright 10y agoI don't remember the exact figure, but the last episode of "Aviation Disasters" was on the Concorde, and mentioned that it burned a major amount of fuel just getting to the runway, and because the delta wing was very inefficient at low speeds, burned another big chunk of fuel just getting off the the ground.
- cyberferret 10y ago
- Animats 10y agoWe've been here before. There was Aereon[1] They announced they were building a $120 million supersonic bizjet back in 2015. It was going to cost $80 million in 2007. Their web site hasn't been updated in more than a year. It's not impossible, but the market is small. The total number of known private jets in the world above $100m is about 10. There's one guy with a private Airbus 380, and a few Boeing Business Jets, including Trump's. Boeing has about 12 more Business Jets on order, but most of those are 737-based. [1] http://www.aerionsupersonic.com http://www.aerionsupersonic.com
- the_duke 10y agoWhile no new press releases or anything similar might not mean much, even the job postings are from November 2015, so yeah, Aerion seems quite dead. I thought they might not just dwindle away because they announced a cooperation with Airbus, but alas, getting enough funding probably is impossible if it's not pushed by a big corp like Airbus/Boeing and governments.
- Cyph0n 10y agoI'm pretty sure that there are more large private aircraft in the Middle East alone. They might be reported as government property to avoid scrutiny though.
- DodgyEggplant 10y agoWhat about climate change [1], and using less fossil fuels? We need the opposite - less first class, less business class seats, less private jets, to maximise the people who can travel per the same quantity of fuel. A typical passengers aircraft burns ~ 48 tons (!) of fuel to cross the Atlantic [2]. Part of the refugees issue happens exactly because of the warming and drought [3] [1]http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/climate-change-game-over-global-warming-climate-sensitivity-seven-degrees-a7407881.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/climate-change-gam... [2]https://www.quora.com/How-much-fuel-do-airplanes-flying-across-the-Atlantic-use https://www.quora.com/How-much-fuel-do-airplanes-flying-acro... [3]http://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/is-a-lack-of-water-to-blame-for-the-conflict-in-syria-72513729/ http://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/is-a-lack-of-water-...
- delhanty 10y ago+1 for this! I'd like to see a moratorium on space tourism too. That's unlikely to be a popular view on Hacker News though, and it's got zero chance of happening anyway.
- kobeya 10y agoWhat's the point of living then?
- cloakandswagger 10y agoI propose all human beings be allocated a 10x10 meter concrete apartment (15x15 if living with a partner, and 20x20 if you are permitted to have children). Furthermore, everyone will be given a standard monthly food ration consisting of rice, dry beans and powdered milk. Each resident can own up to 3 "luxury" items selected from a standard catalog. Each resident is permitted to travel no more than 150 miles from their residence each month, and personal cars are banned. Imagine how quickly we could heal the environment if everyone could agree to these common sense restrictions!
- joshwcomeau 10y agoI refuse to read an article that forces me to whitelist the site in my adblocker. Not because I'm anti-ad, but because their ad code is likely an invasion of privacy. I don't mind paywalls, but _this_ is egregious to me. Fuck the LA Times.
- grzm 10y agoThen don't. If you want to express why, feel free to do so, but please don't rant about it.
- joshwcomeau 10y agoAnd the difference between "expressing why" and "ranting" is..? This is a comment system. I had a comment.
- rayvd 10y agoAdd the following in uBlock Origin under "My Filters": @@||latimes.com^$generichide ||tribdss.com^ latimes.com##[id^=google_ads_iframe] latimes.com##[id^=trb_ad] latimes.com##.trb_gptAd Enjoy.
- joshwcomeau 10y agoThanks!
- Mandrew 10y agoExcellent. Thank you!
- Pxtl 10y agoConsidering the need to lower our carbon footprint and the massive amount of fuel spent in subsonic air travel, this seems wrongish.
- dmix 10y agoI was just watching a documentary on the 2000 Concorde crash in France the other day. It had some really good history and technical breakdown of how it worked. Apparently it was an unusually safe aircraft with no accidents for 30yrs until this incident. I won't ruin it but what caused it is also interesting from an engineering perspective. https://youtu.be/nKu_IoJ65gw https://youtu.be/nKu_IoJ65gw
- 0max 10y agoIs NASA co-operating with JAXA on this project? They've been working on a similar project for over a decade and last I heard were doing small scale tests.
- drallison 10y agoIs individual travel time so important that we should spend our limited environmental capital and build supersonic passenger jets? The Concorde was cool and sexy and destructive. Today's passenger jets, much improved over past aircraft, are still destructive and damaging. * http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/11/average-us-family-destroys-football-fields-worth-arctic-sea-ice-every-30-years http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/11/average-us-family-des... *https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_aviation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_aviati...