5 ms·
Actually, the article suggests that the firms pulled out of the market, and that their actions amplified the crash. Without high frequency traders, the market
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
Actually, the article suggests that the firms pulled out of the market, and that their actions amplified the crash.
Without high frequency traders, the market became far less liquid. This was considered a bad thing by almost all involved. It's almost as if high frequency traders are actually providing a valuable service for the rest of the world!
Also, HFT is not very vulnerable to "black swan" events. HFT doesn't usually use leverage, there are very few counterparties, no leverage, and almost no contagion.
- milkshakes 17y ago>Without high frequency traders, the market became far less liquid. I totally agree. >This was considered a bad thing by almost all involved. What I'm trying to propose is that the regulators involved in overseeing markets are becoming more and more out of touch with the techniques being used to improve their efficiency. What's important for long term economic health does not align with what is important for short term market efficiency. And as a result of this, the long term economic policy cannot keep up with the increasing degree to which short term regulation can affect markets. Yet long term economic health has an impact on other metrics of "utility" beyond itself, and we're in trouble if the power of the people in charge of making the rules can't address the needs of the people who depend on them. In other words, our regulators actions are predicated on the assumption that we knew how to improve the efficiency of the equity market. Lately, the influence they have on the markets has been increasing, but the amount of oversight they have been subjected to is decreasing. The skills that are relevant to getting politician into office are diverging from the skills and attention that are required to selecting these regulator in the first place. The politicians wind up screwing the people who both elected and depend on them. -- Let's consider the current, using arbitrage to improve the market's liquidity case, as an example. The most effective arbitrage techniques are made possible in part by simultaneously exploiting developments in computer science theory with those financial theory, and combining our improved ability to process this newly discovered information with our improved ability to implement our improved knowledge. In other words, in this case our increasingly sophisticated understanding of finance and computer science is what allowed us to more efficiently implement and test our hypotheses in the first place. Previously we used CDO's to improve our ability to assess risk. We did this because we assumed that assessing risk was important to the efficiency of the markets. However, CDOs were made possible by developments in financial theory and implementation, as well as statistics, and the politicians in charge of influencing our dependance on ability to improve this sophistication were out of touch with the long term effects that their decisions have.
- grandalf 17y agoWhy are CDOs bad? Why are crashes bad? I think the point that you may be missing is that there will always be booms, busts, panics, euphorias, etc. Those are byproducts of human psychology. The real problem is when people blindly expect the market to always be stable, to always increase in price, etc. Most of the people who lost money in the recent financial crisis were people who couldn't afford to lose on the bets they made or who had essentially let it all ride without understanding that sometimes share prices go down too.
- tome 17y agoBut (ironically in this context) when bets are available, there will always be people making bets they can't afford to lose. People blindly expecting the market to always be stable is a by product of human psychology!
- grandalf 17y agoI don't necessarily think it's irony. I don't think gambling is bad either. The stock market is still way better odds than the casino.
- skybrian 17y agoYep, that's the standard answer. But (a) why does the average investor care about short term liquidity? Mutual funds only let you sell once a day and most people are perfectly happy with that. And (b) what good is liquidity that disappears when you need it most? It's a self-serving argument at best. I sometimes wonder why the whole thing couldn't be replaced with a giant daily auction.
- skorgu 17y agoMutual funds (along with pension funds and other large institutional investors) move tens of billions of dollars into and out of various positions regularly. Speeding and simplifying those transactions reduces opportunity and transaction costs and (theoretically) benefits all holders of the fund.
- skybrian 17y agoAgain, that's the standard answer, but it's frequently repeated and never proven. I don't see it as anything more than conventional wisdom.
- grandalf 17y agoKeep in mind that we're talking about prices here. What is a stock price? If I put in an order to sell one share of GOOG for $1, would you start to believe that the market price of GOOG was $1 per share? A market price is only as valid as the degree of consensus. Increased liquidity means that there is a high degree of consensus about the current price. This means that one can feel additional confidence that one is getting a fair price. The main concept to think about here is an order book. Think about the psychology behind orders that are a ways away from the best price (both bid and ask). Those parties are willing to transact, but at a premium. In other words, they prefer to hold unless a sweet enough offer is made. Thus, for a very large order one has to pay that premium.
- artsrc 17y agoMost of the funds in the company I work at make position decisions once a day. Some only trade once a week. Liquidity intraday really adds nothing. The investors get a daily price, and they have to notify us they day before.
- gjm11 17y agoIt's almost as if high frequency traders are actually providing a valuable service for the rest of the world! There seem to be two obvious problems here. First, what actually happened was that at the point where that service would have been most valuable they stopped providing it. There seems to be a difference in value between idealized theoretical HFTs that provide liquidity at all times, and real HFTs that provide liquidity when there's plenty of it around anyway. Second, "they abruptly took X away and the results were bad, therefore X was providing something valuable" is an unsound argument -- e.g., coming off a drug cold turkey can be very bad even if the drug was doing you no good at all. It doesn't seem implausible that a sudden drop in liquidity during a market crash might be a very bad thing quite regardless of the optimal level of liquidity in general.
- ggruschow 17y agoThe way HFTs use leverage is opaque to most margin systems. Intraday margins are allowed to go way outside of overnight margins, and only positions are margined, not orders. That said, there's also traditional leverage used in many cases because you may have a fully hedged position across different exchanges that don't recognize each other's instruments in margin calculation. For instance, you can be long Jan 11 Brent Crude Oil on CME and be short just as much on ICE. The risk is practically zero, so firms borrow as much money as they can to put on as much position as they can. If you've got more margin than others in these sorts of trades, you win huge when everyone else is backed up to the wall.